SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(Online)(J&K) 971

HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR
Sanjeev Kumar, Mohd Yousuf Wani, JJ
Mudasir Bashir – Appellant
Versus
High Court of J and K – Respondent
WP(C) No. 251/2026 | CM No. 635/2026



Important Points

Seniority is determined by the date of first appointment. A candidate appointed from a waiting list cannot claim seniority prior to their actual appointment date, even if they possess higher merit than those appointed earlier from the final select list.

Subject

Service Law - Seniority

Act Referred

Jammu and Kashmir Public Service Commission (Conduct of Examinations) Rules, 2005: R.51-A
Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1956: R.24(1), R.24(1)(b)
Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services (Judicial) Recruitment Rules, 1967: R.39, R.42

Headnote

(A) Seniority - Date of Appointment - Seniority of a person in a service, class, category, or grade is determined by the date of first substantive appointment or appointment on probation against a clear vacancy. (Para 16, 17)

(B) Waiting List - Seniority - A candidate appointed against a vacancy arising from the non-joining of a selected candidate cannot claim seniority from a date anterior to their actual appointment, regardless of higher merit in the selection process. (Para 15, 18, 24)

(C) Inter-se Seniority - Simultaneous Appointment - The rule determining seniority based on merit in competitive examinations applies only to candidates appointed simultaneously. (Para 19, 21)

Issues: Whether a candidate appointed from a waiting list can claim seniority based on merit over candidates appointed from the final select list who were appointed earlier.

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • administrative law
    • service law
  • practice and procedure

Advocates:
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Shariq Reyaz Jan, Humaira Sajad
For the Respondents: Syed Faisal Qadri, Mir Mohsin Abbas, Farhat Riyaz

Table of Contents

1. A candidate appointed against a vacancy caused by a non-joining selected candidate claims seniority over previous selectees based on higher initial merit in the recruitment selection process. (Para 01 , 03 , 04 , 06 , 08 , 09 )

2. The petitioner asserts seniority based on superior merit in the selection process, while respondents maintain that seniority is determined solely by the actual date of substantive appointment. (Para 10 , 11 )

3. The court found that seniority is governed by the date of first substantive appointment according to statutory rules, and that the proviso regarding simultaneous appointments does not apply. (Para 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 )

4. Seniority is determined by the date of first substantive appointment on a clear vacancy; appointment through a waiting list is distinct from the initial simultaneous selection of candidates. (Para 16 , 17 , 21 , 24 )

5. The petition seeking re-determination of seniority is dismissed as the petitioner's date of appointment cannot be preponed to the date of selection. (Para 24 , 25 )

6. Does a candidate appointed from a waiting list acquire seniority from the date of the initial select list?

No. Seniority must be determined by the date of first substantive appointment against a clear vacancy. A candidate appointed to a vacancy arising after the initial appointment cycle cannot claim a retrospective date of seniority. (Para 16 , 17 , 18 , 24 )

7. Is the merit-based criterion for seniority applicable to candidates appointed at different times?

No. The proviso for assigning seniority based on merit during a competitive examination applies only to candidates appointed simultaneously to the service. It does not govern inter se seniority between candidates appointed on different dates. (Para 19 , 20 , 21 )

ORDER

12.11.2026 Sanjeev Kumar ‘J’:

01. The petitioner is a Civil Judge (Junior Division) and is aggrieved by the rejection of his representation dated 16th of February, 2024, seeking fixation of seniority in the cadre of Civil Judge (Junior Division) as per the merit obtained by him in the selection process. The petitioner also seeks a writ of mandamus commanding respondents 1 and 2 to redraw the seniority list and place him over and above respondents 6 to 23 (private respondents).

02. Before we advert to the grounds of challenge pleaded and urged in the petition, we deem it appropriate to give a brief factual background leading to the filing of this petition.

03. Vide Advertisement Notification No. PSC/Exam/2018/39 dated 30.05.2018, the Jammu and Kashmir Public Service Commission (PSC) invited applications for filling up 42 posts of Civil Judge (Junior Division) in the Department of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs. Out of the said 42 notified posts, 24 posts were earmarked for the open merit / general category, whereas the remaining 18 posts were reserved for various reserved categories.

04. The petitioner, along with other eligible candidates, participated in the said examination as a general category candidate and, upon culmination of the selection process, figured at serial number 24 in the order of merit in the result declared by the PSC on 22nd of August, 2019. The merit of the petitioner was tied with that of one Ms. Uzma Amin, who was the last candidate selected under the general category. The petitioner was not selected and offered appointment on the ground that the tie between him and Ms. Uzma Amin was broken by applying Rule 51-A of the Jammu and Kashmir Public Service Commission (Conduct of Examinations) Rules, 2005 (the Rules of 2005), and on account of the petitioner having secured lesser points in the viva-voce as compared to the said Uzma Amin.

05. Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner filed SWP No. 3898 of 2019 before this Court challenging, inter alia, the vires of Rule 51-A of the Rules of 2005, as well as the consequential action of the PSC in giving precedence to Ms. Uzma Amin over the petitioner.

06. During the pendency of the aforesaid writ petition, one Nikita Mahajan, a general category candidate figuring at serial number 14 of the select list prepared vide Government Order dated 20th of November, 2019, opted not to join the service, resulting in a vacancy of Civil Judge (Junior Division) in the open merit category becoming available to be filled up by the candidate ranking at serial number 1 in the waiting list.

07. In view of the aforesaid development, SWP No. 3898 of 2019 was disposed of by this Court vide order dated 18th of February, 2021, directing the Department of Law to write a formal communication to the PSC within a period of two weeks for forwarding the name of the petitioner, who was next in order of merit, with its recommendations to appoint him against the post that had fallen vacant due to the non- joining of Nikita Mahajan. A further direction was issued to the Public Service Commission to arrange the medical test of the petitioner as envisaged under the recruitment rules and, if found fit, to make recommendations to the Department of Law for his appointment.

08. In compliance with the directions passed by this Court, the selection of the petitioner was ultimately approved by the Government vide Government Order No. 3474-JK(LD) of 2021 dated 20th of May, 2021. This was followed by his order of temporary appointment as Civil Judge (Junior Division) in terms of Government Order No. 4768-JK(LD) of 2021 dated 11th of October, 2021. The petitioner was thus appointed.

09. He, however, raised a grievance in terms of his representation dated 16th of February, 2024, addressed to the Registrar General of this Court, claiming seniority on the basis of the merit obtained by him in the PSC selection and seeking to be placed over and above the private respondents, who were selected in differ

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top