1. Retired government employee challenges the bank's recovery of a loan debt from his pension account after he stood as a guarantor for a defaulting borrower. (Para 01 , 02 , 03 , 04 )
2026 Supreme(Online)(J&K) 972
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Moksha Khajuria Kazmi, J
Nazir Ahmad Kuchay – Appellant
Versus
Jammu and Kashmir Bank Limited – Respondent
FAO No. 10/2020
Important Points
Subject
Civil - Banking Law
Headnote
(B) Contract of Guarantee - Liability of Guarantor - While a guarantor's liability is generally co-extensive with the borrower, such liability cannot be enforced through coercive recovery from a pension account. (Para 11, 14)
Issues: Whether the respondent bank is justified in recovering loan amounts from the pension account of a retired government employee who stood as a guarantor.
Legal Category Hierarchy
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Aamir Latoo
For the Respondents: Rabinder Singh
Table of Contents
2. Appellant argued pension funds are protected from coercive recovery, while the respondent bank contended that a guarantor shares joint and several liability with the principal borrower. (Para 07 , 08 , 09 )
3. Pension benefits are welfare measures intended to prevent destitution for retired employees and are insulated from coercive recovery measures practiced by creditors for third-party debts. (Para 13 , 14 )
4. A bank cannot recover a defaulted loan from the pension account of a retired government employee acting as a guarantor, as pension funds are protected by law. (Para 13 , 14 )
5. The impugned order is set aside, and the bank is restrained from recovering the loan debt from the appellant's pension bank account. (Para 16 , 17 , 18 )
6. Are pension benefits of a retired government employee liable for attachment to recover a loan debt for which the pensioner was a guarantor?
No, pension benefits are protected from coercive recovery measures. They are intended as a welfare measure to ensure the sustenance of a retired employee and their family, preventing them from falling into vagrancy or destitution. (Para 13 , 14 )
7. Can a court grant an interim injunction preventing a bank from deducting loan repayments from a retired employee's pension account?
Yes, where the recovery mechanism involves coercive deduction from protected pension funds, the court may restrain the bank from further recovery as the pension is insulated from such measures, irrespective of the guarantor's liability. (Para 13 , 16 )
JUDGMENT
01. The appellant, a retired police personnel has approached this Court with the appeal in hand to assail the order dated 02.11.2020, for short referred to as “impugned order”, passed in file No. 52/M, by the learned 3rd Additional District Judge, Srinagar, for short the “trial Court”, whereby the application for grant of interim relief of the appellant has been dismissed.
FACTUAL MATRIX
02. The appellant stood as a guarantor to respondent No. 4, in seeking financial assistance from respondent No. 2. The said respondent failed to repay the requisite installments constraining the respondent No. 2, to deduct the same from the Bank Account of the appellant, who had, by then, retired from the active Government service and was managing his livelihood on the pensionary benefits.
03. Upon the appellant gain knowledge about such financial deductions, he approached the respondent No. 2, and apprised him about the factum of his superannuation and his dependence on the pensionary amount. The said request was entertained by respondent No. 2, and appellant was assured that no further amount would be deducted from his pensionary Bank Account. However, the promise turned out to be a mere eye wash, as the respondent No. 2, continued to deduct amount from the pensionary Bank Account of the appellant.
04. The appellant thereafter was constrained to file a civil suit before the trial Court for recovery of money and injunction. The said suit was accompanied by an application for interim injunction.
05. The learned trial Court considered the matter and passed the impugned order after hearing learned counsel for the parties, refusing the grant of interim relief.
06. Aggrieved of the impugned order, the appellant has filed the instant appeal seeking setting aside of the impugned order as also a restraint upon respondent No. 2, from recovering the loan amount credited to respondent No. 4, from the pension Bank Account number of the appellant bearing No. 0134040600000184.
SUBMISSONS OF LEANRED COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES.
07. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the respondent No. 2, is not justified in law to affect any recoveries from the Bank Account of a retired Government employee, the same being only source of sustenance for him and his family.
08. Learned counsel for the appellant in support of his submissions referred to and relied upon the Judgment of Supreme Court delivered in case titled “ Radhey Sham Gupta Vs. Punjab National Bank ” AIR 2009 SC 930 and Judgments of this Court delivered in cases titled Farooq Ahmad Khan Vs. Mehbooba Khan , bearing CRM(M) No. 210/2020 decided on 11.05.2022 and J&K Bank Limited and Anr. Vs. Chander Udey Singh, bearing CM(M) No. 156/2022, decided on 01.08.2025 at Jammu Wing. The learned counsel has also referred to the Judgment of High Court Orissa at Cuttack delivered in case titled Bharat Chandra Mallick Vs. Branch Manager State Bank of India.
09. On the contrary, the learned counsel for the respondent Bank submits that the appellant as a guarantor to an individual, who secure financial assistance is liable along with the borrower to repay the loan amount under the principle of joint and several liability recognized in contract law and Banking practice. Learned counsel for the respondent Bank further submits that respondents have not done any illegality that may warrant judicial interference as rightly declined by the trial Court. Learned counsel for the respondents referred to and relied upon the Judgment of Supreme Court delivered in case titled Union of India Vs. Jyoti Chit Fund and Finance , reported as AIR 1976 SC 1163.
ANALYSIS
10. Heard learned counsel for the parties, considered the submissions made and perused the material made available, particularly the impugned order.
11. It would be appropriate to reproduce the operative portion of the impugned order in the first instance.
“ 27. Once people enter into legal and solemn engagements or agreements with each other or with the ins