1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 13^TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2021

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P.S. DINESH KUMAR

WRIT PETITION No. 26452 OF 2018

C/W

WRIT PETITION No. 26453 OF 2018

WRIT PETITION No. 30865 OF 2018

WRIT PETITION No. 30866 OF 2018 (GM-AC)

IN W.P. 26452/2018

BETWEEN :

T PRAGATHI

AGED ABOUT 3 YEARS

D/O LATE M THIYAGARAJAN

SINCE MINOR REPRESENTED BY HER

NATURAL GUARDIAN C ANURADHA

FLAT # 102, LANDMARK APARTMENTS

89, PT RAJAN SALAI , KK NAGAR

CHENNAI-600 078

…PETITIONER

(BY SHRI.M.VINAYA KEERTHY, ADVOCATE)

AND :

1.

SHIPRA TAYAL

ADULT BY AGE

W/O ALOK TAYAL

BLOCK-N, N-5, PURVA PANORAMA

KALENA AGRAHARA

BANNERGHATTA ROAD

BENGALURU-560 076

(OWNER OF REVA CAR BEARING

REGN NO.KA-05/MN-9571)

2

2.

IFFCO - TOKYO GENERAL INSURANCE CO.LTD.

REGD OFFICE AT IFFCO SADAN

C-1 DISTT CENTRE, SAKET

NEW DELHI-110 017

AND BRANCH OFFICE AT NO.2

I FLOOR, SNR ARCADE

AYYAPPA TEMPLE ROAD

JALAHALLI CROSS, PEENYA

BENGALURU-560 057

(POLICY NO.1-2G7EA08 FOR THE

PERIOD 02.12.2013 TO 01.12.2014)

3.

DEEPANKAR RAO

AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS

S/O R N SOMASHEKAR

4.

VIPIN RAVINDRANATH

5.

PRAVEEN SHETTY

6.

GIRISH MOHAN

7.

RASHMI PAI

8.

SUDEEP CHANDAN

SL.NO.3-8 ARE RESIDING AT

F-BLOCK, NO.803, PURVA

PANORAMA APAPRTMENT

KALENA AGRAHARA

BANNERGHATTA ROAD

BENGALOORU-560 076

…RESPONDENTS

(BY SHRI.E.I.SANMATHI, ADVOCATE FOR R2;

SHRI. E.CHRISTOPHER, ADVOCATE FOR

SHRI.J.JUDSON SAMUEL, ADVOCATE FOR R3 TO R8)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED

16.03.2018 PASSED BY THE HON'BLE MOTOR VEHICLES ACCIDENT CLAIMS

TRIBUNAL, BENGLAURU ALLOWING

THE IA FILED BY THE SECOND

RESPONDENT IN MVC 279/15 (ANNEXURE-F).

3

IN W.P. 26453/2018

BETWEEN :

1.

R.CHANDRSEKARAN

AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS

S/O LATE RAMAMURTHY

F-2, SUBAKEERTHANA

APARTMENTS, I CROSS

KRISHAN ANGAR

PAMMAL, CHENNAI-600 075

2.

C.GAYATHRI

AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS

W/O J BALAJI

12/307, THIRU VI KA STREET

LAKSHMINAGAR

POZHICHALUR

CHENNAI-600 074

3.

C.ANURADHA

AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS

W/O LATE M THIYAGARAJAN

FLAT 102, LANDMARK APARTMENTS

89, PT RAJAN SALAI, KK NAGAR

CHENNAI-600 078

…PETITIONERS

(BY SHRI.M.VINAYA KEERTHY, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1.

SHIPRA TAYAL

W/O ALOK TAYAL

BLOCK-N, N-5

PURVA PANORAMA

KALENA AGRAHARA

BANNERGHATTA ROAD

BENGALURU-560076

(OWNER OF REVA CAR BEARING

REGN NO.KA-05/MN-9571)

2.

IFFCO-TOKYO GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD

REGD OFFICE AT IFFCO SADAN

C-1 DISTT, CENTRE, SAKET

NEW DELHI-110017

AND BRANCH OFFICE AT NO.2

I FLOOR, SNR ARCADE

4

AYYAPPA TEMPLE ROAD

JALAHALLI CROSS, PEENYA

BENGALURU-560057

(POLICY NO.1-2G7EA08 FOR THE

PERIOD 02.12.2013 TO 01.12.2014)

3.

DEEPANKAR RAO

AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS

S/O R N SOMASHEKAR

4.

VIPIN RAVINDRANATH

5.

PRAVEEN SHETTY

6.

GIRISH MOHAN

7.

RASHMI PAI

8.

SUDEEP CHANDAN

SL.NOS. 3-8 ARE R/A F-BLOCK

NO.803,PURVA PANORAMA

APARTMENT, KALENA AGRAHARA

BANNERGHATTA ROAD

BENGALURU-560 076

…RESPONDENTS

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED

16.03.2018 PASSED BY THE HONBLE MOTOR VEHICLES ACCIDENT CLAIMS

TRIBUNAL, BENGALURU ALLOWING THE IA FILED BY RESPONDENT NO.2 IN

MVC NO.87/15 VIDE ANNEXURE-F AND ETC.,

IN W.P. NO.30865/2018

BETWEEN:

1.

MR. DEEPANKAR RAO

S/O R N SOMASHEKAR

AGED 49 YEARS

R/A S BLOCK, N-803

PURVA PANORAMA APARTMENTS

KALENA AGRAHARA

BANNERGHATTA ROAD

BANGALORE-560 083

5

2.

MR. VIPIN RAVINDRANATH

S/O RAVINDRANATH NAIR

AGED 43 YEARS

R/A A-506

PURVA PANORAMA APARTMENTS

KALENA AGRAHARA

BANNERGHATTA ROAD

BANGALORE-560 083

3.

MR. PRAVEEN SHETTY

S/O RAVINDRANATH SHETTY K

AGED 42 YEARS

R/A MALPE-4113

SOBHA FOREST VIEW

OFF KANAKAPURA ROAD

BANGALORE-560 062

4.

MR. GIRISH MOHAN

S/O LATE J C MOHAN

AGED 44 YEARS

R/A G-604

PURVA PANORAMA APARTMENTS

KALE