KARNATAKA HIGH COURT
A. V. Srinivasa Reddy, J.
Ramakrishna Theatre Ltd. v. M/s. General Investments and Commercial Corpn. Ltd
C. R. P. No. 2721 of 2002
1. This revision is filed under S. 115 C. P. C. against the order dated 16-3-2002 passed on I. A. No. 2 in O. S. No. 118/98 on the file of the Addl. Civil Judge (Sr. Dn.), Udupi dismissing I. A. No.2 filed by the petitioner herein under S. 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 requesting the Court to refer the dispute between the parties to arbitration and stay the suit proceedings.
2. The plaintiff - respondent filed the suit for delivery of possession of the plaint property on the ground of expiry of the lease period. The plaintiff respondent contended in the suit that immediately on the expiry of the lease period, the plaintiff got issued a notice calling upon the petitioner to hand over possession of the property. The petitioner defendant sent reply notice on 20-3-1998 refusing to hand over possession of the premises. The respondent plaintiff decided to invoke the provisions of arbitration clause contained in the lease deed and as per the amended provision of Arbitration Act, 1996 notified the appellant by registered letter dated 9-4-1998 expressing that the matter should be referred to an Arbitrator for determination. The defendant took up a stand that the plaintiff has no right to refer the dispute to the arbitration as per clause 4(a) of the registered lease deed and further stated that the present issue is not an arbitrable issue and further stated that Clause 11(2) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 will not apply. It is under these circumstances the plaintiff respondent has filed the present suit. In the suit the petitioner filed I. A. No. 2 under S. 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 for an order to refer the dispute between the parties to arbitration and stay the proceedings in the suit till finality of the arbitration award. The Court dismissed the I. A. No.2. Being aggrieved, the present revision has been filed by the petitioner defendant.
3. I have heard the learned counsel on both sides.
4. Certain undisputed facts of the case are :
The petitioner took possession of the premises under a registered lease deed. The lease period under the lease agreement has come to an end. The plaintiff respondent issued notice calling upon the petitioner tenant to hand over possession of the premises. The same was refused by the petitioner. The further notice issued by the plaintiff respondent to subject the dispute to an Arbitrator for determination also has been refused by the petitioner - defendant on the ground that the matter is not arbitrable. It is thereafter that the suit has been filed by the respondent - plaintiff.
5. In the light of these undisputed facts, the question that arises for my consideration is whether the court below was right in rejecting I. A. 2 filed by the petitioner - defendant for referring the dispute to an Arbitrator for adjudication.
6. The registered lease deed is dated 3-9-1973. The recitals contained in 4(a) of the said lease deed read as follows :
"Every dispute, difference or question which may at any time arise between the parties hereto or any person claiming under them, touching or arising out or in respect of this deed or the subject matter thereof shall be referred to arbitration and the provisions of the Indian Arbitration Act, 1940 will be applicable thereto."
The handing over of possession by the petitioner - defendant to the respondent - plaintiff after the expiry of the lease period is certainly a matter touching or arising out or in respect of the registered lease deed. As the handing over of possession of the premises is subject matter of the lease agreement and, therefore, any dispute relating to the handing over of the possession would certainly have to be determined in an arbitration proceedings in terms of clause 4(a) of the agreement entered into between the parties. Despite the dispute being fully covered by clause 4(a) of the agreement, the petitioner - defendant played truant and refused to submit to arbitration proceedings and this fact that
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.