THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
M.G.S. Kamal, J
Shubhakar R – Appellant
Versus
State of Karnataka – Respondent
CRL.A No. 499 of 2026
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. applicability of section 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) prima facie in anti-caste law. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6) |
| 2. interpretation of 'public view' and 'intent to humiliate' under sc/st act. (Para 7 , 8 , 9 , 10) |
| 3. effect of pre-existing civil litigation on the nature of 'public' presence. (Para 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16) |
| 4. discretionary bail power when prima facie elements of offense are absent. (Para 17 , 18 , 19) |
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 14(A)2) OF SC/ST (POA) ACT READ WITH SECTION 482 OF BNSS, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 06.03.2026 PASSED IN CRL.MISC.NO.1500/2026 BY THE LXX ADDL. CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE AND SPECIAL JUDGGE (CCH-71) AT BENGALURU AND TO ENLARGE THE APPELLANTS ON ANTICIPATORY BAIL IN CR.NO.37/2026 REGISTERED BY SUBRAMANYAPURA POLICE STATION FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTIONS 3(1)(r), 3(1)(s) OF SC/ST (POA) ACT AND SECTION 351(2), 352 AND 115(2) OF BNS.
THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
ORAL JUDGMENT
This appeal is filed by the accused in Crime No.37/2026 registered before the Subramanyapura Police Station for the offences punishable under Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Amendment Act, 2015 (‘SC & ST (POA) Act’ for short) and under Sections 351(2), 352 and 115(2) of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023 being aggrieved by the order dated 06.03.2026 passed in Crl.Misc.No.1500/2026 on the file of the LXX Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge and Special Judge, Bengaluru, by which the petition filed by the appellants herein under Section 482 of BNSS has been rejected.
2. A complaint dated 06.02.2026 came to be filed by one Gopal alleging commission of aforesaid offences by the appellants herein, pursuant to which case in Crime No.37/2026 is registered. The contents of the complaint as found in the First Information Report reads as under:
“ΐėỳгу:06/02/2026
џẀΠĆ’,
ďỳĒỳΑĄỳΠхಳù,
ẃ—њłќђŁј—џĘ’―Ρ†ύďỳĒ’,
Ě’гхಳüџ—їхџ.
згѕ,
Ć’―†Ęỳψнгѓгĕ’Ġ’†ζќ—Βėỳхјļ,46ẀẂџ್,
Ģỳẃќė’їг.130,1ė’†еяĴџĥ’ķ,ẀяĴџĘỳಳŁ,еĞ’†ẄΣŅ,
йѓķџẄΣŅ,ẃ—њłќђŁј—џегĉ’,
Ě’гхಳüџ—їхџ-560061.Ą’ґẃ:ΘΧė’ύ,ċỳΎ:ě’―†Τ,
Fª ÉÄïï L.r. gopalam586@gmail.com, ªÉƨ ÉÊ¯ï £ÀA§gï: 9448182586.
ĜỳїŁĞ’†...
ΤẂў: їїĻї—Ļ еяĴх·IJ, еĢỳшŁ ẁњĹхΣгѕ Ě’‡ѕ—, ¸ÁªÀðd¤PÀ ẃĸಳѕΡń їїĻ ċỳΎ
Βгѕė’ĜỳΉ,Ą’‡хΣгѕẄĠ’ńĜỳΉџ—Ẁẁ—ћуφќѓ—ķеẀџќхˆģ’ †φû
џẀџΤџ—ѕĺĄỳї―ї—уłќĄ’‡Ć’―ಳŅґ—Ą’―†Π.
и Λ†ґĨгя ΤẂўĄ’Ĩ ẃгњгΑΧѕгē’ Ć’―†Ęỳψ жѕ ėỳї— јΠΥẂIJ ċỳΎ ě’―†Τ
ъėỳгхĄ’Ĩ ĥ’†Πџ—ē’ķ†ė’. ẃ—Ĝỳџ— 60ªÀµ ÀðUÀ½AzÀ еĞ’†ẄΣŅ ќ—фŁ џĥ’ķ, уĚỳľಳќŀ ĕ’†Ẁĥỳĸїѕ
ẄΎķџ, ẀяĴџĘỳಳŁ Ćỳłќ, ąỳēỳ їгњφ 57/1/45 џΡń їќŀ кΠї ģỳĠ’ зѕĹ ċỳхẀї—Ļ
ẃĸġỳгѓΠẃĠỳ¯ их ж ċỳх ąỳΡ зѕ—Ĺ, кΠї йјЏ†хĄ’Ĩ Ħỳх― їќŀ ċỳΎў ћẀїĄ’Ĩ
ĄỳΝĹΠΧ, Θ.Θ.нг.Γ еΡń ąỳē’ ĜỳΉΧѕ—Ĺ,¸ ÀPÁðgÀѕ еΑ†їѕΡńџ—ѓķĕ’. еґńĕ’† зΎķ†ĉ’Ć’ ẃѕΠ
ċỳхĄ’Ĩ ẃгњгΑΧѕгē’ Ą’ґІгѕ— ˆΉĆ’†Ήхಳù ẃѕΠ ċỳхẀї—Ļ ґјĎỳΝẃ—Ẁ йĕ’ņẁΐгѕ
їуΡ ĕỳфĠỳΎхಳї—Ļ ẃ‗ΦIJΧĄ’―гΉџ—Ẁ њĆ’Ī ĜỳΨΎ њгΐѕ—Ĺ, жѕĹΠгѕ ėỳẀ÷ кΠї
ќ—фгяџ—хಳù ĥ’†ΠĄ’―гя— ẃѕΠ ċỳхẀ÷¸ ÀPÁðj ẃņѓ—ķ нгњ¨ÉÆÃqïð еї—Ļ Ħỳˆĕ’ĹẀ÷. и
ΐї ΐėỳгу: 06/02/2026 џгѕ— Ě’ΣĆ’Ī 11-20 хгĎ’ў ẃќўѕΡń їќŀ кΠї ĢỳΧхġỳѕ
ẁ—ћуφ ќѓ—ķ еẀџ ќх ˆģ’ †φ џẀџ— ẃѕΠ ċỳхѕΡń ĦỳˆѕĹ û ¨ÉÆÃqïð еї—Ļ ˆѓ—ķ
Ħỳу—ΎķѕĹ ΤẂў ΎΣѕ— ėỳї— ќѓ—ķ кΠї ќ—фгяџ—хġỳѕ Υł† ĥ’―†ќģ’†фφ Θ. Υł†
ẃ—Ğ’†ϋнο:-Υł†шгѕłјļнг,Υł†Ąỳгѓу—Ĝỳφ,Υł†Ğỳъќѓ—ķзѓџџ—ĥ’†ΠĄ’―гя—ẃѕΠ
ẃņΎķї њΣ Ħ’―†¯ Ą’†ಳĠỳ¯ ẁ—ћуφ ќѓ—ķ еẀџ ќх ˆģ’ †φ оĄỳ оˆ û оĠỳ ẀĐỳĴ їїĻ
ќхė’† зĕ’Ġỳń ΒΒĻгѕĠ’† зĤ’IJĠỳń ж¯ѕ—Ĺ, ĚỳĞ’―† зẀѓ—ķ ΒїĆ’ зĕ’† QüÀÄ ċỳΎĆ’ Ẅ—·IJѕĹẀė’†
нгѕ— ¸ÁªÀðd¤PÀªÁV їїĻ ċỳΎ Βгѕė’ ĜỳΉ, їїĻ ќхė’†, Βгѕ— ċỳΧķ жΝѓ— нгѕ—
їїĻĄỳґφј·IJўї—ĻΨΉѕ—Ą’―гя—їїĻуĘỳಳĄ’ĨĦ’―Đ’ѕ—ẄĠ’ńĜỳΉѕџ—.жẃќўѕΡńėỳї—
уΎķїΡń ĦỳˆĄ’―гΉѕĹ ˜їĻѕ ĉ’‡ο еї—Ļ ˆѓ—ķ Ħỳˆџ—ēỳķĞ’. еẂIJџΡń еΡńѕĹ їќŀ кΠї
ќ—фгяџ—хಳù њгѕ— ъхಳ ΘΉΧѕџ—. їгѓџ еẀџ—хಳù зѕ— їїĻ жΧķ, зė’―Ļгѕ— ẃґ и
ċỳхѕ ΤẂўĄ’Ĩ њгѕĞ’ Β†ї— и кΠїΡń Ħ’†Ć’ цẀї їĐ’ẃ—Ύķ†ĝỳ ė’―†я—ē’ķ†ė’гѕ— Ą’―Ġ’
Ě’ѕΠĄ’Ħỳˆѕџ—.їгѓџėỳї—ẄΎķџѕĢ’ψģ’ †φжẃļē’łĆ’Ħ’―†¯ û ˜ˆē’ʼnјĐ’ѕ—Ą’―гΉџ—ē’ķ†ė’.
жѕĹΠгѕруĨΡхċỳΎĆ’ĥ’†Πѕẁ—ћуφ&еẀџќхˆģ’ †φû зњľџ—¸ÁªÀðd¤PÀªÁV
їїĻ ċỳΎў Βгѕė’ ĜỳΉѕĹґńĕ’† еĢỳαў ẁњĹхΣгѕ Ě’‡ѕ—, Ą’‡хΣгѕ ẄĠ’ń ĜỳΉ, Ą’―Ġ’
Ě’ѕΠĄ’ Ħỳˆџ—Ẁ њĆ’Ī ẁ—ћуφ & ˆģ’ †φû
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.