Back
2022 Supreme(Online)(KER) 36269
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
A. Muhamed Mustaque, Shoba Annamma Eapen, JJ
STATE OF KERALA – Appellant
Versus
SREEVALSAN – Respondent
LA.App. 713 2014
SMT.N.SUDHADEVI, GOVERNMENT PLEADER, SRI.K.A.JALEEL, ADDL. ADVOCATE GENERAL
The judgment emphasized that post-notification sales serve as critical evidence for determining market value in land acquisition compensation, ensuring fair remuneration based on present-day values.
Headnote:
Land Acquisition - Kerala Land Acquisition Act, 1961 - Sections 23(1A), 54 - The court analyzed the classification of acquired lands for compensation and the adequacy of amounts awarded, concluding adjustments based on local market conditions and the nature of the properties.
Fact of the Case:
Land Acquisition Appeals were filed under the Kerala Land Acquisition Act, 1961, challenging enhanced compensation for lands acquired for a road improvement project. The State contested the amounts awarded, while claimants sought higher compensation due to property values in a developed area.
Finding of the Court:
The court upheld the Reference Court's classification of all acquired properties as garden lands despite State arguments. It found the compensation awarded was insufficient and adjusted the rates based on the properties' value and market conditions.
Issues: Whether the Reference Court correctly classified the acquired lands as garden lands and whether the compensation awarded was adequate given the market value of the properties.
Ratio Decidendi: The court reiterated that the context of land acquisition values should consider the best comparative evidence available post-notification for determining market values, supporting the Reference Court's findings.
Final Decision: The appeals by the claimants are allowed, enhancing compensation to Rs.4,50,000/- per cent with statutory benefits, while the State's appeals are partly allowed, confirming some Reference Court judgments.
J U D G M E N T
Shoba Annamma Eapen J :
These Land Acquisition Appeals are filed under Section 54 of the Kerala Land Acquisition Act,1961 in respect of lands acquired for the purpose of widening of Kovoor-Vellimadukunnu Road, which is a project under Kozhikode City Road Improvement Project as per Notification :-2-:
dated 08.07.2010. Challenging the enhanced compensation awarded in Land Acquisition Reference cases and dissatisfied with the compensation awarded, the State as well the claimants are in appeal. LAA Nos. 63/2018, 275/2015, 300/2015, 321/2015, 345/2015, 365/2015, 367/2015, 384/2015, 433/2015, 434/2015, 435/2015, 438/2015, 439/2015, 446/2015, 447/2015, 453/2015, 462/2015, 13/2017, 28/2017, 513/2015, 51/2017, 68/2017, 105/2017, 198/2017, 278/2017, 285/2017, 793/2013, 179/2014, 180/2014, 200/2014, 210/2014, 217/2014, 111/2016, 245/2014, 250/2014, 279/2014, 294/2014, 300/2014, 301/2014, 310/2014, 194/2016, 319/2014, 196/2016, 206/2016, 209/2016, 335/2014, 338/2014, 343/2014, 356/2014, 357/2014, 234/2016, 260/2016, 266/2016, 267/2016, 275/2016, 286/2016, 287/2016, 291/2016, 292/2016, 293/2016, 421/2014, 429/2014, 454/2014, 455/2014, 459/2014, 461/2014, 462/2014, 463/2014, 468/2014, 472/2014, 362/2016, 365/2016, 370/2016, 371/2016, 497/2014, 374/2016, 504/2014, 380/2016, 381/2016, 382/2016, 507/2014, 383/2016, 509/2014, 386/2016, 515/2014, 521/2014, 526/2014, 534/2014, 412/2016, 415/2016, 416/2016, 417/2016, 420/2016, 423/2016, 424/2016, 579/2014, :-3-:
586/2014, 591/2014, 600/2014, 602/2014, 613/2014, 703/2014, 713/2014, 721/2014, 722/2014, 724/2014, 729/2014, 739/2014, 747/2014, 792/2014, 794/2014, 796/2014, 797/2014, 799/2014, 800/2014, 809/2014, 810/2014, 812/2014, 813/2014, 814/2014, 815/2014, 816/2014, 817/2014, 819/2014, 820/2014, 821/2014, 822/2014, 823/2014, 824/2014, 828/2014, 831/2014, 832/2014, 833/2014, 835/2014, 842/2014, 843/2014, 844/2014, 846/2014, 847/2014, 848/2014, 849/2014, 850/2014, 851/2014, 856/2014, 857/2014, 859/2014, 871/2014, 893/2014, 898/2014, 913/2014, 261/2016 are filed by the State challenging the enhanced compensation, Cross Objection Nos.121/2014 in LAA No.335/2014, 148/2022 in LAA No.454/2014 and 17/2022 in LAA No.429/2014 are filed by the claimants and LAA Nos..692/2013, 693/2013, 694/2013, 701/203, 702/2013, 344/2016, 397/2017 and 398/2017 are filed by the claimants, dissatisfied with the compensation awarded by the Reference Court.
2. We have heard Smt.N.Sudhadevi, learned Special Government Pleader (Land Acquisition) appearing for the State of Kerala, Sri.K.A.Salil Narayanan, the learned Counsel appearing for the :-4-:
appellants in L.A.A.Nos.701/2013,702/2013,692/2013,693/2013 and 694/2013, Sri.R.Bindu (Sasthamangalam), the learned counsel appearing for the appellants in L.A.A.No.344/2016, Sri.Vinod Singh Cherian, the learned counsel appearing for the appellants in L.A.A.Nos.397/2017 and 398/2017, Sri.A.V.M.Salahudin, the learned counsel appearing for the cross objector in C.O.No.121/2014 in L.A.A.No.335/2014 and Sri.V.N.Ramesan Nambisan, the learned counsel appearing for the cross objectors in C.O.No.148/2022 in L.A.A.No.454/2014 and C.O.17/2022 in L.A.A.No.429/2014.
3. LAA No.815 of 2014 is treated as the main case. These cases have come up in batches totaling to 162 appeals including cross objections. The properties involved in all these appeals arise out of the same notification and are adjacent properties, acquired for the very same purpose. Hence we have heard the appeals together and are being disposed of by this common judgment. LAA No.815/2014 (LAR No.82/2011) is treated as the leading case and the evidence in this case consists of oral testimony of AW1, Exts. A1 to A3, Ext.R1 to R6 and Ext.X1 and X2.
:-5-:
4. Properties in Sy.Nos.19/9,19/11,19/13,19/15,19/17,19/19, 19/21,20/5,20/7,20/9,20/12,23/15,23/16,23/18,23/22,23/26,122/4,122/5, 213/4,213/7,214/4,214/14,159/4,194/2,226/5,230/8,230/10,230/11,232/ 5,234/6,234/8,234/9,234/11, 234/12, 234/13, 234/14, 236/9, 328/11,328/13,328/17,
