2024 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 77158
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
VISWANATHAN P – Appellant
Versus
STATE OF KERALA – Respondent
Bail Appl. 3268/2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE C.S. SUDHA WEDNESDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF JULY 2024 / 12TH ASHADHA, 1946 RSA NO. 244 OF 2024 AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 05.09.2023 IN AS NO.19 OF 2022 OF SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT, KOCHI ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 18.06.2022 IN OS NO.501 OF 2015 OF MUNSIFF COURT, KOCHI.
APPELLANT(S)/APPELLANT/1ST PLAINTIFF:
P. MAXIE JOHN, AGED 65 YEARS, S/O LATE P C JOHN, RESIDING IN C C NO. 1/1114, TR/1/1081,SKY VIEW, KUNNUMPURAM, FORT KOCHI, COCHIN, PIN – 682 001.
BY ADVS.
A.D.SHAJAN SINDHU SANTHALINGAM JESSY S.SALIM RESPONDENT(S)/RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS 1 TO 4 AND 2ND PLAINTIFF:
1 SANTA CRUZ BASILICA, FORT KOCHI, COCHIN, REP. BY THE VICAR, PIN – 682 001.
2 RT.REV. DR. JOSEPH KARIYIL, THE BISHOP OF COCHIN, BISHOP HOUSE, FORT KOCHI, COCHIN, PIN – 682 001.
3 THE VICAR, SANTA CRUZ BASILICA FORT KOCHI, COCHIN, PIN – 682 001.
4 THE VICAR GENERAL, BISHOP'S HOUSE, FORT KOCHI, COCHIN, PIN – 682 001.
5 SHEELA WILFRED, AGED 71 YEARS, W/O. LATE L.X. WILFRED (WILFRED XAVIER), LANTHAPARAMBIL HOUSE, H. NO. 1/1117TR/1/1225, KUNNUMPURAM, FORT KOCHI, COCHIN, PIN - 682001 THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 03.07.2024, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
C.S.SUDHA, J.
----------------------------------
R.S.A.No.244 of 2024 --------------------------------------------- Dated this the 03rd day of July 2024
J U D G M E N T
This second appeal under Section 100 read with Order XLII Rule 1 CPC filed by the first plaintiff/appellant is against the judgment and decree dated 05/09/2023 in A.S.No.19/2022 on the file of the Subordinate Judge's Court, Kochi, which appeal in turn is against the judgment and decree dated 18/06/2022 in O.S.No.501/2015 on the file of the Munsiff Court, Kochi. The parties and the documents will be referred to as described in O.S.No.501/2015.
2. The suit was for declaration and permanent prohibitory injunction. The plaintiffs are parishioners of Santa Cruz Cathedral Basilica, Fort Kochi (the Basilica). The first plaintiff is one of the sons of late P.C.John, who was buried on 26/05/1971 in the cemetery of the Basilica. The graveyard of late P.C.John was purchased by his widow Suzanna John from the vicar general as per order no.159/D/78 dated 27/09/1978. The graveyard of John was allotted as the family grave for the burial of the family members. Pursuant to the order dated 27/09/1978, an amount of Rs.750/- was paid as consideration and thereafter the graveyard was being possessed and maintained by the first plaintiff's family. When Suzanna John expired on 30/01/2000 she was also buried in the same grave. Wilfred Xavior, the second plaintiff's husband, who expired on 20/06/2012 was also buried in the same cemetery. Franscina Raymond, the grandmother of Wilfred Xavior, who expired on 19/01/1952, was also buried in the same cemetery. The graveyard of late Franscina Raymond was purchased by her daughter L.R.Mary on 17/07/1974 on payment of cost of ₹500/-, which was paid pursuant to Order no.90/D/74 dated 17/07/1974 of the then vicar general. The graveyard was purchased as a family grave for the future burials of the family. After the purchase, the dead bodies of all the family members were buried in the graveyard. Ever since the allotment/assignment of the said graveyard, the same was being possessed and maintained by the second plaintiff and her family members.
2.1. The allotment/assignment of the aforesaid graveyards are perpetual. However, a year before the filing of the suit, when the first plaintiff approached the parish priest seeking permission to repair the tomb belonging to the family members, permission was denied on the ground that 25 years had lapsed since the allotment and therefore the plaintiffs had no further right over the same. Plaintiffs apprehending demolition of the tomb of their ancestors, caused to issue a lawyer notice to defendants 2 to 4. However, the defendants never responded to the notice. The secon