2022 Supreme(Online)(KER) 36211
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
DOMINIC M.D – Appellant
Versus
STATE OF KERALA – Respondent
WP(C)/15879/2022
Important Points
Subject
Administrative Law - Education Law
Act Referred
Headnote
Management - School Transfer - Kerala Education Act, 1958 - Sections Involved: Relevant provisions dealt with management transfer and educational agency definitions. The court ruled the transfer was lawful under the Act based on previous judgments clarifying authority.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner, a parishioner, challenged a government order transferring management of a school from church control to the Diocese, alleging that it disregarded parish opposition, widespread parishioner discontent, and previous court rulings.
Finding of the Court:
The court found the government's transfer decision valid, emphasizing adherence to the Kerala Education Act and previous court findings that the Bishop holds managerial authority, thus dismissing the petitioner's claims.
Issues: Whether the government order transferring school management contravened the rights of parishioners and established legal precedents regarding school management authority.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that judicial review of administrative actions aims to prevent unlawful decisions, confirming that the legal framework establishes the Bishop's authority over school management, aligned with previous judgments.
Final Decision: The writ petition was dismissed.
ADV.JOHN JOSEPH VETTIKAD
JUDGMENT
The challenge in this writ petition is directed against the order passed by the Government allowing the transfer of management of the St. Sebastian's High School, Punnackal to the Corporate Educational Agency of the Diocese of Thamarassery. It appears that the DEO allowed the transfer which was interfered with by the DGE. The Government by the impugned order restored the order passed by the DEO.
2. The facts in brief:- a) The petitioner is a Parishioner belonging to the St.Sebastian Church, Vilikkamthodu. He contends that the St.Sebastian’s High School (‘School’ for short) is owned by the St.Sebastian Church and the Vicar of the Church is the Manager of the School. The decisions regarding the church and the school are taken only after securing the approval of the Parishioners in the General Body Meeting. The school is situated in a property purchased by the Trustee of the Church for and on behalf of the Church as per Document No.108 of 1979 of S.R.O Mukkom. Relying on Ext.P1 series Encumbrance Certificates, it is stated that the property was purchased by one Thondamkulath Philip for and on behalf of the Church as its Trustee and using the funds contributed by the members of the Parish. According to the petitioner, a committee styled as a ‘Work Committee’ was formed among the parishioners for the purpose of administration. Relying on Ext.P3 constitution of the Educational Agency, it is contended that the Managing Committee of the school consists of 8 members. The constitution of the school cannot be changed or amended without the approval of the General Body.
b) The petitioner asserts that the respondents 3 to 8 with malafide intent made attempts to take over the ownership and control of the school for which purpose a proposal was placed before the Edavaka Committee to transfer the school to the Diocese of Thamarassery. A General Body meeting was convened by the parishioners and they unanimously decided not to hand over the management of the school as proposed by the Diocese. It is contended that ignoring the objections of the parishioners, the 7th respondent who was acting as the Manager of the school submitted an application for transfer before the 3rd respondent along with a fresh proposal. Relying on Ext.P6, it is contended that a General Body in which hundreds of parishioners participated took a decision not to proceed with the matter and decided to withdraw the earlier application. However, ignoring Exhibit P6, the 3rd respondent initiated steps to grant transfer of Management.
c) Being aggrieved, a writ petition was filed before this Court as W.P.(C) No.4765 of 2013 and this Court by an interim order interdicted the proceedings for transfer of management of the school. The writ petition was later disposed of directing the 3rd respondent to take a decision on the application submitted for the change of Manager of the school.
d) During the pendency of the matter before the concerned respondent, the 8th respondent was won over by the respondents and based on his statement that the disputes had been settled and Ext.P10 agreement had been entered into, the DEO issued Ext.P11 order dated 6.1.2017 effecting the transfer of management of the school to the Corporate Education Agency of the Diocese of Thamarasserry.
e) In the said circumstances, the petitioner herein preferred Ext.P12 representation and later approached this Court and filed W.P.(C) No.2964 of 2017. This Court by Ext.P13 judgment directed the 2nd respondent to look into the entire matter and to correct the mistakes, if any, after considering the entire aspects. The 2nd respondent in compliance of the directions issued by this Court passed Ext.P14 order holding the transfer of Management of the school was illegal and against the provisions of the Kerala Education Act and Rules, 1958 (KER). The order passed by the 3rd respondent was accordingly set aside.
f) Ext.P14 order was challenged by the 5th respondent before this Court by filing W.P.(C) No.38665 of 2017.