2025 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 47765
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
Devan Ramachandran, M.B. SNEHALATHA, JJ
HARSHAD – Appellant
Versus
JASEELA – Respondent
MAT.APPEAL NO. 587 OF 2020 | MAT.APPEAL NO. 729 OF 2020 | OP NO.275 OF2018 | OP NO.258 OF2018
Important Points
Subject
Family Law - Matrimonial Disputes
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Cruelty - Definition of cruelty assessed case-by-case, taking into account human conduct in the context of matrimonial duties and obligations. (Paras 34-36)
Facts of the case:
The wife alleged misappropriation of 210 sovereigns of gold ornaments and sought divorce on grounds of cruelty, including physical and mental abuse, demanding dowry, and preventing her from exercising her rights over property.
Findings of Court:
Evidence presented by the wife remained uncontradicted, with pensionable documentation supporting her claims about the marriage and gifts.
Issues: Determination of the grounds for divorce, the credibility of claims regarding misappropriation, and the basis for maintenance orders were central to proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi: The court affirmed that cruelty and misappropriation of family assets justified the divorce; clear evidence of misappropriation distinguished in judgment. The principle requiring rigorous evaluation of claims of cruelty in matrimonial contexts was highlighted.
Result: Appeals allowed in part; maintenance and return of gold ornaments upheld. Dismissal of one of the appeals against the third respondent.
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Sri.P.JAYARAM, Sri.A.HAROON RASHEED
For the Respondents: Sri.P.T.SHEEJISH
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. petitioner's claims of misappropriation of gold and maintenance needed for divorce ruling. (Para 4 , 5 , 10 , 18) |
| 2. evidence of financial aid reinforces claims of gold misappropriation by respondents. (Para 22 , 26) |
| 3. determination of cruelty under case specifics; evidence supporting claims essential for divorce. (Para 30 , 31 , 34) |
JUDGMENT
M.B.Snehalatha, J
Mat.A No.729/2020 is preferred by the husband and his parents, challenging the judgment and decree against them in O.P.No.258/2018 of Family Court, Tirur, filed by the wife and children seeking past maintenance, return of gold ornaments and money.
2. Mat.A No.587/2020 is preferred by the husband assailing the judgment and decree of divorce granted by the Family Court, Tirur in O.P.No.275/2018 filed by the wife.
3. The parties shall be referred to by their rank in the Original Petition.
4. The wife filed O.P.No.258/2018 contending that her marriage with the 1strespondent was solemnized on 11.3.2001 as per the Muslim religious rites and ceremonies; that in the said wedlock, two children were born to them. Respondents 2 and 3 are the parents of the 1st respondent. 1st petitioner’s father is conducting jewellery business. At the time of marriage, she was gifted with 300 sovereigns of gold ornaments and a car by her parents. One week prior to the marriage, her father entrusted an amount of ₹2 lakhs with the 2ndrespondent and subsequent to the marriage, another sum of ₹2 lakhs was also handed over to 2nd respondent. Soon after the marriage, petitioner entrusted her entire gold ornaments with the 3rdrespondent, except the ornaments used for her regular wear and respondents 1 to 3 kept the said gold ornaments in the bank locker of the 2nd respondent. After two months of marriage, 1st respondent/husband took 60 sovereigns of her gold ornaments and pledged the same to raise money for his business purposes. In 2004, respondents 1 and 2 sold 115 sovereigns of her gold ornaments for the purpose of starting a 'rent a car' business for the 1strespondent. When the said business also went into loss, 1st respondent went abroad. In 2010, the 1st respondent again took 35 sovereigns of gold ornaments of the 1st petitioner for starting a business at Ras Al Khaimah. Thus, respondents misappropriated 210 sovereigns of gold ornaments of the 1st petitioner. In 2004, 1st respondent sold 12 sovereigns of gold ornaments of the child. Apart from the amount of ₹4 lakhs given at the time of marriage, 1st petitioner’s father gave an amount of ₹12,89,000/- to the 1strespondent on various occasions for discharging his debts, for arranging job visa and for taking UAE driving licence. Respondents are liable to return 210 sovereigns of gold ornaments misappropriated by them and cash of ₹16,89,000/- received by them. 1strespondent ill- treated the petitioner and subjected her to cruelty and due to the acts of cruelty meted out by her, she had to leave the company of the 1strespondent. 1strespondent deserted her from 3.6.2016 onwards and has not provided any maintenance to the petitioners. She also sought past maintenance to the tune of ₹2,30,000/- for her and ₹2,30,000/- for the minor children for the period from3.6.2016 till 3.5.2018 at the rate of ₹15,000/- per month.
5. The wife filed O.P.No.275/2018 seeking dissolution of marriage on the ground of cruelty. Her case is that respondent subjected her to physical and mental cruelty; that he brutally manhandled her, demanding dowry and demanding to transfer the ownership of the house in his name, which was constructed by her father in her name. Her further case is that respondent is a sexual pervert, who is interested in homosexuality and when she questioned the same, while they were residing abroad, he manhandled her and when her life was in danger, she informed the matter to her father, who in turn sent flight tickets for her and her children, and thus she escaped from there. She sought dissolution of marriage under Section 2 (viii) (a) and (d)