2017 Supreme(Online)(KER) 52735
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
A.M.SHAFFIQUE, K.RAMAKRISHNAN, JJ
SREEJITH SREEDHARAN – Appellant
Versus
SHERRY SUDHEER – Respondent
Mat.Appeal 4/2016
Important Points
Subject
Family Law - Divorce
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Evidence in matrimonial matters - Direct evidence may not be available; courts must assess the credibility of each party's version to determine the more probable account. (Para 9)
Facts of the case:
The marriage was solemnized on 26/12/2011, but the couple lived together for only 25 days before the respondent left for employment abroad. The petitioner alleged mental and physical torture, dowry demands, and desertion.
Findings of Court:
The Family Court found sufficient evidence of mental cruelty and granted a decree for divorce, ordering the return of gold ornaments and financial amounts.
Issues: The main issue was whether the evidence supported a decree for divorce on the grounds of cruelty.
Ratio Decidendi: The court upheld the Family Court's finding of mental cruelty based on the respondent's behavior and demands for money, concluding that the petitioner's claims were credible.
Result: Appeal dismissed.
SRI.LATHEESH SEBASTIAN, SRI.M.R.ANANDAKUTTAN, SMT.M.A.ZOHRA, SRI.MAHESH ANANDAKUTTAN, SMT.S.SOUMYA ISSAC
J U D G M E N T
Shaffique, J. This appeal is filed against the judgment dated 31/7/2015 in OP No.1729/2014. The respondent in the original petition is the appellant. The original petition is filed by the respondent herein/wife inter alia contending that the marriage between the parties was solemnized on 26/12/2011 in terms with the Hindu custom and religious rites. They resided together only for 25 days and thereafter the respondent went abroad in connection with his employment. Petitioner alleges that immediately after marriage, she was subjected to physical as well as mental torture by the respondent and his near relatives by demanding more dowry. It is alleged that the respondent could not find a job in UK and as per his request, substantial amounts were sent by her parents to meet his expenses. Further, she remitted ` 50,000/- to M/s. Chirayinkil Service Co-operative Society towards the loan availed by the respondent. It is alleged that respondent had deserted her w.e.f. 21/1/2012. Hence, she sought for dissolution of marriage.
2. In the written statement filed by the respondent/appellant, he denied the allegation of cruelty. According to him, he did not find a job as expected in UK and the petitioner had started to abuse him. She was also under the impression that she could accompany him to UK and find a proper job. He had filed an application for restitution of conjugal rights which is pending consideration. He denied the fact that he had deserted her. The above case was jointly tried with another case OP No.1728/2014. Common evidence was adduced. Petitioner was examined as PW1 and respondent as CPW1. Petitioner relied upon Exts.A1 to A8 documents and respondent relied upon Exts.R1 to R6. The Family Court after considering the matter in detail directed dissolution of the marriage and also directed return of gold ornaments as well as the amount. Appeal is filed only against the judgment in OP No.1729/14 relating to decree for dissolution of marriage.
3. Learned counsel for the respondent/appellant submits that the only case alleged was desertion which is not proved in the case. Appellant had gone abroad for employment which itself does not amount to desertion. The Family Court also found so. However, the Family Court proceeded to consider the case as to whether there is any cruelty and without any material on record, it was found that unnecessary allegations were made against the petitioner which itself amounts to mental cruelty and therefore she is eligible for a decree under Section 13 (1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act.
4. On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/respondent contended that a clear case of cruelty is made out. The very fact that several allegations are raised against the petitioner itself would prove the fact of cruelty. Further, demanding dowry and substantial amounts during the marital relationship itself can create a case of mental cruelty and therefore, there is justification on the part of the Family Court to have come to such a finding.
5. The only question to be considered in this appeal is whether this Court can sustain a decree for divorce on the ground of cruelty. In the original petition, the pleadings would show that they got married on 26/12/2011 and they resided at the matrimonial home for 25 days and on the 26 th day morning, the respondent left to United Kingdom. It is contended that during preliminary discussion, respondent and his relatives made the petitioner and her parents to believe that there is a bright prospectus of getting placement in any one of the leading establishments in the United Kingdom in which event the respondent will be getting a family visa and the couple can reside at UK. The petitioner also will get a decent job and they can settle down at UK. It is contended in para 11 that the attitude of the respondent was indifferent, strange and tainted with physical as well as mental cruelty. It is alleged that he had demonstrated disinterest towards her no