SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2011 Supreme(Online)(KER) 7984

HIGH COURT OF KERALA
K.T.SANKARAN, J
INFANT JESUS PARISH CHURCH THALORE – Appellant
Versus
INFANT JESUS MONASTERY – Respondent
OP (CIVIL) 1198/2011



Important Points

The plaintiffs can restrict obstruction of the cemetery's use but cannot prevent the defendants' entry pending a determination of title.

Subject

Civil - Property Dispute

Headnote

Injunction - Cemetery Use - No specific acts listed - The court focused on the rights of the plaintiffs to use the cemetery, weighing possession against title and dedication, ultimately affirming the lower courts' denial of a broader injunction while allowing limited use.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiffs sought a declaration and permanent injunction against the defendants to prevent obstruction of the cemetery used for parishioners' burial and religious functions, asserting a dedication of the cemetery by the defendants to the parish.

Finding of the Court:

The trial court granted temporary injunction against obstruction but not entry, which was upheld by the appellate court, establishing that the issue of title and dedication requires further evidence without infringing the defendants' access to the cemetery.

Issues: Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to an injunction restraining the defendants from entering the cemetery and obstructing its use for burial and religious functions.

Ratio Decidendi: The courts held that the title and dedication questions would be determined at the final trial, while the plaintiffs showed a prima facie right to use the cemetery, justifying limited interference against obstruction but not total exclusion of the defendants.

Final Decision: The Original Petition is dismissed; the trial court is directed to dispose of the suit expeditiously.

JUDGMENT

The petitioners are the plaintiffs in O.S.No.1592 of 2010 on the file of the Court of the Munsiff of Irinjalakuda. The suit was filed for a declaration that the defendants have no right to obstruct the use of the plaint schedule cemetery by the first plaintiff for the burial of the dead bodies of the parishioners and for conducting religious functions therein. There is also a prayer for permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the defendants from trespassing upon the plaint schedule cemetery or obstructing the use of the cemetery by the plaintiffs.

2. The plaintiffs filed I.A.No.4412 of 2010 for a temporary injunction restraining the defendants from trespassing upon the plaint schedule cemetery or obstructing the use of the cemetery by the plaintiffs for the burial of the dead bodies of the parishioners and for conducting religious functions till the disposal of the suit. The trial court granted temporary injunction restraining the defendants from obstructing the petitioners from using the plaint schedule cemetery for burial of the dead bodies and from causing any obstruction to religious functions to be conducted in the cemetery. However, the trial court did not grant the injunction as prayed for. Dissatisfied with the order passed by the trial court, the plaintiffs filed C.M.A.No.53 of 2010 on the file of the Court of the Principal Subordinate Judge of Irinjalakuda. The Appellate Court also took the view that the respondents/defendants cannot be injuncted from entering into the cemetery. The Appellate Court, accordingly, dismissed the appeal. The concurrent decisions of the courts below are under challenge in this Original Petition filed by the plaintiffs, to the extent to which the courts below did not grant an injunction restraining the defendants from entering into the cemetery.

3. According to the plaintiffs, the cemetery was dedicated by the defendants to the Infant Jesus Parish, when the Parish was constituted taking portions from Ollur and Puthukad Parishes in the year 1977. The first defendant is Infant Jesus Monastery. As per an agreement entered into in the year 1976, it was decided to take portions from Ollur and Puthukad Parishes and to form Infant Jesus Parish, Thalore. As per the decree dated 7.1.1977 of the Bishop, the Parish was constituted. The first defendant Monastery had a chapel and it was designated as the Parish Church. There was no cemetery for the Parish. An extent of 15 cents was earmarked for cemetery. The land belonged to the first defendant. According to the plaintiffs, that land was dedicated by the defendants as a cemetery of the Parish. Accordingly, an application was made for licence to use the land as a cemetery in the year 1977. Licence was granted.

Cemetery was constructed and it is being used as such.

4. In the year 2009, the status of the Parish was changed.

The Parish Church was shifted to another place. The Monastery still remains there. According to the plaintiffs, the cemetery belongs to the Parish and therefore, the defendants have no right over the same. The defendants dispute the dedication. According to the defendants, the title to the property where the cemetery is functioning belongs to the defendants. However, the defendants have no objection in the land being used as the cemetery for burying the dead bodies of the parishioners. The contention of the defendants is that the plaintiffs are not entitled to an order of injunction restraining the defendants from entering into the cemetery and offering prayers.

5. The trial court considered the documentary evidence and held that the question of title and dedication of the plaint schedule property are matters to be decided on evidence at the stage of final disposal of the case. For considering the application for temporary injunction, the material point to be considered is possession. The trial court noticed the fact that the respondents have no objection to allow the petitioners to use the cemetery. The contention of the def

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top