2017 Supreme(Online)(KER) 23280
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
P.N.RAVINDRAN, Devan Ramachandran, JJ
DALIYA GOPINATH @ PREETHI – Appellant
Versus
STEAVE XAVIER – Respondent
MATRIMONIAL APPEAL 1336/2017
Important Points
Subject
Family Law - Jurisdiction of Family Courts
Act Referred
Headnote
Jurisdiction - Family Court - Family Courts Act, 1984 - Sections 7(1)(c) and 7(1)(d) - The court held that the absence of a marital relationship between the parties does not permit Family Court jurisdiction in property disputes, leading to a dismissal of the appeal.
Fact of the Case:
The appellant sought a declaration of property ownership against her brother-in-law in Family Court, but the court returned the petition, stating the respondent was not a party to the marriage, thus lacking jurisdiction.
Finding of the Court:
The court affirmed the lower court's decision, stating that the Family Court's jurisdiction is limited to matters strictly between married parties and not extended to property claims involving non-parties.
Issues: Whether the Family Court had jurisdiction to hear the case involving property claims between non-marital parties.
Ratio Decidendi: The Family Courts Act restricts jurisdiction to disputes strictly between married parties, and since the marriage was disputed, the Family Court lacked jurisdiction in this matter.
Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed due to lack of jurisdiction of the Family Court.
JUDGMENT
P.N.Ravindran, J.
This appeal arises from the order passed by the Family Court, Alappuzha on 8.11.2017 in O.P.No.11 of 2016. By the said order the Family Court returned O.P.No.11 of 2016 filed by the appellant against her brother-in-law on the ground that the respondent is not a party to the marriage and therefore, the Family Court has no jurisdiction. 2. The appellant had in O.P.No.11 of 2016 prayed for a declaration that she is the lawful owner of the petition schedule property as the legal heir of her husband who is incidentally is the brother of the respondent. Upon receipt of notice from the Family Court, the respondent entered appearance and filed a written statement denying and disputing the status of the petitioner. He denied the factum of marriage and claimed absolute right over the property scheduled to O.P.No.11 of 2016 through intestate succession. It was thereafter that the impugned order was passed returning the petition for proper presentation on the ground that the parties to the litigation are not parties to a marriage.
3. The very same question arose before a Division Bench of this MA No.1336/2017 2 court in Suprabha v. Sivaraman ( 2006 (1) KLT 712 ). Suprabha was married to one Santhosh, who later committed suicide. She had in the petition filed by her in the Family Court, Thiruvalla through her next friend claimed the sum of Rs.9,55,160/- which represents the value of gold ornaments, cash paid and other movables given at the time of her marriage with Santhosh. The respondents in the petition filed by her in the Family Court were the parents of Santhosh. The Family Court returned the petition stating that one of the parties to the marriage is no more and therefore, the petition is not maintinable before the Family Court. Suprabha challenged that order by filing F.A.O.No.6 of 2006 in this court. A Division Bench of this court held that when either the husband or the wife is not alive and the suit is filed against the parents of either of them, it cannot be said that it is a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage. It was held that in the context of section 7(c) of the Family Courts Act, 1984 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act' for short), the meaning of the words “parties to a marriage” cannot be given such a wide interpretation so as to include all those who are interested in the welfare of the couple or those who take part to the marriage ceremony. The Division Bench held that for the purpose of section 7(1)(c) of the Act, the suit or proceeding must be between the husband and the wife with respect to the property of the parties or either of them. However, inSuprabha (supra), the MA No.1336/2017 3 Division Bench set aside the order passed by the Family Court on the ground that sub-section (d) of section 7(1) of the Act would come into play. Section 7 (1)(d) of the Act stipulates that the suits and proceedings referred to in that sub-section include a suit or proceeding for an order of injunction in circumstances arising out of a marital relationship. It was held that a petition for return of gold and cash paid at the time of marriage will come within the scope of section 7(1) (d) of the Act, though one of the spouses is not alive at the time when the petition was filed.
4. In the case on hand, section 7(1)(d) of the Act has no application. The plaint schedule property did not jointly belong to the appellant and her husband. The very marriage itself is in dispute. In such circumstances, we are in agreement with the court below that the appellant should invoke the jurisdiction of the competent civil court seeking redressal of her grievances and that she cannot invoke the jurisdiction of the Family Court. The appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed.
(P.N. Ravindran, Judge)
(Devan Ramachandran, Judge)
kav/