SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2013 Supreme(Online)(KER) 37201

HIGH COURT OF KERALA
S.S.SATHEESACHANDRAN, J
M P PORUNCHU RETD K S R T C EMPLOYEE – Appellant
Versus
KARMALEETHA SABHA AND OTHERS – Respondent
FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDERS 82/2011



Important Points

For a suit under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, there must be a specific allegation of trust breach and a claim for reliefs specified therein; individual rights claims do not suffice.

Subject

Civil - Religious Trusts

Act Referred

Code of Civil Procedure : S.92

Headnote

CPC - Religious Trust - Code of Civil Procedure - Section 92 - The court upheld the District Judge's dismissal of the application for leave to institute a suit under Section 92, determining that the proposed suit did not align with the requirement of claiming a breach of trust or specify a relevant relief under the section.

Fact of the Case:

The appellants sought leave to institute a suit under Section 92 following the second respondent's unilateral decision to relocate a Church against an agreement made in 1976, claiming entitlement to religious services and obligations under that agreement.

Finding of the Court:

The court identified that the District Judge correctly concluded that there was no prima facie case for leave to institute the suit, concluding there was no evidence of a trust, dedicated or implied.

Issues: Whether the appellants were entitled to leave to institute a suit under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure regarding the purported breach of trust and their right to religious services.

Ratio Decidendi: The proposed suit did not seek any relief indicated under Section 92, as it focused on individual rights rather than trust-related issues required for such suits, thus justifying the denial of leave.

Final Decision: Appeal dismissed; leave to institute suit under Section 92 was denied.

JUDGMENT

The Order passed by the learned District Judge, Thrissur in O.P.No.304/2010 declining leave applied by appellants, two in number, to institute a suit under section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, for short the Code, is challenged in this appeal.

2. Appellants sought leave to institute a suit for declaration that the parishioners of Thalore Edavaka including them are entitled to continue the Church, cemetery, community hall, kappela etc situate in the plaint property for performing their religious services in accordance with the decision taken under an agreement dated 26.6.1976 with defendants 1 and F.A.O.82/2011 2

2, and the defendants are bound to perform their obligations under that agreement. They also sought for other reliefs including revocation of an order issued by the second respondent in violation of the agreement dated 26.6.1976, and mandatory injunction directing defendants to perform 'nithyakurbana and other services' to the parishioners in the Church situate in plaint property. Application was resisted by respondents, first respondent filing a counter affidavit separately and respondents 2 to 4 in common, both of them contending that appellants (petitioners) are not entitled to the permission sought for to institute the suit. Learned District Judge after hearing both sides dismissed the application holding that there was no material to show the existence of a trust by dedication or implication and also breach of such trust. Applicants who sought for leave failed to show any interest in the scheduled property and also make out a prima facie case for grant of leave, was the conclusion formed by the learned District Judge to F.A.O.82/2011 3 decline leave to institute the suit under section

92 of the Code.

3. I heard the counsel on both sides. Learned counsel for appellants adverting to the facts and circumstances covered by the case contended that the court below proceeded on the premise that there was no trust and in that view of the matter formed erroneous conclusion declining leave for instituting the suit. On the other hand, counsel for respondents contended that there is no merit in the challenge questioning the Order of the District Judge declining leave to appellants holding that they have not made out a prima facie case and also there was no trust dedicated or implied.

4. First respondent a congregation installed a monastry and later a Church in the plaint schedule property, and, it was dedicated in favour of Thalore Parish under Ext.A1 agreement dated 26.6.1976 entered into specifying the terms for functioning of the Parish and the second F.A.O.82/2011 4 defendant, Archbishop,issued a notification recognising the parish, according to applicants. Second respondent later unilaterally took a decision on 31.10.2009 to shift the Church to another place which is against the terms and conditions under the agreement dated 26.6.1976, is the case of applicants to impute breach of trust for reliefs seeking leave to institute the suit. Respondents in their objections contended that there was no trust but only extending of permission to use the premise in the plaint property for religious worship till a new church is constructed for parishioners. Further more decision of the second respondent, who is the Arch Bishop, over construction of Chapel, place of worship etc cannot be challenged by parishioners. Though submissions were made before me with reference to canon law by counsel for respondents drawing distinction between Catholic Church and other Christian churches contending that with respect to Catholic Church orders and directions F.A.O.82/2011 5 given by second respondent over to place of worship, recognition of parish, chapel etc are not open to challenge by parishioners, I find consideration of those questions to examine the propriety and correctness of the order declining leave to institute the suit is not warranted in the present appeal. Learned District Judge with reference to some decisions has taken pa

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top