2021 Supreme(Online)(MAD) 9890
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT DATED : 03.03.2021 CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.SATHISH KUMAR A.S.(MD)Nos.28 to 30, 42 to 46, 48, 50 to 57 and 98 of 2020 and C.M.P.(MD)Nos.1822, 1825 and 3375 of 2020 A.S.(MD)No.28 of 2020:-
M.Thavamani ...Appellant/Plaintiff Vs.
1.Amsath
2.The Revenue Divisional Officer, Lathams Bungalow Road, Ramanathapuram Town and District.
3.The Executive Engineer and Administrative Officer, Tamil Nadu Housing Unit, K.T.M.Building 1st Floor, Vandikaran Street, Ramanathapuram Town and District.
4.The District Collector, Sethupathi Nagar, Ramananathapuram District.
5.The Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Housing Board, 493, Annasalai, Nanthanam, Chennai-35. ...Respondents/Defendants PRAYER: This Appeal Suit is filed under Section 96 r/w Order 41 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, against the judgment and decree made in O.S.No.22 of 2017 dated 28.08.2019 on the file of the Principal District Court, Ramanathapuram.
For Appellant : Mr.A.S.Narasimhan for Mr.M.Thirunavukarasu For R1 : Mr.H.Lakshmi Shankar For R2 & R4 : Mr.J.Gunaseelan Muthiah Additional Government Pleader
COMMON JUDGMENT
Since the facts are identical, this Court is inclined to dispose of all the appeals by this common judgment.
2. These appeals have been filed as against the decree and judgment of the trial Court dismissing the suits filed claiming legal fees at the rate of 10% said to have been agreed by the litigants in a land acquisition proceedings.
3. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to herein, as per their rank before the trial Court.
4. The brief facts, leading to the filing of this Appeal Suit, are as follows:-
(i) The plaintiff is a practicing Lawyer. An extent of 470.28 cents in Survey Nos.56/4, 56/5 and 56/6 were acquired for the purpose of Tamil Nadu Housing Board on 03.04.19927 from the first defendant/land owners in all the suits. As the land owners did not know about the proceedings of the Land Acquisition, the plaintiff contacted them either directly or through letter and impressed upon them to proceed further. Accordingly, he was engaged by the defendants. The plaintiff has also prepared objections as against the acquisition proceedings. Despite his objections, only 16 references were made under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act (for the sake of brevity hereinafter referred to as 'the Act'). One such reference is relating to one Ansari, who is the first respondent in A.S.(MD)No.51 of
2020. The above reference was numbered as L.A.O.P.No.3 of 1999. (ii) The land owners have orally agreed to pay 10% fee of the enhanced compensation. Besides 5% of appeal expenses and also other 5% expenses for engaging Advocates. Accordingly, the first defendant in all the suits have agreed to pay the admitted amount and executed the document dated 12.09.2002 separately. The plaintiff has also taken steps to file writ petition before the High Court to complete the acquisition proceedings. Besides, he also proceeded further under Section 28(A) of the Act and ultimately, got the compensation to the parties at the rate of Rs.5,000/- per cent. After discharging his professional duty, the land owners /defendants have failed to act upon as per the document, dated 12.09.2002. Hence, the suits have been filed seeking fee and expenses with 11% interest and seeking permanent injunction as against the second and third respondents.
5. It is the contention of the land owners/first defendant that the plaintiff has not taken any steps to refer the matter under Section 18 of the Act and similarly, all the proceedings under Section 28 (A) of the Act were conducted by the land owners themselves. It is stated that the plaintiff was not engaged specifically to get enhanced compensation. Many lawyers have appeared in various land acquisition cases. The land owners/ defendants agreed to receive a sum of Rs.5,000/- per cent in a mediation conducted by the defendants 2 to 5, in respect of which the plaintiff herein has no role to play. In fact the plaintiff acted against his profession and delayed the compensation. In fact the plaintiff was demanding 20% of the compensation amount from the land owners/defendants as fee. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the suit.
6. Based on the above pleadings, the trial Court has framed the following issues in all the suits:-
O.S.No.35 of 2013:-
1. Whether the agreement dated 12.09.2002 said to have been executed between the plaintiff and the first defendant is true and binds on the first defendant?
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to permanent injunction?
3. Whether the plaintiff has barred under Section 28(A) of the Land Acquisition Act on behalf of the defendant?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to claim legal fees as
5. To what other reliefs?
O.S.No.17 of 2017:-
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to receive a sum of Rs.
22,960/- from the first defendant?
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to permanent injunction?
3. To what other reliefs?
O.S.No.18 of 2017:-
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to receive a sum of Rs.
26,005/- from the first defendant?
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to permanent i