2023 Supreme(Online)(MAD) 39449
MADRAS HIGH COURT
INTELLECT DESIGN ARENA LIMITED – Appellant
Versus
MINDGATE SOLUTIONS PVT.LTD., – Respondent
A 2688 2023
1
A.No.2688 of 2023
in C.S.(Comm.Div.)No.71 of 2022
S.SOUNTHAR, J.
The instant application has been filed by the applicant/plaintiff
seeking a direction to the Advocate Commissioner to take the representatives
of the applicant along with him to visit the premises of the respondent.
2. The prayer in the application is extracted below;
“20. In the above-mentioned circumstances, the Applicant humbly
prays that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to
1) Direct the Advocate Commissioner and the Expert to
a. To visit the premises of the Respondents at the
following locations along with technical expert of the
representatives of Applicant/Applicant and its counsels, break
open the locks if the premises are found locked, with the
assistance of Police authorities if necessary;
1. 14th Floor, Damji Shamji Business Galleria,
LBS Marg, Kanjurmarg (West),
Mumbai- 400 078,
Maharashtra, India.
2. Smartworks, Kochar Globe,
Plot No Sp 26,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2
Thiru-vi-ka- Industrial Estate,
Guindy, Chennai 600 032.
b. To inspect the Hard Disks of the computers,
compact discs and/or other storage/replicating media, with the
help of technical expert of the Applicant/Applicant.
c. To prepare reports, summaries, inventories of
the same.
d. To make mirror copies of the Respondent's
Hard Disks of the computers, compact discs and/or other
storage/replicating media, seal them immediately in the
presence of the Respondent's representatives and produce the
same before the Court, without tampering with them in any
manner.
e. To seek from the Respondent, their employees
and agents password particulars of any computer system, if
required, in order to enable him to carry out the execution of
the commission.
f. To visit any other premises within the vicinity of
the abovementioned addresses where such computer systems
are kept which could be carrying copies of the Respondent's
software which infringe upon the Applicant's copyright in the
artistic works, literary works and passing off their products
and business as those of Application by use of the said
trademarks.(emphasis added).
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
3
g. To take the assistance of the police, within
whose jurisdiction the Respondent's premises and are to be
visited, in order to carry out the aforesaid activities.
2. Pass such other orders which this Hon'ble Court may
deem it necessary and thus render justice.”
3. Earlier, the applicant herein filed an application in A.No.1600 of
2022 with the following prayer;
“A. To visit the premises of the Respondents at the
following locations along with technical expert of the
representatives of Plaintiff and its counsels, break open the
locks if the premises are found locked, with the assistance of
Police authorities if necessary;
1. 14th Floor, Damji Shamji Business Galleria,
LBS Marg, Kanjurmarg (West),
Mumbai- 400 078,
Maharashtra, India.
2. Smartworks, Kochar Globe,
Plot No Sp 26,
Thiru-vi-ka- Industrial Estate,
Guindy, Chennai 600 032.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
4
b. To inspect the Hard Disks of the computers,
compact discs and/or other storage/replicating media, with the
help of technical expert of the plainitff.
c. To prepare reports, summaries, inventories of
the same.
d. To make mirror copies of the Respondent's
Hard Disks of the computers, compact discs and/or other
storage/replicating media, seal them immediately in the
presence of the Respondent's representatives and produce the
same before the Court, without tampering with them in any
manner.
e. To seek from the Respondent, their employees
and agents password particulars of any computer system, if
required, in order to enable him to carry out the execution of
the commission.
f. To visit any other premises within the vicinity of
the abovementioned addresses where such c