2023 Supreme(Online)(MAD) 118
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT DATED : 11.09.2023 CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.KUMARAPPAN C.R.P.(MD)No.995 of 2019 S.Kishore Kumar ... Petitioner / Petitioner/Plaintiff Vs.
N.Sekar ... Respondent / Petitioner/2nd Defendant Prayer: This Civil Revision Petition is filed under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, against the fair order and executable order, in I.A.No.529 of 2018, in O.S.No.16 of 2013 on the file of the IVth Additional District Judge, Madurai, dated 06.12.2018.
For Petitioners : Mr.S.Manohar For Respondents : Mr.A.V.Arun
ORDER
The instant Civil Revision Petition has been filed against the order, in I.A.No.529 of 2018, in O.S.No.16 of 2013 on the file of the IVth Additional District Judge, Madurai, dated 06.12.2018.
2. The revision petitioner is the respondent / plaintiff and the respondent herein is the petitioner / second defendant before the Court below.
3. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to according to their litigative status before the Court below.
4. It appears that the plaintiff has filed the suit for the relief of specific performance and for delivery of possession in respect of the schedule mentioned property. The total consideration according to the pliant was Rs.79,70,000/-. In which, according to the plaintiff, Rs. 25,00,000/- has already been paid as a advance. It is the submission of the plaintiff that the suit was decreed on 31.07.2017.
5. However, the second defendant has filed an application under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C along with delay condonation application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, to condone the delay of 310 days in filing the connected applications, to set aside the exparte decree.
6. The learned counsel for the plaintiff would submit that when the decree has been passed, based upon the substantial evidence of the parties and has been allowed on merits, the very filing of the application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, is not maintainable. Therefore, contended that the order of the Court below in allowing the application is liable to be interfered with. The learned counsel for the plaintiff has also relied upon the latest judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in S.L.P.No.3543 of 2019 in a case of Y.P.Lele V. Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Ltd.
7. Per contra, the learned counsel for the second defendant would submit that even as per the judgment, dated 31.07.2017, this defendant was set exparte, therefore, would vehemently submit that the very application under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C, as against the defendant is maintainable. Therefore, the learned counsel would submit that, since there was a delay of 310 days in filing the application, to set aside the exparte decree, he moved an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
8. The learned counsel for the second defendant would further submit the second defendant has believed his brother, who is the first defendant. He would submit that since the first defendant engaged a counsel for this second defendant, has not properly intimated about the stage of the suit, and that the second defendant came to know about the exparte decree only when he received summons in I.A.No.302 of 2018, and that in the meanwhile, there was a delay of 310 days. Hence, the learned counsel would submit that in the wisdom of the Court below, has exercised its discretion and allowed the Section 5 of Limitation Act application, therefore, the same should not be interfered with.
9. The learned counsel for the second defendant has relied upon the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in 2008-13- SCC-466 (Bank of India V. Mehta Brothers) and 2019-4-CTC-122 (G.Ratna Raj (D) V. Sri Muthukumarasamy Permanent Fund Ltd.).
10. I have given my anxious consideration to the either side submissions.
11. First of all, we must see whether the judgment, in which, an application is being filed to set aside the exparte decree is based on merits or an exparte decree. On perusal of the judgment, the second defendant admittedly has been set exparte. However, as against the first defendant, the suit was decreed on merits. On the other hand, it is the submission of the second defendant's counsel that, since the first defendant has not been cross examined, the very judgment cannot be construed as the judgment on merits.
12. The learned counsel for the plaintiff would invite the attention of this Court, to the explanation of Order 17 Rule 2 of C.P.C, and would contend that, since the substantial part of the evidence of the first defendant has already been recorde