1. Petitioner seeks judicial intervention to enforce import duty conditions under a foreign trade scheme and a declaration regarding the scope of administrative and appellate authorities. (Para 1 , 2 )
2026 Supreme(Online)(Mad) 120625
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari, CJ, G. Arul Murugan, J
S. Santhosh Kumar – Appellant
Versus
Union of India – Respondent
W.P . No . 45612 of 2026|W C N M R : { P H C N M o A . 0 5 12 1 68 2 0 1 36 4 20 o 26 f }
Important Points
Subject
Customs and Foreign Trade - Public Interest Litigation
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Writ of Mandamus - Policy Enforcement - The Court cannot direct the executive to enforce conditions imposed via public notice when their legal validity is in doubt, nor can it direct the framing of policy notifications. (Para 6)
(C) Jurisdiction - CESTAT vs. DGFT - Statutory jurisdiction granted to the Tribunal under the Customs Act cannot be curtailed by administrative policy provisions in the Foreign Trade Policy. (Para 9)
Issues: Whether a PIL is maintainable to challenge the enforcement of DFIA conditions and whether the DGFT's policy interpretation overrides the statutory jurisdiction of CESTAT.
Result: Dismissed.
Legal Category Hierarchy
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Pooja Thorat, S. Vedhavel
For the Respondents: A. Kumaraguru, M. Santhanaraman
Table of Contents
2. Petitioner argues for mandatory compliance with import conditions via public notice and the subordination of administrative policy to appellate orders, while respondents challenge the petition's validity. (Para 3 , 4 )
3. The court observed that the petition lacks factual specificity, fails to establish standing, and seeks policy-making directions that fall outside the proper scope of judicial scrutiny. (Para 5 , 6 , 7 )
4. A writ of mandamus requires a clear legal duty, and courts cannot direct the executive to frame policy or intervene in purely administrative matters without specific standing. (Para 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 )
5. The court dismissed the writ petition and closed the connected application for lack of merit and standing. (Para 9 )
6. Can a petitioner maintain a public interest litigation without demonstrating personal interest or specific evidence of injury?
No. A public interest litigation requires the petitioner to demonstrate good faith, plead facts with care, and avoid seeking relief in sectors where they lack standing, such as failing to cite specific instances of harm or naming affected parties. (Para 4 , 5 , 7 )
7. Is a court empowered to issue a writ of mandamus to compel the executive to frame or enforce policy?
No. A writ of mandamus requires a clear legal duty. Where the enforcement of specific import conditions is in legal doubt, the court cannot direct the executive to frame policy or issue notifications, as such matters remain within executive discretion. (Para 6 )
8. Does the Directorate General of Foreign Trade have finality in policy interpretation over the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal?
While the Foreign Trade Policy may designate executive interpretations as final on policy, such provisions cannot extinguish the statutory appellate jurisdiction over customs exemptions conferred upon the Tribunal by Parliament. (Para 8 , 9 )
A 26-year-old Chennai resident has filed this public interest petition seeking orders to curb imports under the Duty Free Import Authorisation (DFIA) scheme. The petitioner seeks a further direction to the customs authorities to verify compliance with actual user conditions and value caps prior to granting duty-free clearances. Additionally, the petition seeks this court to declare that rulings by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) do not bind the Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) on policy matters, and to confirm that the DGFT, rather than the Remission of Duties and Taxes on Export Products (RoDTEP) Committee, retains sole authority over exporter eligibility under the RoDTEP scheme.
2.1. The case in brief is that DFIA is a post-export scheme under Chapter 4 of the Foreign Trade Policy ("FTP"). It is issued for products for which Standard Input Output Norms ("SION") are notified. The authorisation is transferable. The holder can import inputs duty free.
2.2. By Public Notice No.41 dated 02.11.2016, the Director General of Foreign Trade ("DGFT") amended the SION for certain food products. The said notice added value caps for some inputs and an actual user condition for others. It is pleaded that importers ignore these conditions, as such conditions cannot be imposed by a public notice and can be imposed only by a notification in the OfÏcial Gazette.
2.3. The petitioner relies on two orders of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal ("CESTAT"). In Frunuts Exim LLP , Final Order No.85184/2026, dated 27.01.2026, the Mumbai Bench allowed duty free import of dried cranberries. In Global Exim , Final Order No.75721/2026, dated 18.06.2026, the Kolkata Bench allowed duty free import of citric acid. Both Benches held that the value cap and the actual user condition, imposed only by public notice, could not be used to deny the exemption. They relied on a decision of the Supreme Court in Viraj Impex Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India , 2026 INSC 80, and on decisions of the Bombay and Rajasthan High Courts.
2.4. The second grievance aired by the petitioner concerns the RoDTEP. Notification No.70/2023 extended RoDTEP to exports by Advance Authorisation holders, Export Oriented Units (EOUs) and Special Economic Zone (SEZ) units. It did not mention DFIA. The petitioner asserts that DFIA exporters still claim RoDTEP and so get a double benefit. He points out that, on a reference, the DGFT informed the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs ("CBIC") that DFIA exports are not eligible for RoDTEP. CBIC passed this on to its field ofÏcers by letter F.No.CBIC-140602/4/2026-DBK-CBIC, dated 07.09.2026.
2.5. In this backdrop, the present writ petition is filed for the reliefs, referred to supra.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied on Sections 9 and 19 of the Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992 ("the FTDR Act") and on Paragraphs 1.03, 2.04 and 2.58 of the FTP. She argued that the DGFT can lay down procedures, including value caps and actual user conditions, and that its decision on policy is final.
4. A public interest litigation is meant for those who cannot reach the Court themselves. It is not a tool for settling policy or for reopening decisions of other forums. The Court must be satisfied that the petitioner is acting in good faith, that the facts are pleaded with care, and that the relief sought is one the Court can properly grant.
5. The present petition does not meet the aforesaid standard.
The petitioner's own afÏdavit says he learnt of the alleged misuse from reports on the internet. He did not mention the name of any importer, nor any bill of entry is cited, or the amount of alleged loss is stated. The statement that there are "regular imports" at the Port of Chennai is not backed by a single instance. He admits that he made no representation to any respondent. The two Tribunal orders he relies on arose at Mumbai and Kolkata, not at Chennai.
6. A writ of mandamu