2023 Supreme(Online)(MP) 8873

1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

A T J A B A L P U R

BEFORE

HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SHEEL NAGU

&

HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK AGARWAL

WRIT PETITION No. 5626 of 2021

BETWEEN:-

1.

HAHNEMANN HOMEOPATHIC MEDICAL

COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL BHOPAL THR.

ITS PRINCIPAL DR. NISHA SEKHRI W/O DR.

S.K. SEKHRI NEW JAIL BYPASS ROAD

KAROUND

BHOPAL

MP

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

2.

MAHATMA

GANDHI

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE

AND

HOSPITAL,

JABALPUR THROUOGH ITS DIRECTOR,

MR. RAJENDRA VERMA S/O LATE K.C.

VERMA A/A 50 YEARS NEEM-KHEDA GOUR

TIRAHA, OPP. MARBLE ROCK SCHOOL,

JABALPUR (MADHYA PRADESH)

3.

NARAYAN SHRI HOMEOPATHIC MEDICAL

COLLEGE

AND

HOSPITAL,

BHOPAL

THROUGH

ITS

PRINCIPAL,

DR.

R.S.

AGRAWAL

S/O

MR.

BHANWARI

LAL

AGARWAL A/A 45 YEARS PUSHPA NAGAR,

NEAR MAIN RAILWAY STATION, BHOPAL

(M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)

4.

ANUSHREE

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE,

JABALPUR

THROUGH

ITS

MANAGING DIRECTOR, MR. ANIRUUDH

VISHNOI S/O MR. AJAY BISHNOI A/A 33

YEARS KASOUDHAN NAGAR, KARMETA,

JABALPUR (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONERS

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI NAMAN

NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL TIWARI, MS.

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

2

ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI DEVASHISH

SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THR

PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPT. OF AYUSH

3RD FLOOR VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL

MP (MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

DIRECTORATE OF AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY STATE OF M.P. THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTOR

GROUND

FLOOR

D

WING

SATPURA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL, M.P. (MADHYA PRADESH)

3.

UNION OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX, AYUSH BHAWAN, B- BLOCK,

INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER

SECRETARY/CHAIRMAN

61-65,

SEWA

MARG, OPP D BLOCK, INSTITUTIONAL

AREA, JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI, DELHI

(DELHI)

5.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS ORGANIZATION) UNDER

THE

DEPARTMENT

OF

HIGHER

EDUCATION MINISTRY OF EDUCATION

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY C-20, 1A/8, SECTOR 62, IITK

OUTRACH CENTRE NEODA 201309 IST

FLOOR NSIC - MDBP BUILDING (DELHI)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI

PIYUSH

JAIN

-

GOVERNMENT

ADVOCATE

FOR

THE

RESPONDENTS-STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE

RESPONDENTS-UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE

WITH MS. NAIN JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE

NCIM, SHRI ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND

SHRI PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR

NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 4609 of 2022

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

3

BETWEEN:-

1.

RANI

DULLAIYA

SMRITI

HOMEOPATHY MEDICAL COLLEGE

AND HOSPITAL THROUGH PRINCIPAL

DR.SANJAY PATKAR S/O LATE SITA

RAM PATKAR HD 46, ABHIRUCHI

PARISAR,

OLD

SUBHASH

NAGAR,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

SHIVANG HOMEOPATHIC MEDICAL

COLLEGE, BHOPAL THROUGH ITS

PRINCIPAL DR. D.N.MISHRA S/O SHRI

J.N.MISHRA

R/O

SHIVANG

HOMEOPATHIC MEDICAL COLLEGE,

BHOPAL (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY

AYUSH DEPTT. III FLOOR VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

2.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY, STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR, D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

3.

UNION OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX,

AYUSH

BHAWAN,

B-

BLOCK, INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

CENTRAL

COUNCIL

FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

4

MEMBER SECRETARY/CHAIRMAN 61-

65, SEWA MARG, OPP. D BLOCK,

INSTITUTIONAL AREA, JANAKPURI,

NEW DELHI, DELHI (DELHI)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 6104 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

SCHOOL OF HOMEOPATHY SRI SATYA SAI

UNIVERSITY

OF

TECHNOLOGY

AAND

MEDICAL SCIENCES THROUGH PRINCIPAL

DR.UMESH

KUMAR

PANDEY

S/O

LATE

R.D.PANDEY

OPPOSITE

OILFED

PLANT,

PACHAMA SH-18, BHOPAL INDORE ROAD,

SEHORE (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY

AYUSH DEPTT III FLOOR, VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

2.

DIRECTOR OF AYUSH/ COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/ DIRECTOR GROUND

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

5

FLOOR, D WING, SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

3.

UNION OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX,

AYUSH

BHAWAN,

B-

BLOCK, INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

FOR

HOMEOPATHY,

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY/ CHAIRMEN 61-

65, SEWA MARG, OPP. D BLOCK,

INSTITUTIONAL AREA, JANAKPURI,

NEW DELHI, DELHI (DELHI)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 6199 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

1.

R.K.D.F.

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL RESEARCH

CENTER

BHOPAL

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL DR.A.D.KHAN S/O LATE

M.D.KHAN

MILE

STONE

12,

HOSHANGABAD ROAD, JAATKHEDI,

DISTRICT

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

2.

RAM

KRISHNA

COLLEGE

OF

HOMEOPATHIC MEDICAL SCIENCES

THROUGH PRINCIPAL DR. ANOOP J

KATYAYAN

S/O

LATE

DR.

J.Y

KATYAYAN PETITIONER INSTITUTION

REGISTERED

ADDRESS

AIRPORT

BYPASS

ROAD

GANDHINAGAR

DISTRICT

BHOPAL

M.P.

(MADHYA

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

6

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY

AYUSH DEPTT III FLOOR VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

2.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR D WING SATPURA BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

3.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B BLOCK

INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

FO

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY/CHAIRMAN 61-

65

SEWA

MARG,

OPP.

D

BLOCK

INSTITUTIONAL

AREA

JANAKPURI

NEW DELHI (DELHI)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 6791 of 2022

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

7

BETWEEN:-

S.M.DEO

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL SADAR PATEL

CAMPUS GAYKHURI BALAGHAT THROUGH

DIRECTOR VIRESHAR SINGH AGED ABOUT

42

YEARS

S/O

CHANDRABHAN

SINGH

SARDAR

PATEL

CAMPUS,

GAYKHURI,

MOTINAGAR,

BALAGHAT

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY

AYUSH

DEPT

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

CENTRAL

COUNCIL

FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY/ CHAIRMAN 61-

65

SEWA

MARG,

OPP.

D

BLOCK

INSTITUTIONAL

AREA

JANAKPURI

NEW DELHI (DELHI)

3.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX,

AYUSH

BHAWAN,

B-

BLOCK, INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY THROUGH

ITS COMMISSIONER/ DIRECTOR GPO

COMPLEX GROUND FLOOR, D WING,

SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL,

M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

8

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 9340 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

SCHOOL

OF

AYURVEDA

AND

SIDDHA

STUDIES THROUGH PRINCIPAL SHRI HIRA

MAN

DAS

BANJARE

S/O

SHRI

CHAD

BANJARE

AGED

ABOUT

61

YEARS

SH

18BHOPAL INDORE, PACHAMA DISTRICT

SEHORE (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX, AHUSH BHAWAN, B-

BLOCK, INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

FOR

HOMEOPATHY,

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY 61-65, SEWA

MARG, OPP. D BLOCK, INSTITUTIONAL

AREA, JANAKPURI (DELHI)

3.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH,

THROUGH

ITS

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH, III FLOOR,

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY, STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH, THROUGH ITS

DIRECTOR GROUND FLOOR, D WING,

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

9

SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 10557 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

1.

RAM

KRISHNA

COLLEGE

OF

AYURVEDA AND MEDICAL SCIENCES

RAM

KRISHNA

DHARMATH

FOUNDATION UNIVERSITY THROUGH

PRINCIPAL DR. ABHIJIT B PATIL S/O

BABURAO VISHWANATH PATIL RKDF

UNIVERSITY NEAR AIPORT BYPASS

ROAD, GANDHI NAGAR, BHOPAL M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

SARVEPALLI

RADHAKRISHNA

COLLEGE OF AYURVEDA HOSPITAL

AND RESEARCH CENTRE, THROUGH

ASSISTANT PROFESSOR DR. SUNIL

KUMAR PARASHAR S/O SHRI BABULA

PARASHAR, AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,

HN-12,

HOSHANGABAD

ROAD,

JATKHEDI (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

10

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B BLOCK

INA

NEW

DELHI

GPO

COMPLEX

AYUSH BHAWAN B-BLOCK INA, NEW

DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE, THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY 61-65, SEWA MARG, OPP.

D

BLOCK,

INSTITUTIONAL

AREA,

JANAKPURI (DELHI)

3.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH,

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH 3RD FLOOR,

SATPUDA BHAVAN BHOPAL (MADHYA

PRADESH)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

(COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY),

THE

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH,

THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR,D WING, SATPUDA BHAWAN

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 10965 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

VIJAYSHREE

AYURVEDIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE

AND

HOSPITAL

THROUGH

CHAIRMAN SHRI RAJESH STHAPAK S/O

LATE SHRI RAVI KANT STHAPAK SHREE

BRAHMANAND

SARASWATI

SHIKSHA

SAMITI

SUBUDHRA

KUMARI

CHOUHAN

WARD

MODEL

ROAD

JABALPUR

MP

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

11

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THORUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH III FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

MP

(MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

FOR

HOMEOPATHY,

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY 61-65, SEWA

MARG, OPP. D BLOCK, INSTITUTIONAL

AREA, JANAKPURI (DELHI)

3.

UNION

OF

INDIA,

MINISTRY

OF

AYUSH, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY

GPO COMPLEX, AHUSH BHAWAN, B-

BLOCK, INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY

STATE

OF

M.P.,

THROUGH

ITS

DIRECTOR GROUND FLOOR D WING

SATPURA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

M.P

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI

PIYUSH

JAIN

-

GOVERNMENT

ADVOCATE

FOR

THE

RESPONDENTS-STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE

RESPONDENTS-UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE

WITH MS. NAIN JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE

NCIM, SHRI ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH

AND SHRI PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR

NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 11010 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

12

VINDHYA SHIKSHA SAMITI (A SOCETY

REGISTERED UNDER REGISTRATION ACT

1973)

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

SHRI

VIRESHWAR SINGH AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS

S/O SHRI CHANDRABHAN SINGH GAYKHURI

DISTRICT

BALAGHAT

M.P.

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH

THE

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

IIIRD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL, M.P. (MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY 61-65, SEWA

MARG, OPP. D BLOCK, INSTITUTIONAL

AREA

JANAKPURI,

NEW

DELHI

(DELHI)

3.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-BLOCK

INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY

STATE

OF

M.P.

THROUGH

ITS

DIRECTOR GROUND FLOOR D WING

SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

13

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 11011 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

OM AYURVEDIC MEDICAL COLLEGE AND

HOSPITAL THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN SHRI

SANTOSH PAL AGED 50 YEARS S/O SHRI

RAM RATAN PAL JAMTHI, P.O. BHARAT

BHARATI, BETUL M.P. RUN BY; OM SWASTH

EVAM

SIKSHA

PARISHAD

BETUL

C/O

JAMTHI, P.O. BHARAT BHARTI B BETUL M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

DEPARTMENT

OF

AYUSH

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH, III FLOOR,

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY 61-65, SEWA

MARG, OPP. D BLOCK, INSTITUTIONAL

AREA

JANAKPURI,

NEW

DELHI

(DELHI)

3.

UNION OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX,

AYUSH

BHAWAN,

B-

BLOCK, INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY,

STATE

OF

M.P.

THROUGH

ITS

DIRECTOR GROUND FLOOR, D WINGH,

SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

M.P.

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

14

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 11013 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

1.

DEPARTMENT OF AYURVEDA AND

COMMUNITY

IES

UNIVERSITY

THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL DR. RAJESH

URMALE S/O LATE SHRI RAMRAO

URMALE AGED YEARS REGISTERED

OFFICE AR IES UNIVERSITY CAMPUS,

KALKHEDA, RATIBAD MAIN ROAD,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

L.N.

AYURVED

COLLEGE

AND

HOSPITAL,

THROUGH

ITS

AUTHORISED

SIGNATORY

MR.

SIDDHARTH RAI S/O SHRI R.K. RAI,

AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS, REGISTERED

OFFICE AT SAVADHAM, C-SECTOR,

KOLAR

ROAD,

J.K.

TOWN,

BHOPAL(M.P.) RUN BY H.K. KALCHURI

EDUCATION

TRUST

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI ASHISH MISHRA - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH III FLOOR,

VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL (M.P.)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

15

(MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE, THROUGH ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY, JAWAHAR LAL

NEHRU BHARTIYA CHIKITSA AVAM

HOMOEOPATHY

ANUSANDHAN

BHAWAN 61-65, INSTITUTIONAL AREA,

JANAKPURI (DELHI)

3.

UNION

OF

INDIA,

MINISTRY

OF

AYUSH, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY

GPO COMPLEX, AYUSH BHAWAN, B-

BLOCK, INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY,

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH,

THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR, D WING SATPURA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 11098 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

1.

DR.

SHANKAR

DAYAL

SHARMA

AYURVEDA COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

AND

AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE SHRI

SANJEEV SOTI S/O SHRI B.M. SOTI AGE

ABOUT 56 POST PRIVATE JOB R/O

NEAR CENTRAL FORENSIC SCINCE

LABORATORY

INDORE

BHOPAL

BYPASS

ROAD,

VILLAGE

BHOURI

BHOPAL, C/O KATYANI SHIKSHAN

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

16

SAMITI

BHOPAL,

M.P.

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

2.

VEENA VADINI AYURVED COLLEG

AND

HOSPITAL

THROUGH

ITS

PRINCIPAL DR. O.P SHUKLA S/O LATE

SHRI S.P SHUKLA AGE 64 YEEARS

POST PRIVATE JOB BEHIND KANHA

KUNJ AKBARPUR PHASE II KOLAR

ROAD BHOPAL M.P. 462033 AN 170

SHANKUNTALA NAGAR RAJHAARSH

COLONY KOLAR ROAD BHOPAL M.P

(MADHYA PRADESH)

3.

RAJEEV GANDHI AYURVED COLLEGE

AND HOSPITAL THROUGH PRINCIPAL

DR. BHAGWATI PRASAD SHARMA S/O

LATE SHRI ANAND PRASAD SHARMA

AGED 55 YEARS POST PRIVATE JOB E-

8

TILANGA

COLONY

SHAHPURA

BHOPAL

H.NO.

37

PRATEEK

APARTMENT

GULMOHAR

COLONY

SHAHPURA BHOPAL M.P . (MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX,

AYUSH

BHAWAN,

B-

BLOCK, INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSON FOR INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY 61-65 SEWA MARG OPP. D

BLOCK

INSTITUTIONAL

AREA

JANAKPURI (DELHI)

3.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

17

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH IIIRD FLOOR

SATPURA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

M.P

(MADHYA PRADESH)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

(COUNSELLING AUTHORITY) STATE

OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

DIRECTOR GROUND FLOOR D WING

SATPURA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

M.P

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI

PIYUSH

JAIN

-

GOVERNMENT

ADVOCATE

FOR

THE

RESPONDENTS-STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE

RESPONDENTS-UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE

WITH MS. NAIN JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE

NCIM, SHRI ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH

AND SHRI PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR

NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 11256 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

POORNAYU AYURVED CHKITSALAYA EVAM

ANUSANDHAN

VIDHYAPEETH

GIRLS

COLLEGE

JABALPUR

THROUGH

ITS

PRINCIPAL DR. SWAPNIL SINGHAI S/O SHRI

SURESHCHAND SINGHAI A/A 46 YAERS

OCCU. PRINCIPAL OFFICE AT POORNAYU

AYURVED

CHIKITLAYA

EVAM

ANHUSANDHAN

VIDHYAPEETH

GIRLS

COLLEGE TILWARAGHAT JABALPUR, M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI RAHUL DIWAKAR - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY GPO COMPLEX AYUSH

BHAWAN B-BLOCK INA, NEW DELHI

(DELHI)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

18

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY 61-65, SEWA MARG, OPP.

D

BLOCK,

INSTITUTIONAL

AREA,

JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

3.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT

OF

AYUSH

IIIRD

FLOOR, SATPURA BHAVAN, BHOPAL,

M.P. (MADHYA PRADESH)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

(COUNSELLING AUTHORITY), STATE

OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

DIRECTOR GROUND FLOOR, D WING,

SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 11286 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

RANI DULLAIYA SMRITI AYURVED P.G.

COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL THROUGH ITS

AUTHORIZED SIGNATORY MR SYED AZHAR

ALI NAQVI S/O LATE SHRI DR. N.A. A/O 43

YEARS OFFICE AT RANI DULLAIYA SMRITI

AYURVED P.G. COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL

BARKHEDI

KALAN,

BHADBHADA

ROAD

BHOPAL,

M.P.,

OCCUPATION

ADMINISTRATIVE

OFFICER

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI RAHUL DIWKAR -ADVOCATE)}

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

19

AND

1.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-BLOCK

INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY 61-65, SEWA MARG, OPP.

D

BLOCK,

INSTITUTIONAL

AREA,

JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

3.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH IIIRD FLOOR

SATPURA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

M.P

(MADHYA PRADESH)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

(COUNSELLING AUTHORITY) STATE

OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

DIRECTOR GROUND FLOOR D WING

SATPURA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

M.P

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 11291 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

PARASHAR

AYURVEDIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL THROUGH ITS

AUTHORISED

REPRESENTATIVE

AND

DIRECTOR SHRI RAHUL GOSWAMI S/O SHRI

B.K.

GOSWAMI

AGE

33

YEARS

POST

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

20

DIRECTOR

ADDRESS-

ZIRANIYA

NARSINGHARH ROAD PARVALIA BHOPAL,

M.P.

462030,

H.NO.

66

SHRAWANKANTA

ESTATE NARELA SANKHARI, BHOPAL, M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-BLOCK

INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY 61-65, SEWA MARG, OPP.

D

BLOCK,

INSTITUTIONAL

AREA,

JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

3.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT

OF

AYUSH

IIIRD

FLOOR, SATPURA BHAVAN, BHOPAL

M.P. (MADHYA PRADESH)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

(COUNSELLING AUTHORITY), STATE

OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

DIRECTOR GROUND FLOOR, D WING,

SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL,

M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

21

WRIT PETITION No. 11579 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

FACULTY OF AYURVEDA, MANSAROVAR

GLOBAL UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS DEAN

DR. BABUL TAMRAKAR S/O L.L. TAMRAKAR

AGED SIXTY FOUR YEARS REGISTERED

OFFICE AT VILLAGE GADIA RATNAKHEDI

BILKISGANJ

SEHORE

M.P.

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI ASHISH MISHRA - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH III FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY JAWAHAR LAL

NEHRU BHARTIYA CHIKITSA AVAM

HOMOEOPATHY

ANUSANDHAN

BHAWAN 61-65 INSTITUTIONAL AREA

JANAKPURI D BLOCK NEW DELHI

110058 (DELHI)

3.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-BLOCK

INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAVAN

BHOPAL M.P. (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

22

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 11673 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

MANSAROVAR

AYURVEDIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE,

HOSPITAL

AND

RESEARCH

CENTER THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL DR.

ANURAG SINGH RAJPUT S/O MR. JAGAT

SINGH RAJPUT AGED YEARS REGISTERED

OFFICE AT VILLAGE HINOTIA ALAM, WARD

NO. 84, KOLAR RD, BHOPAL, MADHYA

PRADESH (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI ASHISH MISHRA - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

DEPARTMENT

OF

AYUSH

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH, III FLOOR,

VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL (M.P.)

(MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE, THROUGH ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY, JAWAHARLAL

NEHRU BHARTIYA CHIKITSA AVAM

HOMEOPATHY

ANISANDHAN

BHAWAN 61-65, INSTITUTIONAL AREA,

JANAKPURI, D BLOCK ,NEW DELHI

(DELHI)

3.

UNION OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX,

AYUSH

BHAWAN,

B-

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

23

BLOCK, INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY

,THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR THE STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

GROUND

FLOOR, D WING, SATPURA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 14806 of 2022

BETWEEN:-

R.K.D.F.

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE

AND

HOSPITAL

RESEARCH

CENTER BHOPAL THROUGH PRINCIPAL DR.

A.D. KHAN S/O LATE M.D. KHAN AGED

ABOUT 56 YEARS PETITIONER INSTITUTION

REGISTERED ADDRESS MILE STONE 12

HOSHANGABAD

ROAD

JAATKHEDI

DISTRICT BHOPAL M.P. (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH III FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

M.P.

(MADHYA PRADESH)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

24

2.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY, STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER / DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR, D WING, SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

3.

UNION OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX,

AYUSH

BHAWAN,

B-

BLOCK, INA, NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

MEMBER SECRETARY / CHAIRMAN 61-

65, SEWA MARG, OPP. D BLOCK,

INSTITUTIONAL AREA, JANAKPURI,

NEW DELHI DELHI (DELHI)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 1360 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

ANUSHREE

HOMOEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE

JABALPUR

THROUGH

ITS

PRINCIPALPROFESSOR DR. VIKAS TRIPATHI

S/O SHRI SHIV PRASAD TRIPATHI AGED

ABOUT 48 YEARS 1/2 KASODHAN NAGAR

KARMETA DISTRICT JABALPUR (MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

25

AND

1.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B BLOCK

INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION

)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 1A/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTER

NOIDA 201309 1ST FLOOR NSIC-MPDB

BUILDING

OKHDA

INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI DELHI 110020

(DELHI)

4.

STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUACTION STATE OF M.P. THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTOR

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

CONSELING AUTHORITY STATE OF

M.P. THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER /

DIRECTORATE GROUND FLOOR D

WING SATPUDA BHAWAN BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

26

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 1730 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

SCHOOL OF HOMEOPATHY SRI SATYA SAI

UNIVERSITY

OF

TECHNOLOGY

AND

MEDICAL

SCIENCES

THROUGH

DR.

PUSHPENDRA

TIWARI

S/O

LATE

C.

P.

SHARMA DY REGISTRAR SHRI SATYA SAI

UNIVERSITY

PETITIONER

REGISTERED

ADDRESS

OPPOSITE

OILFED

PLANT

PACHAMA SH18 BHOPAL INDORE ROAD

DISTRICT SEHORE (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-BLOCK

INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

61-65,

SEWA

MARG,

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK,

INDUSTRIAL

AREA, JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

27

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

,MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 1A/8,

SECTOR 62,IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC

MDBP BUILDING, OKHDA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH,

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH 3RD FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION, THE STATE OF MADHYA

PRADESH,

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR, D WING, SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY.

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH,

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR, D WING, SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI

PIYUSH

JAIN

-

GOVERNMENT

ADVOCATE

FOR

THE

RESPONDENTS-STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE

RESPONDENTS-UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE

WITH MS. NAIN JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE

NCIM, SHRI ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH

AND SHRI PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR

NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 2681 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

28

1.

MAHATMA GAJNDHI HOMEOPATHY

COLLEGE THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL

DR. JHUMA VERMA W/O LATE SHRI

RAJU VERMA AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS

NEEMKHEDA NEARBY GUAR TIRAHA

JABALPUR (MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

HAHNEMANN

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL COLLEGE THROUGH ITS

PRINCIPAL DR. NISHA SEKHRI D/O

SHRI S.K. SEKHRI, AGED ABOUT 62

YEARS, NEW JAIL ROAD KAROND

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

3.

SIVANG

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL

DR. D.N. MISHRA S/O LATE SHRI J.N.

MISHRA

SHIVANG

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE

BAIRAGARH

CHICHALI, KOLAR ROAD BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

4.

NARAYAN

SHREE

HOMEOPATHIC

MEDICAL COLLEGE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY AMBRISH CHOUKSEY S/O

LATE SHRI SURESH CHAUKSEY, AGED

ABOUT 39 YEARS, PUSHPA NAGAR

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B

BLOCK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR

HOMEPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG,

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

29

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA

JANAKPURI,

NEW

DELHI

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 1A/8,

SECTOR 62,IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC

MDBP BUILDING, OKHDA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH 3RD FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER / DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 2701 of 2023

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

30

BETWEEN:-

1.

R.K.D.F

HOMOEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE AND RESEARCH CENTER

BHOPAL THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL

CENTRE DR. A.D KHAN S/O LATE M.D.

KHAN

AGE

56

PETITIONER

INSTITUTION REGISTERED ADDRESS-

MILE STONE 12, HOSHANGABAD ROAD

JAATKHEDI (MADHYA PRADESH)

2.

RAMKRISHNA

COLLEGE

OF

HOMOEOPATHY

AND

MEDICAL

SCIENCES RKDF UNIVERSITY BHOPAL

THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL DR. ANOOP

J. KATYAYAN S/O DR. J Y KATYAYAN

AGED

ABOUT

62

PETITIONER

INSTITUTION REGISTERED ADDRESS

RKDF UNIVERSITY CAMPUS GANDHI

NAGAR

BHOPAL

462033

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-

BLOCK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG,

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

31

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 IA/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC-

MDBP BUILDING, OKHDA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI NEW DELHI

(DELHI)

4.

STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION STATE OF M.P. THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTOR

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPURA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELING AUTHORITY STATE OF

M.P. THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER /

DIRECTORATE GROUND FLOOR -D

WING SATPURA BHAWAN BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 4007 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

SCHOOL

OF

AYURVEDA

AND

SIDDHA

STUDIES S/O LATAE R.D. PANDEY, AGED

ABOUT 62 YEARS, OCCUPATION: THROUGH

AUTHORISED PERSON DR. UMESH KUMAR

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

32

PANDEY OCCUPATION PRINCIPAL/ DEAN,

ADDRESS: SSS UTMS SEHORE MP. SH 18

BHOPAL INDORE, PANCHAMA DISTRICT

SEHORE (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-

BLCOK INA (DELHI)

2.

THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR

INDIAN

SYSTEM

OF

MEDICINE

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY 61-65 SEWA

MARG,

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK,

INDUSTRIAL AREA JANAKPURI, NEW

DELHI (DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 1A/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE,

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC-

MDBP BUILDING, OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH 3RD FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER / DIRECTOR GROUND

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

33

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELING AUTHORITY STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI

PIYUSH

JAIN

-

GOVERNMENT

ADVOCATE

FOR

THE

RESPONDENTS-STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE

RESPONDENTS-UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE

WITH MS. NAIN JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE

NCIM, SHRI ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH

AND SHRI PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR

NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 4187 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

S.M.

DEO

HOMOEOPATHIC

MEDICAL

GOLLEGE

HOSPITAL

SADAR

PATEL

CAMPUS GAYKHURI BALAGHAT DISTRICT

BALAGHAT RUN BY VINDHYA SHIKSHA

SAMITI (A REGISTERED SOCIETY UNDER

THE SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT 1973)

THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR SHRI BIRESHWAR

SINGH AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS S/O SHRI

CHANDRABHAN SINGH R/O SARDAR PATEL

CAMPUS GAYKHURI DISTRICT BALAGHAT

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

34

BLOCK INA, NEWDELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

OF

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG,

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION

GOVT.

OF

INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 IA/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC-

MDBP BUILDING, OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI 110020 (DELHI)

4.

STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION STATE OF M.P. THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTOR

GROUND FLOOR-D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELING

AUTHORITY

STATE

OF

M.P.

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR-D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

35

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 4335 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

RANI

DULLAIYA

SMRITI

HOMEOPATHY

MEDICAL

COLLEGE

AND

HOSPITAL

THROUGH

ITS

PRINCIPAL

DR.

VIJAY

PRATAP SINGH S/O RAGHWENDRA PRATAP

SINGH AGED 58 R/O BARKHEDI KALAN

BHADBHADA

ROAD

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B

BLOCK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR

HOMEOPATHY

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA

JANAKPURI,

NEW

DELHI

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 1A/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC-

MDBP BUILDING, OKHDA INDUSTRIAL

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

36

ESTATE NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/ DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTOR OF AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY, THE STATE OF MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 4857 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

VIJYA

SHREE

AYURVEDIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL SCHEME NO. 41/65

GRAM

BASAHA

(RAINGWA)

NEAR

KACHPURA RAILWAY STATION RUN BY

SHREE

BRAHMANAND

SARASWATI

SHIKSHA SAMITI (A SOCIETY REGISTERED

UNDER

THROUGH

ITS

CHIRMAN

SHRI

RAJESH STHAPAK AGED 56 YEARS S/O LT.

SHRI RAVI KANT STHAPAK C/O SUBUDHRA

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

37

KUMARI CHOUHAN WARD MODEL ROAD

JABALPUR (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY AYUSH GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B- BLCOK

INA NEWDELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION OF INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION

GOVT.

OF

INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 IA/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NODIA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR NSIC

MDBP BUILDING OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI 110020 (DELHI)

4.

STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION STATE OF M.P. THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/

DIRECTOR

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/COUNSELING AUTHORITY STATE OF

M.P. THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER /

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

38

DIRECTORATE GROUND FLOOR D

WING SATPUDA BHAWAN BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 4863 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

VINDHYA SHIKSHA SAMITI (A SOCIETY

REGISTERED

UNDER

SOCIETIES

REGSTRATION ACT 1973) THROUGH ITS

DIRECTO SHRI DR. MANJEET SINGH AGED

33 YEARS S/O INDRASEN SINGH O/O SADAR

PATEL

CAMPUS,

GAYKHURI

DISTRICT

BALAGHAT (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B-

BLCOK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL

COMMISSION

INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

39

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION

GOVT.

OF

INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 IA/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NODIA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR NSIC

MDBP BUILDING OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI 110020 (DELHI)

4.

STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL EDUCATION

STATE

OF

M.P.

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER / DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY STATE OF

M.P. THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER /

DIRECTORATE GROUND FLOOR D

WING SATPUDA BHAWAN BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 5041 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

RAM KRISHNA COLLEGE OF AYURVEDA

AND

MEDICAL

SCIENCES

R.K.D.F.

UNIVERSITY

THROUGH

AUTHORISED

PERSON DR. ABHIJIT PATIL S/O SHRI

BABURAO VISHWANATH PATIL AGE ABOUT

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

40

44 YEARS OCCUPATION PRINCIPAL RKDF

UNIVERSITY NEAR AIRPORT BYPASS ROAD

GANDHI

NAGAR

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF AYUSH

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY

GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B BLOCK

INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR

INDIAN

SYSTEM

OF

MEDICINE

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY 61-65 SEWA

MARG,

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK,

INDUSTRIAL AREA JANAKPURI, NEW

DELHI (DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 1A/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE,

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC-

MDBP BUILDING, OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH 3RD FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER / DIRECTOR GROUND

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

41

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELING AUTHORITY STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 5107 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

PARASHAR

AYURVEDIC

MEDICAL

COLLEGE

AND

HOSPITAL

(RUN

BY

PARASHAR SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

EDUCATION

SOCIETY

(A

SOCIETY

REGISTERED

UNDER

SOCIETIES

REGISTRATION ACT 1973) THROUGH ITS

DIRECTOR DR. ANOOP CHATURVEDI S/O

SHRI SIDDH NATH CHATURVEDI ZIRANIYA

NARSINGHARH ROAD, PARVALIA BHOPAL

M.P. THROUGH R/O FLAT NO. 107 SOMA

VIHAR CHUNA BATTI BHOPAL (MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADOVCATE)}

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

42

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B

BLOCK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION OF INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION

GOVT.

OF

INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20IA/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NODIA 201309 AND 1ST NSIC MDBP

BUILDING

OKHLA

INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI DELHI 110020

(DELHI)

4.

STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION STATE OF M.P. THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTOR

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY STATE OF

M.P. THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER /

DIRECTORATE GROUND FLOOR D

WING SATPUDA BHAWAN BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

43

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 5108 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

DR. SHANKAR DAYAL SHARMA AYURVEDA

MEDICAL

COLLEGE

AND

HOSPITAL

THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR SHRI SANJEEV

SOTIE AGED 58YRS S/O BRIJ MOHAN SOTIE

INDORE BHOPAL NY PASS ROAD GRAM

BHOURI

BHOPAL

RUN

BY

KATYAN

SHIKSHAN SAMITI (A SOCIETY REGISTERED

UNDER SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT 1973)

O/O 175 TIRPTI HOSPITAL GUFA MANDIR

ROAD

LALGHATI

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY IF AYUSH GPO

COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B BLOCK

INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION OF INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE, THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER

THE

DEPARTMENT

OF

HIGHER

EDUCATION,

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION,

GOVT

OF

INDIA,

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 IA/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

44

NODIA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR NSIC

MDBP BUILDING OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI 110020 (DELHI)

4.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH,

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH 3RD FLOOR,

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION,

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH,

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELLING

AUTHORITY,

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

,

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 5109 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

VEENA VADINI AYURVED COLLEGE AND

HOSPITAL

RUN

BY

VEENA

VADINI

EDUCATIONAL

EVAM

PRASHIKSHAN

SANSTHAN (A SOCIETY REGISTERED UNDER

SOCIETIES

REGISTRATION

ACT

1973)

THROUGH ITS VICE PRINCIPAL DR. MANISH

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

45

JAIN S/O LATE R.K. JAIN AGED 40 YEARS

BEHIND KANHA KUNJ AKBARPUR KOLAR

ROAD BHOPAL THROGH R/O D.K. 3/49

DANISH

KUNJ

KOLAR

ROAD

BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI -ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B

BLOCK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION OF INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION

GOVT.

OF

INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 IA/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NODIA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR NSIC

MDBP BUILDING OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI 110020 (DELHI)

4.

STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION STATE OF M.P. THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTOR

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

46

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH/COUNSELING

AUTHORITY

STATE

OF

M.P.

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER/DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 5289 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

RADHARAMAN

AYURVEDA

MEDICAL

COLLEGE RESEARCH HOSPITAL THROUGH

MR. PRAVEEN SAXENA AGED ABOUT 47

YEARS

PRESIDENT

TAPASYA

SHIKSHA

SAMITI, HAVING ITS OFFICE AT 504 BDA

COMPLEX 7 NO. BUS STOP, SHIVAJI NAGAR

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

(BY SHRI KISHORE SHRIVASTAVA – SENIOR ADVOCATE AND SHRI

NAMAN NAGRATH – SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI NIKHIL

TIWARI, MS. ADITI SHRIVASTAVA, SHRI ATUL SHUKLA AND SHRI

DEVASHISH SAKALKAR – ADVOCATES)

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B

BLOCK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR

INDIAN

SYSTEM

OF

MEDICINE

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

47

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY 61-65 SEWA

MARG,

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK,

INDUSTRIAL AREA JANAKPURI, NEW

DELHI (DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 1A/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC-

MDBP BUILDING, OKHDA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER / DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELLING AUTHORITY STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

48

WRIT PETITION No. 5540 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

DEPARTMENT

OF

AYURVEDA

AND

COMUNITY IES UNIVERSITY BHOPAL RUN

BY INFOTECH EDUCATION SOCIETY (A

SOCIE

THROUGH

ITS

REGISTRAR

DR.

JYOTIRAM

SAWALE

S/O

SHRI

ARJUN

SAWALE AGED 45 YEARS C/O IES CAMPUS

KALKHEDA RATIBAD MAIN ROAD BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B

BLOCK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION OF INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA

JANAKPURI,

NEW

DELHI

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION,

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION,

GOVT.

OF

INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 1A/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE,

NOIDA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR, NSIC-

MDBP BUILDING, OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI (DELHI)

4.

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH 3RD FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

49

(MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION,

STATE

OF

MADHYA

PRADESH

THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER / DIRECTOR GROUND

FLOOR D WING SATPUDA BHAWAN,

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELING AUTHORITY, STATE OF

MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTORATE

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN,

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENTS-

UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE WITH MS. NAIN

JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE NCIM, SHRI

ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH AND SHRI

PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR NATIONAL

TESTING AGENCY)

WRIT PETITION No. 5541 of 2023

BETWEEN:-

OM AYURVEDIC MEDICAL COLLEGE AND

HOSPITAL

THROUGH

ITS

CHAIRMAN

SANTOSH PAL AGED 51 YEARS S/O LATE

SHRI RAM RATAN PAL C/O JAMTHI P.O.

BHARAT BHARATI B BETUL JAMTHI P.O.

BHARAT BHARATI BETUL RUN BY OM

SWASTH EVAM SHIKSHA PARISHAD BETUL

(A SOCIETY REGISTERED UNDER SOCIETIES

REGISTRATION

ACT

1973)

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....PETITIONER

^{(BY SHRI JAI KUMAR PILLAI - ADVOCATE)}

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

50

AND

1.

UNION

OF

INDIA

THROUGH

ITS

SECRETARY MINISTRY OF

AYUSH

GPO COMPLEX AYUSH BHAWAN B

BLOCK INA NEW DELHI (DELHI)

2.

NATIONAL COMMISSION ON INDIAN

SYSTEM OF MEDICINE THROUGH ITS

SECRETARY

61-65

SEWA

MARG

OPPOSITE

D-BLOCK

INDUSTRIAL

AREA JANAKPURI NEW DELHI 110058

(DELHI)

3.

NATIONAL

TESTING

AGENCY

(AUTONOMOUS

ORGANIZATION)

UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER

EDUCATION

MINISTRY

OF

EDUCATION

GOVT.

OF

INDIA

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY C-20 IA/8

SECTOR 62 IITK OUTREACH CENTRE

NODIA 201309 AND 1ST FLOOR NSIC

MDBP BUILDING OKHLA INDUSTRIAL

ESTATE NEW DELHI 110020 (DELHI)

4.

STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL

SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH

3RD

FLOOR

VALLABH

BHAWAN

BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)

5.

DIRECTORATE

OF

MEDICAL

EDUCATION STATE OF M.P. THROUGH

ITS

COMMISSIONER

/

DIRECTOR

GROUND FLOOR D WING SATPUDA

BHAWAN

BHOPAL

(MADHYA

PRADESH)

6.

DIRECTORATE

OF

AYUSH

/

COUNSELING AUTHORITY STATE OF

M.P. THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER /

DIRECTORATE GROUND FLOOR D

WING SATPUDA BHAWAN BHOPAL

(MADHYA PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

Signed by: PUSHPENDRA

PATEL

Signing time: 11-07-2023

16:21:52

Signature Not Verified

51

(SHRI

PIYUSH

JAIN

-

GOVERNMENT

ADVOCATE

FOR

THE

RESPONDENTS-STATE, SHRI VIKRAM SINGH – ADVOCATE FOR THE

RESPONDENTS-UNION OF INDIA, SHRI ADITYA SANGHI - ADVOCATE

WITH MS. NAIN JYOTI AND SHRI AMAN BAJPAI – ADVOCATES FOR THE

NCIM, SHRI ADITYA SINGH RAJPUT – ADVOCATE FOR THE NCH/CCH

AND SHRI PUSHPENDRA YADAV – ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR

NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Reserved on : 28.04.2023

Pronounced on : 10.07.2023

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

These petitions having been heard and reserved for orders, coming

on for pronouncement this day, Hon’ble Shri Justice Vivek Agarwal

passed the following: