2023 Supreme(Online)(MP) 11771
1
Cr. A. No.5710/2017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRAKASH CHANDRA GUPTA
ON THE 8TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2023
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5710 of 2017
BETWEEN:-
1.
MANSA @ MANSU S/O KAMAL SINGH
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS, BORDA DHAKAD
DISTRIC UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
GOVIND SINGH S/O KAMAL SINGH
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS, BORDA DHAKAD
DISTRICT UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(SHRI CHANDRA PRAKASH PUROHIT, ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
STATION HOUSE OFFICER
THROUGH P.S. KAYETHA
DISTRICT UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT/STATE
(SHRI BHASKAR AGRAWAL GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE)
Reserved on :
30.01.2023
Pronounced on : 08.02.2023
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This appeal having been heard and reserved for judgement,
coming on for pronouncement this day, Hon'ble Shri Prakash Chandra
2
Cr. A. No.5710/2017
Gupta pronounced the following:
Vivek Singh,Advocate General
Appellants have filed this appeal under Section 374 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “the “Cr.P.C.”),
against the judgement dated 16.11.2017 passed by the 10th Additional
Sessions Judge, District-Ujjain (M.P.) in Sessions Trial No.379/2015,
whereby learned Trial Court has convicted and sentenced the appellants
as under :-
S.
No.
Conviction
Sentence
Imprisonment
Fine
amount
Additional
imprisonment
in default of
payment of fine
Appellant – Mansa @ Mansu
1
302 of IPC
Life
imprisonment
Rs.5,000/-
RI for 04 months
Appellant – Govind Singh
1
302/34 of IPC
Life
imprisonment
Rs.5,000/-
RI for 04 months
Case of the prosecution in nutshell is that on 23.03.2015 at 9.00
PM, when complainant Ramu Bai (PW/1) and her son/deceased Devi
Singh were sitting in Otala (i.e. a platform) present in front of the house
of Dhapu Bai situated in front of the home of deceased, at village Borda
Dhakad, Police Station Kayetha, District Ujjain (M.P.), the appellants
came there by motorcycle. Appellant Govind Singh was riding the
motorcycle and appellant Mansa @ Mansu was pillion rider. Appellant
Mansa @ Mansu had fired gun three times on the deceased. Due to
3
gunshot injuries, the deceased fell down. The appellants fled away
towards the house of Karan Singh. Ramu Bai (PW/1) raised alarm by
shouting, hearing to which Anil Dhakad (PW/3) and other persons came
there. The inured/deceased was taken to the hospital at Dewas. The
doctor declared him dead. After receiving information, SHO Munni
Parihar (PW/14) went to the house of the deceased and lodged a dehati
nalisi (Ex.P/1), on the basis of the information given by Ramu Bai
(PW/1). On the basis of dehati nalisi (Ex.P/1), an FIR was lodged at
Police Station Kayetha on the same night. A merg intimation (Ex.P/25A)
was also registered at Police Station Dewas on the basis of intimation
(Ex.P/25) received from Dewas hospital. On the basis of merg intimation
(Ex.P/25A), a merg (Ex.D/3) was lodged at Police Station Kayetha.
3.
ASI Sanjay Saurashtre (PW/13), Police Station Dewas went to
mortuary room of Dewas hospital. He issued notice (Ex.P/26) and
prepared Lash Panchnama (Ex.P/27) in the presence of witnesses. ASI
Sanjay Saurashtre (PW/13) has issued request letter (Ex.P/8) to the
District Hospital, Dewas for post-mortem. Dr. Tariq Ahmad Sheikh
(PW/8) conducted post-mortem on 23.02.2015 at 10:00 AM and prepared
post-mortem report (Ex.P/9). During post-mortem, he preserved and
sealed a bullet and 2 pellets which were found in the wounds present on
the body of the deceased. He also preserved and sealed skin of both
hands, head, chest, left leg and clothes of the deceased and handed over
the same to the concerned constable. On 01.04.2015, HC Narendra Singh
(PW/5) seized sealed packets produced by constable Ashok Dubey from
4
District Hospital, Dewas and prepared seizure memo (Ex.P/5).
4.
During investigation SHO Munni Parihar (PW/14) on 23.02.2015
at about 08:00 AM inspected the place of incident in presence of Laxman
(PW/4) and prepared a spot map (Ex.P/4). On the same day at 10:30 AM,
she seized blood stained soil, simple soil and 3 empty cartridges from the
spot and prepared seizure memo (Ex.P/24A). SHO Munni Parihar
(PW/14) arrested appellant Mansa @ Mansu on 24.03.2015 at 10:10 PM
and on 02.04.2015 at 09:00 AM accused Govind Singh vide arrest memo
(Ex.P/18 and P/19, respectively). Disclosure memos (Ex.P/20, P/21 and
P/2, respectively) of appellant Mansa @ Mansu were prepared. On the
basis of disclosure memo (Ex.P/2), SHO Munni Parihar (PW/14)
recovered a country-made pistol at the instance of accused Mansa @
Mansu on 01.04.2015 at 10:45 AM vide seizure memo (Ex.P/3). On
02.04.2015 at 08:40 AM, she seized a motorcycle bearing registration
No.MP-41-MH-1603 from accused Govind Singh vide seizure memo
(Ex.P/22).
5.
On the request of SHO Police Station Kayetha and under direction
of Tehsildar Tarana, Halka Patwari Sanjay Lalawat (PW/7) went to the
place of incident and prepared a spot