2023 Supreme(Online)(MP) 6063
(1)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH,
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ROHIT ARYA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 244 of 2001.
BETWEEN :-
1. SONERAM S/O JAGNU SHAKYA, AGED 20
YEARS,
2. JASWANT S/O RAMDAYAL SHAKYA, AGED
24 YEARS,
BOTH ARE R/O VILLAGE SALAMPUR, P.S.
RAMPURKALA, DISTT. MORENA.
…..APPELLANTS
(BY SHRI RAJKUMAR SINGH KUSHWAH - ADVOCATE)
AND
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
POLICE STATION VIJAYPUR, DISTRICT
SHEOPURKALA (MADHYA PRADESH)
…..RESPONDENT
(BY MS. ANJALI GYANANI – PUBLIC PROSECUTOR)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reserved on
:
14.06.2023
Pronounced on
:
16.08.2023
Whether approved for reporting
:
Yes.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This appeal having been heard and reserved for judgment,
coming on for pronouncement this day, Justice Sanjeev S Kalgaonkar
pronounced the following:
(2)
Advocate General,Manoj Munshi,Pritam Singh,A.G.,Bl,Ol,Vk,Nn.Jain,U.Gajankush,Uk.Choukse,S.Verma,
1.
This criminal appeal, under Section 374 of Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 is directed against the judgment dated 26.03.2001
passed by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Sabalgarh, District
Morena in Sessions Trial No.192/1999, whereby the appellants Soneram
and Jaswant have been convicted and sentenced as under:-
S.No. Name of
accused
Section
Sentence
Fine
In default
stipulation
1
Soneram
and
Jaswant
302 of IPC life Imprisonment Rs.1000/-
six months
R.I.
2
Soneram
and
Jaswant
201 of IPC seven years of R.I. Rs.1000/-
six months
R.I.
3
Soneram
420 of IPC seven years of R.I. Rs.1000/-
six months
R.I.
2.
The Prosecution story, in nutshell, may be stated as under-
Around September to October, 1998, accused Soneram deceived
the complainant Prabhu that he will secure a job of Hostel Superintendent
at Bhopal for Harvilas, son of Prabhu but they will have to pay
Rs.60,000/- for securing the job. The complainant Prabhu paid
Rs.55,000/- to Soneram in the month of January, 1999. In order to
arrange the payment, Prabhu had taken loan from other persons. Harvilas
went along-with Soneram to Bhopal for getting the job as promised but
Soneram escaped from Railway Station, Bhopal. So, Harvilas returned to
his village Barakala, District Morena. After a few days, on 26.01.1999
Soneram and Jaswant again visited residence of Prabhu and stated that
job for Harvilas has been arranged, therefore, Harvilas may be sent with
them. Harvilas went to village Salampur on bicycle with Soneram. Three
days thereafter, accused Jaswant returned bicycle of Harvilas with an
(3)
inland letter to complainant Prabhu and Urmila Bai. In the said letter, it
was mentioned that Harvilas has reached Bhopal comfortably and
Rs.6,000/- be paid to Soneram.
3.
Naresh, a relative of Prabhu informed that Harvilas did not reach
village Salampur, therefore, Prabhu went to village Salampur and
enquired about Harvilas from Soneram. Soneram informed that Harvilas
is serving at Bhopal. Prabhu asked Soneram to accompany him to Bhopal
so that he may meet Harvilas. Soneram and Prabhu proceeded for Bhopal
by bus, but as the bus reached to Kailaras, Soneram fled away. On
suspicion, Prabhu lodged a report at Police Station Vijaypur, District
Sheopur on 01/02/1999 against the accused Soneram and Jaswant for
abduction of his son Harvilas. The inland letter of Harvilas delivered by
Jaswant to complainant Prabhu was seized.
4.
T. I. Suresh Chandra Dohare arrested Jaswant and Mithlesh (since
acquitted). Jaswant and Mithlesh on interrogation informed that dead
body of Harvilas is lying in a well of village Tailari. Pursuant to such
information given by Jaswant and Mithlesh in police custody, dead body
of Harvilas was recovered from a dry well at village Tailari, concealed
beneath dry leaves of sugarcane. Panchnama of dead body of Harvilas
(Exhibit P/2) was prepared and dead body was sent for autopsy. The
Medical Officer, on Post-mortem examination, opined that Harvilas had
died 5-10 days before the examination due to anti-mortem injury on his
skull.
5.
The full pant of deceased and a tomahawk (farsa) were recovered
at the instance of Jaswant. A pair of shoes and wooden stick were
recovered at the instance of Mithlesh. Soneram was arrested on
05.03.1999 and a blood-stained stone was recovered on his information .
6.
Sample of handwriting of accused Soneram and Jaswant was taken
and natural handwritings of accused Soneram, Jaswant and deceased
Harvilas were seized. The handwriting expert opined that the inland letter
(4)
was in the handwriting of Jaswant. After recording the statement of
witnesses and completing the investigation, police station Vijaypur
submitted charge-sheet against accused Soneram, Jaswant and Mithlesh.
7.
The Trial Court framed charges against Soneram under Section
420, 302, 201 of IPC and charges under Section 302, 201 of IPC were
framed against Jaswant and Mithlesh. Learned Sessions Judge, after
Trial, passed the impu