2024 Supreme(Online)(MP) 14972
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
SMT. JUSTICE ANURADHA SHUKLA, J
Manish Gupta – Appellant
Versus
The State Of Madhya Pradesh – Respondent
MCRC 31538/2023
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Excise Offenses
Act Referred
Madhya Pradesh Excise Act : S.34(2),S.42
Headnote
(B) Criminal liability - Mere ownership of a vehicle does not absolve responsibility in cases of illicit transportation of goods - Evidence of complicity was established through statements indicating the transportation of excess liquor. (Paras 3, 7)
Facts of the case:
The applicant was implicated in an FIR for transporting illicit liquor based on police action following a tip-off, despite claiming innocence and absence during the incident.
Findings of Court:
The court found no grounds to quash the FIR, emphasizing that absence from the scene does not negate liability in such cases.
Issues: The main issues included the applicant's alleged complicity in the crime and the validity of the evidence presented for quashing the FIR.
Ratio Decidendi: The court ruled that ownership of the vehicle does not exempt the applicant from liability, and absence from the scene does not establish innocence.
Result: Petition dismissed.
,Advocate General
This petition, filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973, aims to challenge the registration of FIR at Crime No.285/2023 in Police Station, Gohparu, district Shahdol, under Sections 34(2) and 42 of the Madhya Pradesh Excise Act, 1915 against the applicant.
2. The brief facts necessary for the decision of this petition are that on 3.5.2023 information was received about the transportation of illicit liquor, therefore the police party reached on the intimated spot; a truck bearing registration no.MP-18-GA-4358 was stopped by the raiding party and was also searched; the truck driver had the permit but that was of different date and the quantity of liquor was comparatively very high than what was mentioned in the bill; hence the liquor was seized and the FIR was registered both against the driver of the vehicle Mukesh Choudhary and its owner Manish Gupta, who is the applicant herein. It is submitted that after investigation, charge-sheet has also been filed in the case.
3. The grounds raised in this petition for quashing of FIR are that the applicant is malafidely implicated in the case; he was merely the owner of vehicle and on the basis of memorandum of co-accused, namely Mukesh Choudhary, he is roped in the case; the applicant was not present on the spot at the time of seizure nor was present when the liquor was being loaded in the vehicle; the liquor seized is not of intoxicating nature or unfit for human consumption. It is, therefore, prayed that the FIR and all consequential proceedings registered against the applicant be quashed.
4. State has opposed this petition. 5. The arguments of both the sides have been heard.
6. The applicant has relied upon some CCTV footage and CCTV Panchnama to press upon the fact of his innocence but these are the pieces of evidence which cannot be examined and evaluated here, hence the request for quashment of proceedings on this basis cannot be accepted.
7. It is argued that the applicant was not present at the time when the liquor was being loaded in the vehicle nor was present when the seizure was made but these facts are again the matter of evidence and further mere absence from the scene of crime would not establish the innocence in such kind of crime. The applicant has relied upon the statements of Rakesh Chand Awadhiya, Incharge Officer, Bhandagar Jamua, district Shahdol, in which he has mentioned that the liquor was handed over to the licencee Rakesh Singh Parihar but these statements show the complicity of applicant in the crime as they reveal that only the permitted quantity was handed over to Rakesh Singh Parihar while the truck was found to be transporting huge quantity of liquor which was in addition to the permitted quantity.
8. Taking all these facts into consideration, this court finds no justified reason to quash the FIR and the incidental proceedings registered against the applicant on the basis of Crime No.285/2023 at Police Station, Gohparu, district Shahdol.
9. Accordingly, the petition is dismissed and disposed of.