SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(Online)(MP) 121782

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH AT JABALPUR


BEFORE HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA


SECOND APPEAL No. 770 of 1999


SMT.VIDHYA WATI BAI & ORS. Versus KASHI RAM & ANR.


Appearance:

Shri Purushottam Narain Pathak - Advocate for the appellants.

Shri Krishan Kumar Kushwaha - Advocate for the respondent no.1.

Shri Ramji Pandey - Govt. Adv. for the respondent no.2/State.


Reserved on : 20.08.2026

Pronounced on : 02.09.2026


(PRANAY VERMA)


JUDGE

Advocates:
N.jha,Sanjay Roy,,Rp.mishra,,A.g.,Rl.ariha,Pramod Verma,Sushila Ariha

J U D G M E N T

This appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been preferred by the appellant/plaintiff, being aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated 19.03.1999 passed in Civil Appeal No. 2-A/1998 by the Additional District Judge, Sohagpur affirming the judgment and decree dated 01.12.1997 passed in C.S. No. 152-A/1996 by the Civil Judge Class-1, Pipariya, District Hoshangabad.

2. As per the plaintiff, he has purchased Khasra No. 283/4, area 0.40 acre, Gram Pipariya, from Moolchand Maurya by way of an unregistered sale deed dated 11.06.1970. He had obtained possession of the land purchased by him and he has been in possession ever since then to the knowledge of defendant No. 1 for a period of more than 12 years hence has acquired title thereto by virtue of adverse possession. He had given an application for mutation of his name over the suit land, which was eventually decided against him hence the claim has been instituted by him for declaration of his title to the suit land.

3. The defense of defendant No. 1 was that plaintiff has not purchased Khasra No. 283/4 from Moolchand. The same is not recorded in the name of Moolchand in the revenue records. The proceedings before the revenue Courts were in respect of Khasra No. 283/9 and that plaintiff has not impleaded the necessary parties to the suit.

4. The Courts below have dismissed the plaintiff's claim by holding that he has failed to prove that he has acquired title to the suit land by virtue of adverse possession.

5. By order dated 22.07.2002, the appeal was admitted on the following substantial questions of law:

i) Whether mere fact that survey number of land was not correctly mentioned in the sale deed while boundaries of the land was mentioned which were in consonance with the disputed land. In such circumstances the Court below erred in dismissing the suit of appellant ?

ii) Whether in a deed whereas the survey number was given which were found incorrect then the boundaries given in the sale deed will prevail ?

6. Even if it is assumed that the Khasra number of the land was not correctly mentioned in the sale deed executed in favour of the plaintiff and the boundaries of the land which were mentioned therein are in respect of the very suit land since it is always the boundaries which prevail over the Khasra number and the area, it is, however, required to be seen whether the plaintiff has acquired title to the suit land by virtue of adverse possession.

7. The plaintiff has purchased the suit land from Moolchand Maurya. He has not been impleaded as a party. Defendant No. 1 has been impleaded as a party, who is Kashiram, son of Deendayal Maurya, but nowhere in the plaint it has been stated that it is Kashiram, who is the owner of the land. Adverse possession can be claimed only against the true owner of the suit land and not against any third person. There is no mention whatsoever in the plaint or in the statement of the plaintiff as to who is the real owner of the suit land against whom adverse possession is being claimed by him. The defendant had specifically taken an objection in his written statement to the effect that he is not the owner of the suit land and it is some other persons, who are the owners thereof. Despite naming of those persons, the plaintiff has chosen not to implead them as parties to the suit. Thus, even if it is assumed that the plaintiff has been in possession of the suit land for a period of more than 12 years, but in absence of claiming adverse possession against the true owner or not even stating as to who is the true owner of the suit land, his claim for adverse possession cannot be maintained.

8. A perusal of the sale deed, Exhibit D/1, unmistakably shows that the seller therein is Moolchand, son of Rahmal Kachi but there is no plea of adverse possession against him.

9. From a perusal of the entire plaint, it is seen that though plaintiff has pleaded acquisition of title to the suit

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top