Date of pronouncement:-31.12.2025 IN THE NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION NEW DELHI FIRST APPEAL NO. 440 OF 2018 (Against the Order dated 17.01.2018 in CC No. 17/13 of the State Commission Maharashtra Nagpur Circuit Bench)

1. The Chief Officer, Nagpur housing & Area Development Board, (A MHADA unit),Civil Lines, Nagpur Maharashtra.

2. The Chief Executive Officer, Maharashtra Housing & Area Development Authority, GRIHA Nirman Bhavan, Bandra East, Mumbai-400055., through its Vice-Chairman & CEO, Mumbai, Maharashtra.

….. Appellants Versus

1. Mrs. Usha Suresh Thakare, C/o. Dr. Suresh Thakare, AchalpurRoad, Paratwada, TAH. Achalpur Dist. Amravati, Maharashtra.

2. M/s. IVRCL infrastructure and Project Ltd., Having its local office at, MHADA city, Near Geeta Mandir, Subhash Road, Nagpur, Through its Chairman cum Managing Director, Nagpur, Maharashtra.

3. Mitali Co-Operative Housing Society, Through its President, having its office at MHADA City, Near Geeta Mandir, Subhash Road, Nagpur, Maharashtra. … Respondents FIRST APPEAL NO. 2334 OF 2019 (Against the Order dated 17.01.2018 in CC No. 17/13 of the State Commission Maharashtra Nagpur Circuit Bench)

MRS. USHA SURESH THAKARE C/o Dr. Suresh Thakre, Achalpur Road, Paratwada, Taluka Achalpur, District Amaravati ….. Appellants Versus (1) The Chief Officer, Nagpur Housing and Area Development Board, (A MHADA UNIT) MHADA Gruha Nirman Bhavan, Civil Lines, Nagpur.

(2) Maharashtra Housing & Area Development Authority, Griha Nirman Bhavan, Bandra East, Mumbai 400055 through its Vice-Chairman and CEO. …. Respondents FIRST APPEAL NO. 1112 OF 2018 (Against the Order dated 23.03.2018 in CC No. 69/2016 of the State Commission Maharashtra Nagpur Circuit Bench)

1. The Chief Officer, Nagpur Housing and Area Development Board (A MHADA Unit), Civil Lines, Nagpur

2. The Estate Manager, Nagpur Housing & Area Development Board A MHADA Unit, Civil Lines, Nagpur

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Maharashtra Housing & Area Development Authority, Griha Nirman Bhavan, Bandra (East), Mumbai-400055 ….. Appellants Versus Sh. Ajay Radhelal Shranagat, R/o House No. 734, Village Navin Yerkheda, Tah & Post- Kamptee, Distt.

Nagpur-441001, Nagpur, Maharashtra. …… Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1113 OF 2018 (Against the Order dated 23.03.2018 in CC No. 70/2016 of the State Commission Maharashtra Nagpur Circuit Bench)

1. The Chief Officer, Nagpur Housing and Area Development Board (A MHADA Unit), Civil Lines, Nagpur

2. The Estate Manager, Nagpur Housing & Area Development Board A MHADA Unit, Civil Lines, Nagpur

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Maharashtra Housing & Area Development Authority, Griha Nirman Bhavan, Bandra (East), Mumbai-400055 ….. Appellants Versus Sh. Ashwin Kumar Thakkar S/o Odha Vajibhai Thakkar R/o Ring Avantibai Chowk, Bajrangi Bazar, Near Dosa HUT, Gondia-4416114. …… Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1114 OF 2018 (Against the Order dated 23.03.2018 in CC No. 96/2016 of the State Commission Maharashtra Nagpur Circuit Bench)

1. The Chief Officer, Nagpur Housing and Area Development Board (A MHADA Unit), Civil Lines, Nagpur

2. The Estate Manager, Nagpur Housing & Area Development Board A MHADA Unit, Civil Lines, Nagpur

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Maharashtra Housing & Area Development Authority, Griha Nirman Bhavan, Bandra (East), Mumbai-400055 ….. Appellants Versus Sh. Sayyad Shaneali S/o Nadar Ali R/o Flat No. 68, Vidharbh Housing, Colony, Ramnagar, Datala Road, Distt. Chandrapur-441401….(deceased)

Through LRs Mrs. Asifa Bano Wd/o Shri Sayyad Shaneali, R/o 68, Vidharbha Housing Board Colony, Ramnagar, Chandrapur – 442 401. ……Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1115 OF 2018 (Against the Order dated 23.03.2018 in CC No. 97/2016 of the State Commission Maharashtra Nagpur Circuit Bench)

1. The Chief Officer, Nagpur Housing and Area Development Board (A MHADA Unit), Civil Lines, Nagpur

2. The Estate Manager, Nagpur Housing & Area Development Board A MHADA Unit, Civil Lines, Nagpur

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Maharashtra Housin