Back
2023 Supreme(Online)(NGT) 4731
BEFORE THE NATIONAL GREEN TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH NEW DELHI EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 26/2023 IN ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 639/2018 IN THE MATTER OF:
SHAILESH SINGH S/o Mr. Babu Singh Office Add: 41B, Hanuman Road, Sansad Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi-110001 ...Applicant(s)
Versus
1 STATE OF HARYANA Through Chief Secretary, 4th floor, Haryana Civil Secretariat, Sector-1, Chandigarh - 160001
2 HARYANA STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD Through its Member Secretary, C-11, Sector-6, Panchkula Haryana - 134109
3 CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD Through its Member Secretary, “Parivesh Bhawan”, East Arjun Nagar, Near Karkarduma Court, Shandara, New Delhi - 110092
4 CENTRAL GROUND WATER AUTHORITY Through its Chairman, 18/11 Jamnagar House, Mansingh Road, New Delhi - 110011
5 MINSTRY OF WATER RESOURCES, RIVER DEVELOPMENT GANGA REJUVENATION Through its Secretary, 627, Shram Shakti Bhawan, Rail Marg, New Delhi - 110001
6 ASIAN COLOUR COATER ISPAT LTD.
7-12, Sector-6, HSIIDC, Bawal District Rewari, Haryana - 125501
7 KANSAI NEROLAC PAINTS LTD.
Plot No. 36, Sector-7, HSIIDC Growth Centre, Bawal, District Rewari, Haryana –123501
8 M/s SATISH STEEL UDYOG HSIIDC, Samalkha, District Panipat Haryana - 132101
9 M/S ANANDTEX INDIA PVT. LTD.
Vill- Brahman Majra, District Panipat Haryana - 132101
10 M/S ANANDTEX INTERNATIONAL PVT. LTD.
Risalu Road. District Panipat Haryana - 132101
11 BINDAL INDUSTRIES Plot No. 29, HSIIDC Industrial Area, Samalkha, District Panipat, Haryana - 132101
12 M/S ANIL SPINNERS Plot No. H-19, 20 Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132101
13 M/S GUPTA INTERNATIONAL Pasina Khurd Road, Sewah, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
14 M/S HOME TRENDS E-2, Old Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
15 M/S JAGRITI DRAPES New Rishalu Road, District Panipat Haryana - 132103
16 M/S JAI UDYOG H-3, Industrial Area. District- Panipat Haryana - 132104
17 M/S KANODIA GLOBAL PVT. LTD.
Pasina Khurd Road, Sewah, District- Panipat, Haryana 132108
18 M/S KHUSHBOO PROCESSOR Plot No. 30, Sector- 25, Part-II, Industrial Area HUDA, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
19 M/S JINDAL WOOLEN INDUSTRIES T-2, Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132104
20 M/S JINDAL YARN PVT. LTD. E-1. Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana Pin code - 132103
21 M/S DERBY DAIRY PVT. LTD.
V.P.O. Jattal Road, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
22 M/S LALLY AUTOMOBILES (INDIA) PVT. LTD.
708/798, Opp. DAV Police Public School, G.T. Road, Siwah, District Panipat, Haryana - 132108
23 M/S LOVELY MATCHING CENTRE Plot No. 25, Near Blind School, Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132104
24 M/S METRO AGRI INDUSTRIES LTD.
Village- Kakoda, Israna, District Panipat Haryana - 132107
25 M/S PARV TEX INDIA Bapoli Road, Village- Behrampur, Tehsil- Bapoli, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
26 M/S NAVEEN PROCESSORS Plot No. 52, Sector- 25, Phase-1, HUDA, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
27 M/S PRAKASH WOOLEN MILLS E-6 Industrial Area, Opp. Kherikeha Phatak, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
28 M/S PRJ SANITARY APPLIANCES (P) LTD.
34, HSIDC Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
29 M/S MITTAL STEELS G.T. Road, Industrial Area, Samalkha, District Panipat, Haryana - 132107
30 M/S RANGAI UDYOG M-11, Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
31 M/S RKH HANDICRAFT (P) LTD.
Bath-N-Beyond, 188, Sector-25, Part-III HUDA, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
32 M/S SAINIK INDUSTRIES H-53, Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
33 M/S SHIV POLYMERS (TEXTILE INDUSTRY)
Vill- Balana, District Panipat Haryana - 132103
34 M/S SHIVALIK PRINTS E-59, Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132104
35 M/S TRIVENI INDUSTRIES H-41-42, Industrial Area, District Panipat Haryana - 132104
36 M/S SHREE KRISHNA INDUSTRIES E-55, Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132104
37 M/S NILE OVERSEAS VIII- Pardhana, Tehsil- Israna, District Panipat, Haryana - 132101
38 M/S N.K. FASTENER Biholi- Bhapra Road, Samalkha, Dist- Panipat, Haryana - 132107
39 M/S VIJ ENGINEERING & CONSULTANTS (P) LTD.
78 KM Mile Stone. G.T. Road, Vill- Karhans Khalila More, Samalkha, District Panipat Haryana - 132104
40 M/S VSP ENTERPRISES (P) LTD. (UNIT-II)
Chulkana Road, Near G.A. College Volk Kiwana, Samalkha, District Panipat, Haryana - 132104
41 M/S CHROMA PROCESSOR (TEXTILE DYEING)
Vill- Sewah Near Choutala Road, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
42 M/S GOVIND PROCESS Plot No. 53, Sector-25, Part-I HUDA, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
43 M/S GOLD SPIN INDIA PVT. LTD.
H7 to 10, Industrial Area, District- Panipat Haryana - 132103
44 M/S SHREE KRISHNA INDUSTRIES E-55, Industrial Area, District Panipat, Haryana - 132104
45 M/S SUBH LAKSHMI TEXTILES (P) LTD.
E-9, Industrial Area, District Panipat Haryana - 132104
46 M/S SUNNY INTERNATIONAL LTD.
10th Km stone, Gohana Road, Vill- Naultha, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
47 M/S FAZE THREE LTD. (Textile Mill)
Opp. BBMB Residence Colony, Sector- 29, G T. Road, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
48 M/S MITTAL STEELS G.T. Road, Industrial Area, Samalkha, District Panipat, Haryana - 132104
49 M/S CHARAK PHARMA PVT. LTD.
Jaurasi Road, Pauti Village, G.T. Road, Samalkha, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
50 M/S GRM OVERSEAS LTD. (RICE MILL)
Gohana Road, Vill- Naultha, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
51 M/S HARISONS AUTOMOBILES Plot No. 23, Sector-25, Part-I, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
52 M/S JINDAL SPINNING MILLS LTD.
E-51, Industrial Area, District Panipat Haryana - 132103
53 M/S RAGHAV WOOLLEN MILLS Near Nimbri Chowk, Bapoli Road, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
54 M/S SR OVERSEAS Dadola Road, Bapoli District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
55 M/S SACHDEV HOME FURNISHING (P) LTD.
Vill- Kurar, Sanoli Road, Tehsil- Bapoli, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
56 M/S SARV INDIA HOME FURNISHING Sanoli Road, 11 km Stone, Near Krishna Gaushala, Near- Kurar Town, VOP- Jalalpur, District Panipat Haryana - 132103
57 M/S SHAKUMBRA SPINNERS Post box No. 81, Rishalu Road, Sewah, District Panipat Haryana - 132103
58 M/S SSA INTERNATIONAL LTD.
67th Mile Stone, G.T. Road, Vill- Bhodwal Mari, Samlkha, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
59 M/S SWAN K MOTORS (P) LTD.
Near Toll Plaza, G.T. Road, District Panipat, Haryana - 132103
60 M/S UNIQUE PROCESSORS H-24-25, Industrial Area, District Panipat Haryana - 132103
61 M/S VARDHMAN YARN T-6, Industrial Area, District Panipat Haryana - 132103
62 M/s AADIT MOTORS (P.) LTD. (FORD SHOWROOM)
Sector-8, G.T. Road.
Near Toll Plaza, District Panipat, Haryana - 132101
63 M/S ATLAS CYCLES (HARYANA) LTD.
Atlas Premises, Atlas Road, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
64 M/S BHARAT LEATHER MANUFACTURERES PVT. LTD.
18th Mile Stone, G.T. Road, Nathupur, Dist- Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
65 M/S BIO SYNERGY INDIA Vill- Sanpera, Post- Bhigan, Tehsil- Gannaur, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131101
66 M/S CHINTPURNI FOODS PVT. LTD.
29 Milestone, Gohana, District Sonipat Haryana - 131001
67 M/S CHOUDHARY CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES
22/2, G.T. Road, Bahalgarh, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
68 M/S COMBITIC GLOBAL CALPET PVT. LTD.
M-15, D-2, D-3, Industrial Area, District Sonipat Haryana - 131001
69 M/S CORAL DRUGS PVT. LTD. (UNIT-II)
12-A & 49, HSIIDC Industrial Area, Murthal, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
70 M/S GALAXY LEATHERS Narela Sonepat Road, Viii- Akbarpur Barota, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
71 M/S INDIAN LEATHERS 18th Km Mile Stone, G.T. Road, Nathupur, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
72 M/S JPG ELECTRICALS PVT. LTD.
Kila No. 4/7, 17, Vill- Kheri Manjat, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131103
73 M/S KOHINOOR FOODS LTD.
42-43 Km Stone, G.T. Road, Sultanpur, Bahalgarh, District Sonipat Haryana - 131021
74 M/S KASHMIR KATHA INDUSTRIES PVT. LTD.
G.T. Road, Near Nidhu Cinema, Kundli, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131103
75 M/S MAHESH WOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD.
Khewra Road, Bahalgarh, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131021
76 M/S MALWA AUTO SALES PVT. LTD.
G.T. Road, Kundli, District Sonipat Haryana -131028
77 M/S MALWA MOTORS SALES PVT. LTD. (CHEVORELET)
G.T. Road, Kundli District Sonipat Haryana - 131028
78 M/S MANNAT HAVELI (M/S LAGUNA HOSPITALITY)
NH-1, Bhagan Chowk, G.T. Road, Murthal, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131027
79 M/S M.R. ENGINEERS Plot No. 33, HSIIDC, Murthal, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
80 M/S NOVATEUR ELECTRICAL DIGITAL SYSTEM PVT. LTD.
51 KM G.T. Karnal Road, Murthal, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131027
81 M/S P.D. METAL CRAFT PVT. LTD.
VIII- Nathupur District Sonipat, Haryana - 131029
82 M/S PARUTHI ENGINEERS PVT. LTD. (UNIT-II)
VIII- Dhaturi, District Sonipat.
Haryana - 131039
83 M/S PRIUS AUTO INDUSTRIES Kila No. 9/5/1 (2-2), Vill- Nathupur, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131029
84 M/S RADHA GOVIND INDUSTEIES Vill- Kakori, District Sonipat Haryana - 131001
85 M/S SAHIL AUTOMOBILES PVT. LTD.
Rohtak Road, Sector-15, Fly Over, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
86 M/S SHAKTI PRODUCTS Bahalgarh, Sonipat Road, Jat Joshi, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131021
87 M/S SHIV SHAKTI ENTERPRISES LTD.
Vill- Ram Nagar, Tehsil- Ganaur, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131039
88 M/S SR KATHA Vill- Narela Road, Kundll, PIO Maniyari, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131028
89 M/S UNITED FOODS PVT. LTD.
Vill- Wazidpur Saboli, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131029
90 M/S VSP ENTERPRISES (P) LTD
60 Km Stone, G.T. Road, Vill- Barhi District Sonipat, Haryana – 131101
91 M/S ZURUDH PHARMA LLP Vill- Dhaturi, Ganaur, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131101
92 M/S VIDYA SAGAR FOODS (P) LTD.
Plot No.- D-56 Piau Maniyari, Narela Road, Kundli, District Sonipat Haryana - 131028
93 M/S KOHINOOR FOODS LTD.
42-43 km Stone, G.T. Road, Sultanpur, Bahalgarh, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131021
94 M/S B.K. ANAND FOODS PVT. LTD.
Plot No. 67, Murthal Industrial Area, Murthal, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
95 M/S MITRA SPINNING MILLS PVT. LTD.
Khasra No. 26-3/1, 3/2, VIII-Safiabad, District Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
96 M/S K K ENTERPRISES Plot No. 7B/5, MIE Part-B, Bahadurgarh, Haryana – 124507
97 SHRI DURGA SHANKER MISHRA Chief Secretary, Govt. of Uttar Pradesh, 101 B-Block, Lok Bhawan, UP Secretariat, District - Lucknow-226001
98 SHRI AJAY KUMAR SHARMA Member Secretary, Uttar Pradesh Pollution Control Board, TC-12V, Vibhuti Khand, Gomti Nagar, District – Lucknow -226010
99 DR. S.S. SANDHU Chief Secretary, Govt. of Uttarakhand
4, Subhash Road, Uttarakhand Secretariat, District – Dehradun - 248001
100 SHRI S.K. PATTNAIK Member Secretary, Uttarakhand Pollution Control Board, Gaura Devi Bhawan, 46B, IT Park, Sahastradhara, District -Dehradun Uttarakhand- 248001
101 SHRI K.S. JAWAHAR REDDY Chief Secretary, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh Building No.1, 1st Floor, Interim Government Complex, A.P. Secretariat, Velagapudi, Guntur-522002, 102 SHRI B. DREEDHAR Member Secretary, Andhra Pradesh Pollution Control Board, Paryavaran Bhawan, APIIC Colony Road, Gurunanak Colony, Autonagar, Vijayawada-520007
103 SMT. USHA SHARMA Chief Secretary, Govt. of Rajasthan Chief Secretary Office, Secretariat, District- Jaipur Rajasthan- 302005
104 SHRI VIJAI N.
Member Secretary, Rajasthan Pollution Control Board
4, Jhalana Industrial Area, Jhalana Doongri, District- Jaipur-302004
105 SHRI IQBAL SINGH BAINS Chief Secretary, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh MP Mantralaya, Vallabh Bhawan, District –Bhopal -462004
106 MADHYA PRADESH POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD Through its Member Secretary, Paryavaran Parisar, E-5, Arera Colony, District - Bhopal - 462016
107 SHRI NARESH KUMAR Chief Secretary, Govt. of Delhi
3rd Floor, Delhi Secretariat, I.P. Estate, New Delhi-110002
108 DR. K.S. JAYACHANDRAN Member Secretary, Delhi Pollution Control Committee, 6th Floor, C-wing, Delhi Secretariat, I.P. Estate, New Delhi-110002 ...Respondent(s)
Counsels for Applicant(s):
Ms. Preeti Singh and Mr. Sunklan Porwal, Advocates in Execution Application CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRAKASH SHRIVASTAVA, CHAIRPERSON HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR AGARWAL, JUDICIAL MEMBER HON’BLE DR. A. SENTHIL VEL, EXPERT MEMBER RESERVED ON: FEBRUARY 27, 2024 PRONOUNCED ON: MAY 29, 2024
JUDGMENT
BY HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR AGARWAL, JUDICIAL MEMBER
1. This Execution Application (hereinafter referred to as ‘EA’) has been filed by Shailesh Singh in Original Application No. 639/2018 (hereinafter referred to as ‘OA’), Shailesh Singh vs. State of Haryana & Others with a prayer for execution of orders and directions dated 05.11.2019, 25.08.2020 and 23.03.2021 passed in the above OA.
2. Applicant seeking execution has also prayed for issue of a direction of civil imprisonment or stopping of salary of erring officers who had irresponsibly handled the situation resulting in further degradation of environment.
3. OA was filed vide memo of application dated 31.08.2018 by Shailesh Singh impleading 96 respondents which included State of Haryana through Chief Secretary as respondent 1, Haryana State Pollution Control Board (hereinafter referred to as ‘HSPCB’) as respondent 2; Central Pollution Control Board (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPCB’) as respondent 3; Central Ground Water Authority (hereinafter referred to as ‘CGWA’) as respondent 4; Ministry of Water Resources, River Development & Ganga Rejuvenation (hereinafter referred to as ‘MoWR, RD&GR’) as respondent
5 and 91 private parties i.e., various industries.
4. Private respondents included 02 industries namely Asian Colour Coater Ispat Ltd. as respondent 6 and Kansai Nerolac Paints Ltd. as respondent 7, which were functioning in District Rewari. 55 industrial units functioning in District Panipat were impleaded as respondents 08 to 62 and the same are as under:
i. M/s Satish Steel Udyog
ii. M/s Anandtex India Pvt. Ltd
iii. M/s Anandtex International Pvt. Ltd.
iv. M/s Bindal Industries
v. M/s Anil Spinners
vi. M/s Gupta International
vii. M/s Home Trends
viii. M/s Jagriti Drapes
ix. M/s Jai Udyog
x. M/s Kanodia Global Pvt. Ltd.
xi. M/s Khushboo Processor
xii. M/s Jindal Woolen Industries
xiii. M/s Jindal Yarn Pvt. Ltd
xiv. M/s Derby Dairy Pvt. LTD.
xv. M/s Lally Automobiles (India) Pvt. Ltd
xvi. M/s Lovely Matching Centre
xvii. M/s Metro Agri Industries Ltd.
xviii. M/s ParvTex India
xix. M/s Naveen Processors
xx. M/s Prakash Woolen Mills
xxi. M/s PRJ Sanitary Appliances (P) Ltd.
xxii. M/s Mittal Steels
xxiii. M/s Rangai Udyog
xxiv. M/s Rkh Handicraft (P) Ltd.
xxv. M/s Sainik Industries
xxvi. M/s Shiv Polymers (Textile Industry)
xxvii. M/s Shivalik Prints
xxviii. M/s Triveni Industries
xxix. M/s Shree Krishna Industries
xxx. M/s Nile Overseas
xxxi. M/s N.K. Fastener
xxxii. M/s Vij Engineering & Consultants (P) Ltd.
xxxiii. M/s VSP Enterprises (P) Ltd.
xxxiv. M/s Chroma Processor (Textile Dyeing)
xxxv. M/s Govind Process xxxvi. M/s Gold Spin India Pvt. Ltd.
xxxvii. M/s Shree Krishna Industries xxxviii. M/s Subh Lakshmi Textiles (P) Ltd.
xxxix. M/s Sunny International Ltd. xl. M/s Faze Three Ltd. (Textile Mill)
xli. M/s Mittal Steels xlii. M/s Charak Pharma Pvt. Ltd.
xliii. M/s GRM Overseas Ltd. (Rice Mill)
xliv. M/s Harisons Automobiles xlv. M/s Jindal Spinning Mills Ltd.
xlvi. M/s Raghav Woollen Mills xlvii. M/s SR Overseas xlviii. M/s Sachdev Home Furnishing (P) ltd.
xlix. M/s Sarv India Home Furnishing l. M/s Shalumbra Spinners li. M/s SSA International Ltd.
lii. M/s Swan K Motors (P) Ltd.
liii. M/s Unique Processors
liv. M/s Vardhman Yarn
lv. M/s Aadit Motors (P.) Ltd. (Ford Showroom)
5. 33 industrial units functioning in District Sonipat were impleaded as respondents 63 to 95 and the same are as under:
i. M/s Atlas Cycles (Haryana) Ltd.
ii. M/s Bharat Leather Manufacturers Pvt. Ltd.
iii. M/s Bio Synergy India
iv. M/s Chintpurni Foods Pvt. Ltd.
v. M/s Choudhary Chemical Industries
vi. M/s Combitic Global Calpet Pvt. Ltd.
vii. M/s Coral Drugs Pvt. Ltd. (Unit-II)
viii. M/s Galaxy Leathers
ix. M/s Indian Leathers
x. M/s JPG Electricals Pvt. Ltd.
xi. M/s Kohinoor Foods Ltd.
xii. M/s Kashmir Katha Industries Pvt. Ltd.
xiii. M/s Mahesh Wood Products Pvt. Ltd.
xiv. M/s Malwa Auto Sales Pvt. Ltd.
xv. M/s Malwa Motors Sales Pvt. Ltd. (Chevorelet)
xvi. M/s Mannat Haveli (M/s Laguna Hospitality)
xvii. M/s M.R. Engineers
xviii. M/s Novateur Elect
