SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(Online)(Pat) 18135

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Bibek Chaudhuri, J
Ravi Prakash Saxena @ Ravi Prakash – Appellant
Versus
Priyanka Rani – Respondent
CRIMINAL REVISION No.676 of 2024



Important Points

Maintenance awards under Section 125 Cr.P.C. must be based on a reasoned assessment of both parties' assets and liabilities through mandatory disclosure affidavits, considering the wife's actual or potential earning capacity to determine if she is truly unable to maintain herself.

Subject

Criminal - Maintenance

Act Referred

Headnote

(A) Family Courts Act, 1981 - Section 19(4) - Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - Section 125 - Maintenance - Earning capacity and disclosure of assets - Maintenance claims require mandatory disclosure affidavits of assets and liabilities as per the guidelines established by the Hon’ble Supreme Court to ensure transparency and balanced assessment of needs and quantum based on parties’ status and income (Paras 22, 29).

(B) Maintenance - Entitlement - A wife who is highly qualified and capable of earning for her livelihood, or has suppressed material facts concerning previous alimony and assets, may be considered as not being "unable to maintain herself," which is a prerequisite for maintenance under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C. (Paras 19, 25).

Facts of the case:
An appeal was filed by the husband against an order directing him to pay Rs. 20,000 per month as maintenance to his wife. The husband contended that the wife had received Rs. 40 lakhs as alimony from a previous marriage, was highly qualified with an M.Sc. in Botany and a diploma in Japanese, and had fraudulenty declared herself unmarried at the time of marriage. The wife alleged cruelty, dowry demands, and claimed she had handed over her previous alimony to the husband.

Findings of Court:
The court found that the trial court passed the maintenance order in a mechanical manner, overlooking the mandatory guidelines regarding the filing of affidavits of assets and liabilities. It observed that the wife's earning capacity and potential assets were not properly considered, and there was a lack of transparency in the financial disclosures.

Issues: Whether the maintenance order was sustainable given the failure to obtain assets and liabilities affidavits and whether the wife's qualification and previous alimony affected her entitlement to maintenance.

Ratio Decidendi: The court ruled that before passing a final order of maintenance, the family court is under a statutory obligation to direct both parties to file affidavits of assets and liabilities to conclude the amount of maintenance based on status, assets, and earning capacity.

Result: Revisional application allowed; impugned order quashed and set aside.

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • family law
    • maintenance and alimony
      • process and evidence (Para 28, 29)
      • eligibility and quantum (Para 25)
    • matrimonial disputes
  • practice and procedure
    • judicial review / revisional jurisdiction (Para 30, 31)
    • affidavit requirements (Para 29, 33)

Advocates:
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Amit Mallick
For the Respondents: Shweta Priya

Table of Contents

1. The trial court failed to evaluate assets, liabilities, and income of both parties through affidavits as mandated, leading to an inadequately reasoned maintenance order. (Para 29 , 30 )

2. Courts must mandatorily direct parties to file affidavits of assets and liabilities to determine maintenance; failure to do so renders an order improper and unsustainable. (Para 29 , 30 )

3. Impugned maintenance order set aside; parties directed to file affidavits of assets and liabilities, and trial court ordered to pass a fresh judgment within four weeks. (Para 31 , 33 , 34 )

4. Is the filing of affidavits of assets and liabilities mandatory in maintenance proceedings?

Yes, following the Supreme Court guidelines in Rajnish v. Neha, courts are under a statutory obligation to require parties to file affidavits of assets and liabilities to enable a balanced assessment of financial capacity, status, and reasonable needs before determining maintenance. (Para 29 , 33 )

5. Does education and academic qualification automatically negate a spouse's claim for maintenance?

Not necessarily. While earning capacity is a relevant factor, the term unable to maintain herself postulates absolute incapacity; however, the court must balance educational qualifications against actual assets and income to arrive at a fair quantum. (Para 25 )

6. How does the suppression of material facts regarding prior marital status affect maintenance claims?

Material concealment, such as suppressing a prior divorce, constitutes a lack of equity. A litigant invoking summary maintenance proceedings must provide full, bona fide disclosures of assets and income to be eligible for relief. (Para 25 , 27 , 28 )

JUDGMENT

Date : 04-09-2025

1. In the instant proceeding under Section 19 (4) of the Family Courts Act challenges a final order of maintenance passed by the learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Saran at Chapra on 24th of May, 2024 directing him to pay maintenance allowance to the opposite party / wife at the rate of Rs. 20,000/- per month.

2. It is not in dispute under the facts and circumstances of this case that the opposite party was a divorcee and her marriage with the petitioner was her second marriage. It also appears from the materials on record that the petitioner came to know the opposite party from a matrimonial site and their marriage was settled. It is stated by the petitioner that at the time of dissolution of first marriage, the opposite party got Rs. 40 Lakhs towards final settlement of alimony and she had adequate source and sufficient means to maintain herself independently.

3. The petitioner has alleged that the opposite party/wife is in the habit of duping different young men with the sole motive of earning huge amounts of money after marriage, either by way of alimony or claiming maintenance allowance. Even during the strained relation with the petitioner, the opposite party started to find out another person as a groom to whom she could marry.

4. The petitioner has challenged the impugned order of maintenance directing him to pay Rs. 20,000/- per month on the ground that she received a sum of Rs. 40 Lakhs as a final settlement of alimony from her first husband. She earns considerable interest per month from the said money. Secondly, she is academically qualified, having M.Sc. degree in Botany. She is also a diploma holder in Japanese language and is capable of earning money not only for her livelihood but a decent sum to run a luxurious life.

5. The petitioner, on the other hand, has his obligation for his old and ailing parents aged about 80 years and 75 years respectively. It is further contended by the petitioner that the respondent has suppressed her previous marriage and settled her marriage with the petitioner. Their marriage was solemnized on 16th of February, 2020 at Arya Samaj Mandir, Ghaziabad, according to Hindu Vedic Rites and Ritual. At the time of marriage, the opposite party had sworn an affidavit declaring herself unmarried. On the basis of such false affidavit, the opposite party married with petitioner by fraud in obtaining free consent to marriage.

6. It is also alleged by the petitioner that within 3 months of marriage, the opposite party refused to cohabit with the petitioner. She also refused to take care of his parents, abused them with filthy language, threatened them to implicate in criminal case by lodging false complaint and also assaulted him on 10th of October, 2020.

7. The petitioner medically treated her and came to know that the opposite party was suffering from Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) leading to suicidal tendencies.

8. Thus, the petitioner has challenged legality, propriety and correctness of the order of maintenance dated 24th of May, 2024, in Maintenance Case No. 61 of 2021, passed by the learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Saran at Chapra.

9. The opposite party has filed a counter affidavit against the instant petition under Section 19 (4) of the Family Courts Act denying the allegations made by the petitioner against her.

10. It is the specific case of the opposite party that on being asked by the petitioner, she delivered entire sum of Rs. 40 Lakhs to him which she got as final settlement of alimony from her previous husband. The opposite party also alleged that the petitioner demanded dowry of Rs. 15 Lakhs. After marriage, she was subjected to physical and mental torture which resulted in her abortion and then she left her matrimonial home on 10th of October, 2020. The respondent again went to her matrimonial home sometimes in January, 2021 with the hope of leading a peaceful and happy conjugal life but she was harassed and maltreated. She filed an application un

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top