IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

230 (11 cases)+ CWP-928-2017 (O&M)

234 (22 cases)+ Date of Decision :06.02.2025

240 & 249 Director Horticulture, Punjab, and another ...Petitioners Versus Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Patiala and another ...Respondents CWP-646-2016 Director Horticulture, Punjab, Mohali and others ...Petitioners Versus Harmesh Chand and others ...Respondents CWP-7670-2016 Secretary/Financial Commissioner Development Agriculture, Punjab, Chandigarh and others ...Petitioners Makhan Singh and others ...Respondents CWP-7671-2016 Secretary/Financial Commissioner Development Agriculture, Punjab, Chandigarh and others ...Petitioners Lachhmi Devi and others ...Respondents CWP-7684-2016 Secretary/Financial Commissioner Development Agriculture, Punjab, Chandigarh and others ...Petitioners Versus Sohan Lal and others ...Respondents CWP-7692-2016 Secretary/Financial Commissioner Development Agriculture, Punjab, Chandigarh and others ...Petitioners Versus Teja Singh and others ...Respondents CWP-7693-2016 Secretary/Financial Commissioner Development Agriculture, Punjab, Chandigarh and others ...Petitioners

Bhajan Ram and others ...Respondents

CWP-7694-2016 Secretary/Financial Commissioner Development Agriculture, Punjab, Chandigarh and others ...Petitioners H.P. Singh and others ...Respondents CWP-932-2017 (O&M)

Director Horticulture, Punjab and another ...Petitioners Versus Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Patiala and another ...Respondents CWP-933-2017 (O&M)

Director Horticulture, Punjab and another ...Petitioners

Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Patiala

CWP-934-2017 (O&M)

Director Horticulture, Punjab

Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Patiala CWP-8236-2017 and others ...Petitioners Versus Jaswinder Singh ...Respondent CWP-14816-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department and another ...Petitioners Versus Gurmail Singh & another ...Respondents CWP-14817-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department CWP-14818-2017 Ravinder Pal Singh & another ...Respondents CWP-14823-2017 Versus Ashok Kumar & another ...Respondents CWP-14824-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department and another ...Petitioners Versus

CWP-14825-2017

CWP-14834-2017 Salik Ram & another ...Respondents CWP-14835-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department and another ...Petitioners Versus Joginder Kumar & another ...Respondents CWP-14836-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department and another ...Petitioners

CWP-14837-2017

Tejinder Pal Puri & another ...Respondents CWP-14838-2017 Ranjit Singh & another ...Respondents CWP-14839-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department and another ...Petitioners Versus Balwinder Singh & another ...Respondents CWP-14840-2017

CWP-15372-2017

Gurdeep Singh & another ...Respondents CWP-15373-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department and another ...Petitioners Versus Dilbar Khan & another ...Respondents CWP-15375-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department and another ...Petitioners Versus CWP-15376-2017 CWP-15377-2017 Rajinder Kumar & another ...Respondents CWP-15392-2017 Principal Secretary, Printing & Stationary Department and another ...Petitioners Versus Narinder Pal Singh & another ...Respondents CWP-15616-2017

CWP-22926-2017

Punjab and another ...Petitioners Dara Singh ...Respondents CWP-18379-2017 Executive Engineer, Construction Division No.1 P.W.D. B & R, Ferozepur and others ...Petitioners Versus Avinash Chander and others ...Respondents CWP-368-2018 Executive Engineer, Central Division No.1 P.W.D. B & R, Patiala and others ...Petitioners Versus Ram Lal and another ...Respondents CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI Present: Mr. T.P.S. Chawla, Senior DAG, Punjab &

Mr. Soloman Pratap Singh, AAG, Punjab for the petitioner-State.

* * *

Harsimran Singh Sethi, J. (Oral)

1. In the present bunch of petitions, the challenge is by the petitioner-State to the awards passed