SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(Online)(P&H) 52226

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
BALBIR – Appellant
Versus
SANJEEV – Respondent
RSA_3712_2000



##PAGE1##

##PAGE2##

2. In order to avoid confusion, par(cid:20)es shall be referred as per their status before the trial Court.

3.1 Plain(cid:20)ff claimed that he along with other co-sharers was owner in possession of plot No.203 comprised in khewat No.218 situated within the revenue estate of village Gochhi, District Jhajjar, on which he had constructed a garage and a shop and with which defendants had no concern whatsoever. It was alleged that defendants were threatening to interfere in his possession. With these allega(cid:20)ons, decree for permanent injunc(cid:20)on was sought against defendants.

3.2 The suit was contested only by defendant No.1 - Balbir. The other defendants, who are his brother, son and nephew did not contest the suit. Defendant Nos.2 and 3, namely Chander and Satbir were proceed ex parte; whereas, defendant No.4 - Narinder alias Nando was given up. Controver(cid:20)ng the stand of the plain(cid:20)ff, it was pleaded by defendant No.1 that he along with his brother - defendant No.2 is the owner in possession of the plot in dispute. According to him, an exchange had taken place between Smt. Harkaur wife of Sunder & Mahabir son of Sunder on one hand, and Diwan Singh son of Charan Singh & Hukam Singh (father of defendant Nos.1 & 2) son of Behari on the other hand in 1975 and by virtue thereof, the plot in dispute was given to said Hukam Singh & Diwan Singh in lieu of some residen(cid:20)al property and in this regard, a wri(cid:20)ng dated 19.11.1975 was prepared. Subsequently, he (defendant No.1) had constructed a residen(cid:20)al house on the suit plot about 15 years back in the presence and to the knowledge of the plain(cid:20)ff, who did not raise any objec(cid:20)on whatsoever. Denying any concern of the plain(cid:20)ff with the suit property and with this stand and also raising some preliminary objec(cid:20)ons like estoppel etc., defendant No.1 prayed for dismissal of the suit.

3.3 Necessary issues were framed. Evidence produced by the par(cid:20)es was taken on record. Trial Court held that it is the plain(cid:20)ff, who was the owner in possession of the property in dispute and that defendant No.1 had failed to prove the exchange relied by him. It was further found that even if the exchange relied by defendant No.1 is taken on record, it was not pertaining to the property in dispute. A;er apprecia(cid:20)ng the en(cid:20)re evidence on record, the suit was decreed by the trial Court on 26.11.1998 and the findings have been affirmed by the First Appellate Court on 12.06.2000, as have already been no(cid:20)ced.

##PAGE3##

4. Assailing the aforesaid concurrent findings, it is contended by learned senior counsel for defendant No.1-appellant that evidence on record has not been properly appreciated by the Courts below and therefore, the impugned judgments are liable to be set aside.

5. The contes(cid:20)ng respondent was duly represented by counsel. However, despite in(cid:20)ma(cid:20)on about the date of hearing, nobody put in appearance for the plain(cid:20)ff-respondent No.1 at the (cid:20)me of final hearing. As such, the arguments have been heard in the absence of the counsel for the respondent.

6. I have considered submissions made by learned counsel for defendant No.1-appellant and have appraised the record carefully.

7. As per the jamabandi for the year 1991-92 (Ex.P3), it is the plain(cid:20)ff, who along with his brother Rajiv and mother Parba(cid:20), who were recorded to be owner of the suit property in possession to the extent of 1/2 share; along with Dharambir son of Sunder, who is recorded to be owner in possession to the extent of remaining 1/2 share in the suit property. Defendant claimed the suit property based upon an exchange of 1975, regarding which a wri(cid:20)ng dated 19.11.1975 was claimed to have taken place. 8. The trial Court has referred to the evidence as produced by the par(cid:20)es in this regard, which reads as under:-

"18. From the perusal of Jamabandi for the year 1975

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top