Back
RAILWAY CLAIM TRIBUNAL - GUWAHATI
M/S MEGHALAYA CEMENTS LTD. – Appellant
Versus
GM/ N. F. RLY GM/ EASTERN RLY – Respondent
OA (III)/GHY/2011/0183
Mrs. Leena Sarma, Member (Technical) Mr. Mahtab Ahmad, Member (Judicial)
Date of Judgement: 31.08.2023
Sl. No
O.A. No.
Applicant
Respondent
Applicant’s Counsel
Respondent’s Counsel
1.
OAIII-142/2013 OAIII-2013/0187 (ONLINE)
M/s Vinayak Logistics
N.F. Railway
K P Maheshwari
PS Deka
2.
OAIII-04/2017
M/s Calcom Cement India Ltd.
N.F. Railway
K P Maheshwari
PS Deka
3.
OAIII-65/2013 OAIII-2013/0110 (ONLINE)
M/s Meghalaya Cement Ltd.
N.F. Railway/ South Eastern Railway
K P Maheshwari
PS Deka (NF) H.Gupta (SER)
4.
OAIII-78/2013 OAIII-2013/0123 (ONLINE)
M/s Meghalaya Cement Ltd.
N.F. Railway/ Eastern Railway
K P Maheshwari
PS Deka
5.
OAIII-82/2013 OAIII-2013/0127 (ONLINE)
M/s Meghalaya Cement Ltd.
N.F. Railway/ Eastern Railway
K P Maheshwari
PS Deka (NF)
6.
OAIII-246/2012 OAIII-2013/0019 (ONLINE)
M/s Meghalaya Cement Ltd.
N.F. Railway
K P Maheshwari
S Basu (NF)
7.
OAIII-222/2012 OAIII-2012/0256 (ONLINE)
M/s Purbanchal Cement Ltd.
N.F. Railway/Eastern Railway
K P Maheshwari
PS Deka
Mrs. Leena Sarma, Member (Technical)
8.
OAIII-208/2012 OAIII-2012/0242 (ONLINE)
M/s Star Cement Ltd.
N.F. Railway/East Central Railway
K P Maheshwari
A.K.Sarma
9.
OAIII-182/2011 OAIII-2011/0183 (ONLINE)
M/s Meghalaya Cement Ltd.
N.F. Railway/Eastern Railway
K P Maheshwari
S Basu
COMMON JUDGEMENT
1. Since in all these 09 claim applications, more or less similar issues are involved, therefore these applications were heard together and are being decided by Common Judgement.
2. Details of Invoice no. railway receipt no. date of booking, consignment booked and claim of the applicant against each OA, are as follows:-
O.A. No.
Invoice no./RR no, date of booking & consignment
Claim for refund of overcharges on account of
1. OAIII-142/2013
22.10.2012, 09/212009920 from Alwar Goods Sheds to JTTN , 22.10.2012, 10/212009921 from Alwar Goods Sheds to JTTN , 22.10.2012, 27/212009922 from Alwar Goods Sheds to JTTN , 22.10.2012, 09/212009918 from Alwar Goods Sheds to JTTN , 22.10.2012, 09/212009919 from Alwar Goods Sheds to JTTN ,
(a) Punitive Undercharge.
2. OAIII-04/2017
2 8.03.2016, 03-212001642 from Siuri to Lanka, 09.04.2016, 01-212001649 from Siuri to Lanka, 11.05.2016, 02-212001667 from Siuri to Lanka, 25/26.04.2016, 04-212000351 from NTSK/CLG to Lanka, 09.05. 2016, 06-212000366 from NTSK/CLG to Lanka, 18.06.2016, 11-212000396 from NTSK/CLG to Lanka, 06.07.2016, 15-212000406 from NTSK/CLG to Lanka, 23.07.2016, 16-212000415 from NTSK/CLG to Lanka, 05.08.2016, 17-212000420 from NTSK/CLG to Lanka, 20.08.2016, 17-212000429 from NTSK/CLG to Lanka,
(a) Punitive Undercharge.
3. OAIII-65/2013
15.02.2011, 14-298147 from PTJP/TATA to Digaru, 26.02.2011, 06/212000010 from PTJP/TATA to New Guwahati
(a) Terminal Charges.
4. OAIII-78/2013
18.04.2011, 01/212000337 from Siuri to New Guwahati.
(a) Terminal Charges. (b) Punitive Undercharge.
5. OAIII-82/2013
30.04.2011, 04/212000015 from Kahalgaon to Digaru.
(a) Terminal Charges. (b) Punitive Undercharge.
6. OAIII-246/2012
07.10.2010, 01/298128 from PTJT/TATA to Digaru.
(a) Terminal Charges. (b) Punitive Undercharge.
7. OAIII-222/2012
29.04.2010, 07/202024 from Dhulianganga to NGC.
(a) Terminal Charges. (b) Punitive Undercharge.
8. OAIII-208/2012
17.01.2010, 01-212000004 from PATRATU to New Guwahati 28.03.2010, 02/212000005 from PATRATU to New Guwahati
(a) Terminal Charges. (b) Punitive Undercharge.
9. OAIII-182/2011
2 0.12.2008, 03/176359 from DGLE to DGU.
(a) Terminal Charges. (b) Punitive Undercharge. (c) NTR
3. On the basis of pleadings, the following issues were framed:
1. Whether statutory legal notice under Section 106 of the Railways Act, 1989 has been served?
2. Whether the claim application is properly verified, signed and filed?
3. Whether the applicant holds legal title?
4. Whether the applicant is entitled for compensation as claimed in the claim application and to wha
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
