1. An Administrator appointed under the Banking Regulation Act unilaterally wrote down Additional Tier 1 Bonds issued by a banking company during its reconstruction process. (Para 5 , 6 , 8 , 9 )
2026 Supreme(Online)(SC) 1977
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
2026 INSC 1132
CIVIL APPEAL NO.3182 OF 2025
CIVIL APPEAL NOS.3193-3202 OF 2025
CIVIL APPEAL NOS.3183-3192 OF 2025
CIVIL APPEAL NOS.3203-3212 OF 2025
YES BANK LIMITED & ANR. …APPELLANTS VERSUS AXIS TRUSTEE SERVICES LIMITED & ORS. …RESPONDENTS
YES BANK LIMITED & ETC. …APPELLANTS VERSUS INDIABULLS HOUSING FINANCE LTD. ETC. ETC. & ORS. …RESPONDENTS
RESERVE BANK OF INDIA …APPELLANT VERSUS AXIS TRUSTEE SERVICES LIMITED ETC. ETC. & ORS. …RESPONDENTS
UNION OF INDIA …APPELLANT VERSUS AXIS TRUSTEE SERVICES LIMITED & OTHERS
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
OCTOBER 15, 2026
…………….……….…………………J.
(DIPANKAR DATTA)
…………….………….………………J.
(AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH)
NEW DELHI;
OCTOBER 15, 2026.
Legal Category Hierarchy
- administrative law
- banking and finance law
- practice and procedure
Table of Contents
2. Appellants argued the Administrator retained residual power to write down bonds post-reconstruction; respondents contended the exclusion of such provisions from the scheme rendered the write-down unauthorized. (Para 13 , 14 , 17 , 43 , 57 , 61 , 74 )
3. The exclusion of bond-write-down clauses from the notified reconstruction scheme demonstrated a conscious decision to protect instrument holders, rendering the Administrator's subsequent unilateral write-down action ultra vires. (Para 35 , 37 , 38 , 39 , 40 , 41 , 77 , 78 )
4. A general savings clause in a reconstruction scheme cannot implicitly vest powers, like bond-write-downs, that are neither specifically conferred nor clearly provided for within the statutory framework. (Para 41 , 63 , 72 , 73 )
5. The court dismissed the appeals, vacated interim orders, and directed that annual coupons must be paid in terms of the initial bond information memoranda. (Para 80 , 81 )
6. Can an Administrator exercise a power to write down bonds if the specific empowering clause was omitted from the notified reconstruction scheme?
No. The omission of a write-down clause from the final scheme indicates a conscious decision by the authorities to exclude it. An Administrator cannot exercise authority beyond the four corners of the reconstruction scheme and the statute governing their appointment. (Para 37 , 38 , 40 , 41 , 72 )
7. When is the trigger for writing down AT-1 bonds activated under the Basel III framework during a bank's reconstruction?
The trigger for writing down AT-1 instruments is activated at the point of non-viability. This must occur before the reconstruction scheme comes into force, as the point of non-viability is deemed reached when the relevant authorities decide to initiate the reconstruction process. (Para 56 , 59 , 63 , 69 )
8. Does a general savings clause in a reconstruction scheme authorize an Administrator to perform actions not explicitly prescribed?
No. A general savings clause preserving existing contractual efficacy does not confer specific powers, such as the authority to write down bonds, if that power was not expressly included in the reconstruction scheme. Powers not specifically conferred cannot be implicitly vested through an omnibus clause. (Para 41 , 72 )
REPORTABLE
DJD1R S A 7 i i a e g g : Tt a2 n i e tI s1 a a N: o : l t 2 lD 0 u n y 02 r : E e s 2 R I A E i 6S g N . n T K1 o e 0A t T dX.V U1 b e 5Ry r C if I ied . S E T T R C U . S & T E O E R S S E . RVIC ES L IMITE D
J U D G M E N T
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
I. INTRODUCTION
1. On the tip of Switzerland, sharing its borders with France and Germany, lies the city of Basel. Through this city runs the river Rhine. As the river winds through the city, the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), a pivotal institution at the heart of the global financial system, stands prominently on its bank.
2. In or about 2008, a certain bank — the term used loosely at this juncture — collapsed. What followed therefrom led to a series of one of the biggest financial meltdowns in history, ripples of which were felt across the world. This led to, among other things, the enactment in 2010 of the Basel III Capital Regulations or the Basel III framework by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision at the BIS. The Reserve Bank of India, RBI has implemented this framework through its Master Circular – Basel III Capital Regulations, Master Circular.
3. The present judgment interprets parts of the RBI’s mammoth Master Circular—possibly, the first of its kind by this Court to date. The novelty of this decision is less of a fascination and more of a formidable challenge, as we are mindful of the large-scale impact it may have, both immediate and gradual. Over the course of the last few decades, the banking and finance industry has ballooned into a sector worth billions. To a large extent, the RBI regulates this space. Its rules, regulations, and guidelines are routinely subjected to interpretation by law firms, senior advocates, retired judges and the like. Seldom do these disputes reach this Court. This leads to challenges in judicial clarity over matters of fiscal nature. Keeping all of this in mind, we now approach the matter at hand.
II. THE FACTS
4. A judgment and order dated 20th January, 2023, impugned order, passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, High Court is impugned before us. The impugned order succinctly records the detailed factual matrix; to avoid prolixity, we advert only to a few dates that are relevant to the analysis which follows.
5. On 23rd December, 2016, Yes Bank Limited, YES BANK issued Basel III Compliant Additional Tier I Bonds, AT-1 Bonds or Bonds, used interchangeably in the form of non-convertible debentures for Rs. 3,000 crore. On 18th October, 2017, a further tranche of AT-1 Bonds was issued for Rs. 5,415 crore. For both sets of AT-1 Bonds, Axis Trustee Services Limited, Axis Trustee was appointed as the trustee company. The AT-1 Bonds were regulated by the Master Circular.
6. Since the financial position of YES BANK underwent a steep decline, on 5th March, 2020, the Central Government imposed a moratorium on it under section 45 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, BR Act till 3rd April, 2020. On the same day, a notification under section 36ACA of the BR Act came to be issued by the RBI appointing an Administrator in supersession of the Board of Directors of YES BANK and to oversee it. On the day following, 6th March, 2020 to be precise, a draft scheme, Draft Scheme of reconstruction of YES BANK was placed in the public domain and comments were invited from the general public by 9th March, 2020. Objections were duly lodged.
7. On 13th March, 2020, the Central Government notified the final reconstruction scheme called the ‘Yes Bank Limited Reconstruction Scheme, 2020’, Reconstruction Scheme. The Reconstruction Scheme, in its final form, underwent certain changes from the Draft Scheme, which we propose to deal with at a later part of this judgment.
8. On 14th March, 2020, the Administrator wrote down the AT-1 Bonds. This was also communicated to the Bombay Stock Exchange, BSE and the National Stock Exchange, NSE. While there is a substantial difference between the words ‘write off’ and ‘write down’ as per the Master C