2026 Supreme(Online)(SC) 2066
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Dr. G. Srinivasan – Appellant
Versus
Union Of India – Respondent
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 479 OF 2018
##PAGE1##
2026 INSC 1218 REPORTABLE IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CIVIL APPEAL NO. 479 OF 2018 DR. G. SRINIVASAN … APPELLANT VS.
UNION OF INDIA & ORS. … RESPONDENTS
J U D G M E N T
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
1. The exposition of Hon’ble D.A. Desai, J. (as His Lordship then was) in Ajit Singh v. the State of Punjab, (1983) 2 SCC 217 remains the authoritative statement of the genesis and object of probation in service jurisprudence. It reads:
7. When the master-servant relation was governed by the archaic law of hire and fire, the concept of probation in service jurisprudence DMD1R7 i a e Ag :t a5 iNe t s0 a :I o K : l 2 l 3n y 08 K : s 2 U I i 6S gM. n T1 eA1 d .R1 b 6 y w o m r h a d e t e t n r e r t o e o f r f m t j e u in r d m a ic t i i i n a o a l n t r i e o o v n r i e r o w e r m , r t o h e v m e a l c o o v b n a e c l c e a f p m ro t e m o f m p s o r e o r r e b v a ic a t e n io d n b e m c c a o a m r m e e e d t o i a f f a ic s c u u q l b u t j i e r a e c n t d a -
##PAGE2##certain connotation. If a servant could not be removed by way of punishment from service unless he is given an opportunity to meet the allegations if any against him which necessitates his removal from service, rules of natural justice postulate an enquiry into the allegations and proof thereof. This developing master-servant relationship put the master on guard. In order that an incompetent or inefficient servant is not foisted upon him because the charge of incompetence or inefficiency is easy to make but difficult to prove, concept of probation was devised. To guard against errors of human judgment in selecting suitable personnel for service, the new recruit was put on test for a period before he is absorbed in service or gets a right to the post. Period of probation gave a sort of locus pententiae to the employer to observe the work, ability, efficiency, sincerity and competence of the servant and if he is found not suitable for the post, the master reserved a right to dispense with his service without anything more during or at the end of the prescribed period which is styled as period of probation. Viewed from this aspect, the courts held that termination of service of a probationer during or at the end of a period of probation will not ordinarily and by itself be a punishment because the servant so appointed has no right to continue to hold such a post any more than a servant employed on probation by a private employer is entitled to [see Parshotam Lal Dhingra v. Union of India : AIR 1958 SC 36) : 1958 SCR 828 : 1958 SCJ 217 : (1958) 1 LLJ 544]. The period of probation therefore furnishes a valuable opportunity to the master to closely observe the work of the probationer and by the time the period of probation expires to make up his mind whether to retain the servant by absorbing him in regular service or dispense with his service. Period of probation may vary from post to post or master to master. And it is not obligatory on the master to prescribe a period of probation. It is always open to the employer to employ a person without putting him on probation. Power to put the employee on probation for watching his performance and the period during which the performance is to be observed is the prerogative of the employer.
(emphasis ours)
2. The instant appeal, by special leave granted on 16th January, 2018, involves a controversy whose origin is the termination of the appellant’s probationary service by the Institute, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, the second respondent. The lis has to be decided bearing in mind the above instructive passage and the other precedents in the field; also, given the fact that a judgment of affirmation is under challenge, interference
##PAGE3##would not be called for unless perversity, in some measure, is demonstrated.
3. Appellant was employed as an Associate Professor in the Institute, which is funded by the Central Government. Vide office memorandum dated 10th April, 2013, he