2026 Supreme(Online)(SC) 2087
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 13301 OF 2015
SUBRATA BHATTACHARYA ...APPELLANT VERSUS SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA & ORS. …RESPONDENTS
WITH CIVIL APPEAL NO. 13394 OF 2015
………………………………....J.
[PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA]
………………………………....J.
[ATUL S. CHANDURKAR]
NEW DELHI;
NOVEMBER 19, 2026.
ANNEXURE A-1 (Annexure- 100-C1)
Sector 100: Category-1 (On the basis of Due Diligence Audit Report) (Full Payment Made through Banking Channels i.e. RTGS/Cheques)
(Sale Deed Executed or Possession Taken by Allottees/Residents)
More than 50 Houses Constructed Total Allottees: 92
ANNEXURE A-2 (Annexure- 100-C2): Sector 100: Category-2 (More than 50 % payment made through Banking Channel through RTGS/Cheques)
Total Allottees: 228
ANNEXURE A-3 (Annexure-100-C3): Sector 100: Category-3 (Less than 50 % payment made through Banking Channel i.e.
RTGS/Cheques)
Total Allottees: 117
ANNEXURE A-4 (Annexure- 104-C1): Sector 104: Category-1 (Full Payment Made through Banking Channels i.e. RTGS/Cheques)
(Sale Deed Executed or Possession Taken)
More than 200 Houses Constructed Total Allottees: 241
ANNEXURE A-5 (Annexure- 104-C2): Sector 104: Category-2 (More than 50 % payment made through Banking Channel i.e.
RTGS/Cheques)
Total Allottees: 138
ANNEXURE A-6 (Annexure-104-C3): Sector 104: Category-3 Less than 50 % payment made through Banking Channel i.e.
RTGS/Cheques Total Allottees: 66
ANNEXURE A-7 (Annexure- 3A)
Pearl’s Township Bathinda Category-1: (On the basis of Due Diligence Audit Report) (Full Payment Made through Banking Channels i.e. RTGS/Cheques)
Total Allottees: 203
ANNEXURE A-8 (Annexure- 3B)
Pearl’s Township Bathinda Category-2: More than 50 % payment made through Banking Channel through RTGS/Cheques)
Total Allottees: 126
ANNEXURE A-9 (Annexure- 3C)
Pearl’s Township Bathinda Category-3: Less than 50 % payment made through Banking Channel through RTGS/Cheques)
Total Allottees: 16
O R D E R
1. This order disposes of Interlocutory Applications regarding claims filed by plot holders/allottees of PACL at Sector 100 and 104 of Mohali, and at Bhatinda.
2. The present dispute arises from the regulatory action taken by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (“SEBI”) against PACL on the ground that its business model, under which it collected money from public/investors under various investment schemes, constituted an Signatureu Notn Verrifieedgistered Collective Investment Scheme (“CIS”).
DJD1R a5 iae gy:ta4 iaet s1 an:o : lt2l 5n yK01: s2u I i6mS g.n T1ae1rd .A1 br9oyra
3. In 1999, SEBI issued notices directing PACL to either obtain registration under the SEBI (CIS) Regulations, 1999, or to wind up its operations. Asserting that its activities were confined to real estate dealings and did not constitute CIS activity, PACL initiated writ proceedings before the High Court of Rajasthan. By its judgment dated 28.11.2003, the High Court allowed the said writ petition, holding that PACL’s activities did not satisfy the statutory requirements of a CIS, and consequently quashed the notices issued by SEBI. In the appeal filed by SEBI, by its order dated 26.02.2013, this Court disposed of the appeal by setting aside the judgment of the High Court and remanded the matter to SEBI, directing that the original 1999 notices be treated as show-cause notices and that SEBI should conduct a de novo adjudication to determine whether its business activities fell within the ambit of a CIS.
4. Pursuant to the said remand, SEBI passed final orders concluding that PACL was, indeed, running an unregistered CIS and directed its promoters and directors to refund the monies collected from investors and to wind up all existing schemes. This order was upheld by the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT). It is in this context that the present Civil Appeals against this judgment and order of SAT are ongoing.
5. By an order dated 02.02.2016, this Court constituted the Justice (Retd.) R.M. Lodha Committee (“the Committee”), which was entrusted with the dual mandate of liquidating the Company’s land assets and ensuring the equitable refund of investor funds. In furtherance of these duties, the Committee retrieved and scrutinized title deeds from the CBI, engaged necessary experts for valuation and auditing, and also formulated and executed modalities for the sale of immovable properties and then verified and disbursed investors’ claims.
6. The Committee’s proposal for appointment of Shri R. S. Virk, District Judge (Retd.), to examine a large number of applications, objections, grievances, and representations related to Committee’s proceedings was accepted by this Court’s order dated 15.11.2017. Subsequently, many such applications were heard and disposed by Shri R.S. Virk following due procedure. In the course of these proceedings, a large number of Interlocutory Applications (IAs) were filed by various parties before us.
7. For the purpose of disposal of the present IAs it may be stated that the Committee examined the records relating to the residential projects that PACL had at Sectors 100 and 104, Mohali, and at Bhatinda. The Committee found that Sectors 100 and 104 at Mohali, together, had 2032 units and Bhatinda had 1078 units, and that many were allotted or sold before 02.02.2016.
8. By order dated 04.03.2020, this Court, while considering I.A No. 150831 of 2023 (filed by State of Punjab) and I.A No. 105681 of 2019 (filed by Pearl City Mohali Residents Welfare Association), directed disclosure of the names of the allottees of plots in Sectors 100 and 104 in Mohali, the dates on which the respective agreements were entered into, the mode and dates of payment, and whether the original allottees remain members of the Association or have transferred their rights. Pearl City Mohali Residents Welfare Association filed an affidavit dated 04.10.2024, supplying the necessary details regarding allottees of Sector 100 and 104, Mohali. By order dat