A-20-139 to 146 A-20-147 to 152

Court-2 APPEAL NOs. 139 to 152 OF 2020 APPEAL NO.139 Of 2020 The Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Mahajans Lane, Raopura, Vadodara. …Appellant (Ori. Opp. No.2)

Vs.

1. Jagruk Nagrik, (A Voluntary Consumer Association Through their Managing Trustee P.V.Moorjani, Opp. LBS Vidhyalay, Nr. Prerna School, Sangam Karelibaug Road, Vadodara.

2. Smt. Ganiben Thakorbhai Parmar, Residing at Sardar Bhavan Khancha, Vadli Gali, Opp. Akhada, Vadodara.

3. The Medical Superintendent/ Hospital Authority Managing Director, M/s. Jalaram Chaksu Kendra and Sheth M.L.Vaduvala Eye Hospital, Vinodbhavan Marg, Salatwada, Vadodara-390 001.

4. Dr. Farki Jiruwala, 804/B,Mangal Kirti Apartment, Fatehgunj, Vadodara-02. ...Respondents (Nos. 1 & 2 Ori.

Complainant, No. 3 & 4 Ori. Opp. Nos.1 & 3)

APPEAL NO.140 Of 2020 The Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Mahajans Lane, Raopura, Vadodara. …Appellant (Ori. Opp. No.2)

Vs.

1. Jagruk Nagrik, (A Voluntary Consumer Association Through their Managing Trustee P.V.Moorjani, Opp. LBS Vidhyalay, Nr. Prerna School, Sangam Karelibaug Road, Vadodara.

2. Heirs of deceased Gulamhusen Hajiismail Mansuri brought on record: 1. Yakubbhai Gulamhusen Mansuri, 2. Salimbhai Gulamhusen Mansuri, Both residing at: Vorwad Sunder Kuwa, At & Post & Tal- Dabhoi, Dist: Vadodara.

3. The Medical Superintendent/

Hospital Authority, Managing Director, M/s. Jalaram Chaksu Kendra and Sheth M.L. Vaduvala Eye Hospital, Vinodbhavan Marg, Salatwada, Vadodara-390 001.

4. Dr. Bhadresh Thakkar, F-104, Kalindi Complex, V.I.P. Road, Vadodara, ...Respondents (Nos. 1 & 2 Ori.

Complainant, No. 3 & 4 Ori. Opp. Nos.1 & 3)

APPEAL NO.141 Of 2020 The Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Mahajans Lane, Raopura, Vadodara. …Appellant (Ori. Opp. No.2)

Vs.

1. Jagruk Nagrik, (A Voluntary Consumer Association Through their Managing Trustee P.V.Moorjani, Opp. LBS Vidhyalay, Nr. Prerna School, Sangam Karelibaug Road, Vadodara.

2. Shri Ramanbhai Chaturbhai Rathod (deceased)

2A). Shantaben Ramanbhai Rathod, (W/o. Ramanbhai C. Rathod), 2B). Dilipkumar Ramanbhai Rathod, (S/O. Ramanbhai C.Rathod)

Residing at: Post: Dodka, Ta & Dist: Vadodara.

3. The Medical Superintendent/ Hospital Authority, Managing Director, M/s. Jalaram Chaksu Kendra and Sheth M.L.Vaduvala Eye Hopital, Vinodbhavan Marg, Salatwada, Vadodara-390 001.

4. Dr. Rajshriben Vadhani, 1283, Akashganga Society, Makarpura, Vadodara. ...Respondents (Nos. 1 & 2 Ori.

Complainant, No. 3 & 4 Ori. Opp. Nos.1 & 3)

APPEAL NO.142 Of 2020 The Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Mahajans Lane, Raopura, Vadodara. …Appellant (Ori. Opp. No.2)

Vs.

1. Jagruk Nagrik, (A Voluntary Consumer Association Through their Managing Trustee P.V.Moorjani, Opp. LBS Vidhyalay, Nr. Prerna School, Sangam Karelibaug Road, Vadodara.

2. Shri Hasmukhbhai Gordhanbhai Patel (Heir and grandson of Dahiben Shabhubhai Patel)

Moksi, Ta: Salvi, Dist: Vadodara.

Address of Correspondence:

C/o. Savitaben Laxmidas Patel, 2/4, Narmadanagar Society, Opp. Ghanshyam Park, Gorva-refinary Road, Vadodara.

3. The Medical Superintendent/ Hospital Authority, Managing Director, M/s. Jalaram Chaksu Kendra and Sheth M.L.Vaduvala Eye Hopital, Vinodbhavan Marg, Salatwada, Vadodara-390 001.

4. Dr. Bhadresh Thakkar, F-104, Kalindi Coplex, V.I.P.Road, Vadodara. ...Respondents (Nos. 1 & 2 Ori.

Complainant, No. 3 & 4 Ori. Opp. Nos.1 & 3)

APPEAL NO.143 Of 2020 The Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Mahajans Lane, Raopura, Vadodara. …Appellant (Ori. Opp. No.2)

Vs.

1. Jagruk Nagrik, (A Voluntary Consumer Association Through their Managing Trustee P.V.Moorjani, Opp. LBS Vidhyalay, Nr. Prerna School, Sangam Karelibaug Road, Vadodara.

2. Shri Chhotabhai Panjabhai Tadpadavaghari, Padra Near Kantioala Talav In the house of Bhagabhai Desai, Padra, Dist: Vadodara.

3. The Medical Superintendent/ Hospital Authority, M