2025 Supreme(Online)(SCDRC) 30463
STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION
United india ins co ltd – Appellant
Versus
Hitendra B Desai – Respondent
SC/24/A/343/2022
S[; O[\;, TFZLB o !_q!_qZ_ZZ S[; NFB, YIF TFZLBo Z&q_5qZ_ZZ lGSF,GF lNJ;M o __ JQF"4 _$ DF;4 !5 lNJ;
U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 SlDXG4 U]HZFT ZFHI4 VDNFJFN SM8" G\P! s.vCLIZL\Uf V5L, G\P#$#qZ_ZZ V[5[,g8 o I]GF.8[0 .g0LIF .g:IMZg; S\5GL ,LP ZFI R[dA;"4 G[XG, CF.J[ G\P(4HLPVF.P0LP;LP S|M; ZM04 JF5L4 TFPJF5L4 HLP J,;F0v#)&!)5 lJZ]wW ZL:5Mg0g8 o zL lCT[gN= ALPN[;F.
)_!vAL4 G\NG 8FJZ4 VF;M5F,J SMd5,[1F4 KZJF0F ZM04 JF5L4 TFP HLP J,;F0P SMZD o DFPH:8L; zL JLP5LP58[,4 5|D]BzL ;]PzL VR"GFA[G ;LPZFJ,4 ;eIzL zL VFZPV[GPDC[TF4 ;eIzL V[0JMS[8 o V[5[,g8 TZO[ o zL VFZP5LPZFJ, ZL:5Mg0g8 TZO[ o zL ;LPVFZPSM9FZL C]SD ov ;]PzL VR"GFA[G ;LPZFJ,4 ;eIzL DFZOT[
!P V[5[,g8[ CF,GL V5L, U|FCS ;]Z1FF VlWlGID Z_!)GL S,Dv$! D]HA lJP J,;F0 HL<,F U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 SlDXG4 D]PJ,;F0 s CJ[ 5KL lJP lH<,F SlDXG TZLS[ p<,[B SZJFDF\ VFJX[f wJFZF U|FCS ;]Z1FF S[; G\P!#&qZ_Z_GF SFD[ TFPZ(q_$qZ_ZZGF ZMH SZJFDF\ VFJ[, C]SDYL GFZFH Y. NFB, SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P !PZ 50SFZ[, C]SD o lJP J,;F0 lH<,F U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 SlDXG4 D]PJ,;F0 wJFZF GLR[
D]HA C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P cc!P OZLIFNLGL OZLIFN V\XTo D\H]Z SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P ZP ;FDFJF/FG[ V[JM C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[ S[4 OZLIFNLG[ Z]FP#4Z$4_*)qv s V\S[ Z]5LIF +6 ,FB RMJL; CHFZ VMU^IFV[\XL 5]ZFf OZLIFNGL TFZLBYL *@ GF jIFH ;FY[4 lNGv#_ DF\ R]SJL VF5JFP #P T[DH ;FDFJF/FG[ V[JM 56 C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[ S[ OZLIFNLG[ YI[, XFZLlZS VG[
DFGl;S +F;GF T[DH OZLIFN BR" lJU[Z[GF Z]FPZ45__qvs V\S[ Z]5LIF A[ CHFZ
5F\R;M 5]ZFf 56 V,UYL J;], VF5JFP $P 51FSFZMG[ VF C]SDGL HF6 lJGF D]
ZP V[5[,g8 TZO[ lJP JSL, zL VFZP5LPZFJ,G[ ;F\E?IFP ;FDFJF/F TZO[ lJP JSL, zL ;LPVFZP SM9FZLG[ ;F\E?IFP ZP! VF SFD[ V[5[,g8 D]/ OlZIFNDF\ ;FDFJF/F CTFP CF,GF ZL:5Mg0g8 D]/ OZLIFNL CTFP H[YL R]SFNFDF\ ;Z/TF DF8[ 51FSFZMG[ D}/ OlZIFNGF R]SFNF 5|DF6[ ;\AMWJFDF\ VFJX[P #P OlZIFNGL 8\]SL CSLST o OlZIFNGL 8\]SDF\ CSLST V[JL K[ S[4 OZLIFNL VF SFDGF ;FDFJF/F 5F;[YL 36M JZ;MYL 5M,L;L ,[TF VFJ[, K[P OZLIFNLV[ ;FDFJF/F 5F;[YL C[
5P S[;GF U]6NMQF HMTF S[8,LS CSLSTM lGlJ"JFlNT K[P H[D S[4 V[5[,g8 JLDF S\5GL TZOYL OZLIFNLG[ C[
5P! HIFZ[ V[5[,g8 JLDF S\5GLV[ OZLIFNLGM S,[.D GSFZ[, GYL4 5Z\T] 8LP5LPV[P DFZOT VF S,[.DGL S[8,LS S5FT SZLG[ R]SJ6]\ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P H[ S5FT JLDF S\5GLV[ S,[.D ;[8,D[g8 JFpRZDF\ NXF"JL K[P S,[.D ;[8,D[g8 JFpRZ 5FGF G\P() YL ZH] K[P H[DF 0L0SXG ZLDFS";DF\ GLR[
D]HA GM\W K[P "
As per clause 1.2 A. Room rent and Nurshing charges payble upto 1% of SI per day hencce deducted Rs. 26,250/- As per Clause 1.2 Note 1 Surgeon charges payble as per Room rent Proportionate deduction on Rs. 83,410/- hence deducted Rs. 60,889/-. GAMMA KNIFE PROCEDURE CHARGE BRECKUP DETAIL NOT AVAILABLE,HOSPITAL SERVICE CHARGE NOT PAYBLE.RS. 672/- DIGITAL THERMOMETER, OINTMENT CHARGE NOT PAYBLE,1 DAY STAY CHARGE PAID, As per Clause 1.2 Note 1 Investigation and lab charges payble as per Room rent Proportionate deduction on Rs. 15,700/- hence deducted Rs. 11,461/- As per Clause 1.2 Note 1 visit charges payble as per Room rent Proportionate deduction on Rs. 6,800/- hence deducted Rs.4,964/-."
5PZ 0L0SXGGL IMuITFGL D},J6L lJP HL<,F SlDXG[ C]SDGF 5[ZFv5 DF\ SZ[,L K[P H[ HMTF 5|lT5FlNT YFI K[ S[4 V[5[,g8 S\5GLV[ ,FU] 5F0[, lGIDM VG[ S5FT SZ[, ZSDG]\ IMuI D]
5P# S5FTDFGL D]bI ZSD UFDF GF.O 5|M;LHZ V\U[GL K[P UFDF GF.O 5|M;LHZGF AL, D]HA S], Z]FPZ4$&4_)_qv H6FJ[, K[P V[5[,g8 JLDF S\5GLV[ UFDF GF.O 5|M;LHZGL H[ ZSD AL,DF\ H6FJ[,L K[P T[ V\U[ A|[SV5 V[5[,g8 JLDF S\5GLV[ OZLIFNL 5F;[ TFP!!q!qZ__( GF 5+YL DF\U[, K[P H[GF VG];\WFG[ OZLIFNLV[ HIF\YL T[D6[ ;FZJFZ ,LW[,L T[ lCgN]HF CM:5L8, 5F;[ A|[SV5 ;FY[GL lJUTM DF\U[,L4 H[GM HJFA lCgN]HF CM:5L8,[ TFPZZq!qZ_Z_GF 5+YL VF5[, K[P H[ 5FGF G\PZ( YL ZH] K[P H[DF UFDF GF.O 5|M;LHZ RFHL";GM SM. A|[SV5 VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,M GYLP VFYL OZLIFNL A|[SV5 ZH] SZL XS[,F GYLP H[ AFAT OZLIFNLGF SFA]DF GYL VG[ H[ lJUTM CM:5L8,[ H[ ZLT[ VF5L K[ T[ H :JZ]5DF