ADDITIONAL BENCH STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, PUNJAB, DAKSHIN MARG, SEC-37A, CHANDIGARH.

Date of institution : 14.12.2022Reserved on : 01.08.2025Date of decision : 25.08.2025Raman Hospital, Kitchlu Nagar Extension, Lane No.1, Opposite Ram Sharnam, Near Petrol Pump, Ludhiana through its Partner Dr. Raman Mittal. .……Appellant/Opposite party No.3Versus

1. Ashok Kumar, aged 60 years, resident of H.No.4288, Street No.1, New Madhopuri, Ludhiana ……Respondent No.1/Complainant

2. Sandhu Cancer Center, SCF-09, Udham Singh Nagar Market, Ludhiana, through Dr. Davinder Singh Sandhu.

3. Dr. Davinder Singh Sandhu of owner of Sandhu Cancer Centre, SCF- 09, Udham Singh Nagar Market, Ludhiana.

4. Dr. Raman Mittal, Director/Prop./Partner/Owner Raman Hospital, Kitchlu Nagar Extension, Lane No.1, Opposite Ram Sharnam, Near Petrol Pump, Ludhiana.

5. Dr. Anshu Mittal of Raman Hospital , Kitchlu Nagar Extension, Lane No.1, Opposite Ram Sharnam, Near Petrol Pump, Ludhiana.

6. Dr. Gagan Modgil of Raman Hospital, Kitchlu Nagar Extension, Lane No.1, Opposite Ram Sharnam, Near Petrol Pump, Ludhiana.

7. Dr. Pankaj Sihag of Raman Hospital, Kitchlu Nagar Extension, Lane No.1, Opposite Ram Sharnam, Near Petrol Pump, Ludhiana and also at Fortis Hospital, Mundian Kalan, Chandigarh Road, Ludhiana, now resident of Mulberry 4, Flat No.702, Centre Green, Pakhowal Road, Ludhiana.

8. Pancham Hospitals Private Limited, SCO 34-37, Canal Road, Jawaddi Bridge, Near GK Mall, Ludhiana 141002 through its Director Dr. R.P.Singh, Dr. Harsimran Singh, Anup Chand and Dr. Harmandeep Singh.

9. Dr. R.P. Singh, Director of Pancham Hospitals Private Limited, SCO 34-37, Canal Road, Jawaddi Bridge, Near GK Mall, Ludhiana 141002.

10. Dr. Harsimran Singh, Director of Pancham Hospitals Private Limited, SCO 34-37, Canal Road, Jawaddi Bridge, Near GK Mall, Ludhiana 141002.

11. Anup Chand, Director of Pancham Hospitals Private Limited, SCO 34-37, Canal Road, Jawaddi Bridge, Near GK Mall, Ludhiana 141002.

12. Dr. Harmandeep Singh, Director of Pancham Hospitals Private Limited, SCO 34-37, Canal Road, Jawaddi Bridge, Near GK Mall, Ludhiana 141002.

13. Dr. Kanwaljit Kaur, Director of Pancham Hospitals Private Limited, SCO 34-37, Canal Road, Jawaddi Bridge, Near GK Mall, Ludhiana 141002.

14. Dr. Sushil Jindal, Director of Pancham Hospitals Private Limited, SCO 34-37, Canal Road, Jawaddi Bridge, Near GK Mall, Ludhiana 141002.

15. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., GT Road, Vishawakarma Chowk, Ludhiana (PB), Div. Off.No.1, 455, The Mall, Ludhiana.

……Respondents/OPs No.2 to 15 First Appeal against the order dated 16.09.2022 passed by District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, SBS Nagar, Camp Court at Ludhiana.

Quorum:-

Mr. H.P.S.Mahal, Presiding Judicial Member Mrs. Kiran Sibal, Member Present:-

For the appellant : Sh. Ashish Gupta, Adv For respondent No.1 : None For respondent No.2 & 3 : Sh. Jatinder Nagpal, Adv For respondent No.4,5&8 to13: Ex-parte For respondent No.6 : None For respondent No.7 : Sh.Anish Chopra, Adv for Sh.Sidhant Bhonsle, Adv For respondent No.14 : Deleted, vide order dt.18.10.2023 For respondent No.15 : Sh. D.P.Gupta, Adv KIRAN SIBAL, MEMBER For orders see First Appeal No.989 of 2022 titled as “Sandhu Cancer Center Vs. Ashok Kumar & others” decided on the even date i.e.25.08.2025.

(H.P.S. MAHAL)