2025 Supreme(Online)(SCDRC) 32636
STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION
1.Shaik Shameena – Appellant
Versus
1.Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Ltd. – Respondent
SC/36/CC/231/2017
THE TELANGANA STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION: HYDERABAD.
C.C.No.231 OF 2017 Between:
1. Shaik Shameena, W/o. Late. Shareef, Aged about: 24 years, Occ: Household duties, R/o. Ammapalem Village, Konijerla Mandal, Khammam District, Telangana State.
2. Shaik Rafath, S/o. Late. Shareef, Aged about: 7 years, Occ: Studying 1st Class, R/o. Ammapalem Village, Konijerla Mandal, Khammam District, Telangana State.
3. Mr. Shaik Sameer, S/o. Late. Shareef, Aged about: 5 years, Occ: Studying Nursery, R/o. Ammapalem Village, Konijerla Mandal, Khammam District, Telangana State.
4. Shaik Yakub @ Yakub Miya, S/o. Late. Fathe Ahmed, Aged about: 70 years, Occ: Nil, (died on 05.05.2021 and memo filed along with D.C.),R/o. Ammapalem Village, Konijerla Mandal, Khammam District, Telangana State. Complainants No.1 & 2 are being minors represented by their mother and natural guardian Complainant No.1 namely Shaik Shameena.
… Complainants And
1. Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Ltd., Multi Super Specialty Hospital, Rep.by its Chief Executive Officer, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003.
2. The Chief Executive Officer, Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Ltd., Multi Super Specialty Hospital, Rep.by its Chief Executive Officer, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003. 3. Dr. Krishna Reddy A., S/o. Name not known, Aged about: Major, Occ: Consultant Neuro Surgeon, Department of Neuro Surgery of KIMS Hospital, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003.
4. Dr. Mansa Panigrahi, S/o. Name not known, Aged about: Major, Occ: Consultant Neuro Surgeon, Department of Neuro Surgery of KIMS Hospital, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003.
5. Dr. R. Chandra Sekhar Naidu, S/o. Name not known, Aged about: Major, Occ: Consultant Neuro Surgeon, Department of Neuro Surgery of KIMS Hospital, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003.
6. Dr. Sujit Kumar Vidiyala, S/o. Name not known, Aged about: Major, Occ: Consultant Neuro Surgeon, Department of Neuro Surgery of KIMS Hospital, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003. 7. Dr. Phani Raj, S/o. Name not known, Aged about: Major, Occ: Consultant Neuro Surgeon, Department of Neuro Surgery of KIMS Hospital, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003.
8. Dr. Rama Krishna, S/o. Name not known, Aged about: Major, Occ: Consultant Neuro Surgeon, Department of Neuro Surgery of KIMS Hospital, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003.
9. Dr. Kumari M., Aged about: Major, Occ: Consultant Neuro Surgeon, Department of Neuro Surgery of KIMS Hospital, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003.
10. Dr. Chandra Sekhar Y.B.V.K., S/o. Name not known, Aged about: Major, Occ: Consultant Neuro Surgeon, Department of Neuro Surgery of KIMS Hospital, Minister Road, Secunderabad – 500003.
11. The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Hyderabad, Rep. by its Divisional Officer IV, Hyderabad, 1st Floor, 6-2-976, Pavani Estates, P.B. NO.74, Khairatabad, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
(The Opposite Party No.11 was added as per order in IA No.5019/2022, dated 25.04.2023).
…Opposite parties Counsel for the Complainants : M/s. Shaik Noorul Haq Counsel for the Opp. Party No.1 to 7 & 10 : Mr. D. Devendar Rao Counsel for the Opp. Party No.11 : M/s. S. Satyananda Rao QUORUM: HON’BLE SRI K.RANGA RAO - PRESIDING OFFICER-
MEMBER - (JUDICIAL).
&
HON’BLE SMT.R.S.RAJESHREE, MEMBER (NON JUDICIAL).
TUESDAY, THE NINETH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, TWO THOUSAND TWENTY FIVE ORDER: (PER HON’BLE SMT. R.S. RAJESHREE, MEMBER, N-JUDICIAL)
1. This is a complaint filed by the Complainants U/s. 17(1)(a)(i) of Consumer Protection Act,1986 on 04.12.2017 against the Opposite Parties to direct them as follows:-
(i) To award compensation of Rs.1,00,00,000/- (Rupees One Crore Only) from the date of filing of the complaint till the date of realization to the Complainants, towards medical expenses, damages, carelessness.
(ii) Treatment, deficiency in services of Opposite Parties by suppressing the glaring fact of death of the deceased Shaik Shareef from 23.03.2017 to till 27.03.2017.
(iii) To award costs of the complaint and (iv) To grant any other re