STATE CONSUMER DISPUTE REDRESSAL COMMISSION MAHARASHTRA, AT MUMBAI (Arisen out of order order dated 07/04/2025 passed by the Additional Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Mumbai Suburban District, at Bandra in complaint No. CC/36/2025)

Suman Prabhat Upadhyay Through her husband Prabhat Vijay Upadhyay Residing at - Room no. 6, Near Pujari General Store, Samta Sidhhi Vinayak Society, Filter Pada, Aarey Colony Road, NITIE, Mumbai -4000 87 ....APPELLANT V/s

1. Dr. Dharmendra V. Dubey, BREATH CARE HOSPITAL, At-: N-1/4, Girivihar C.H.S Ltd., Anand Nagar, Opp. Sai Baba Mandir, Vasai (W), District- Palghar- 401202, Maharashtra

2. BREATH CARE HOSPITAL, At-: N-1/4, Girivihar C.H.S Ltd., Anand Nagar, Opp. Sai Baba Mandir, Vasai (W), District- Palghar- 401202, Maharashtra ....RESPONDENTS Before : Hon’ble Mr. Mukesh V. Sharma : Presiding Member Hon’ble Dr. Mrs. Nisha A. Chavan : Member For Appellant : Advocate Shri. A.K. Moiely a/w Advocate Shri. Rupesh Jambawadekar ************************************************************************************

ORAL ORDER (07/04/2026)

Per - Hon’ble Mr. Mukesh V. Sharma : Presiding Member

1. Advocate Shri. A.K. Moiely a/w Advocate Shri. Rupesh Jambawadekar are pr