2025 Supreme(Online)(Tel) 56339
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURENDER
STATE REP.BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE ACB WARANGAL RANGE SPL.PP – Appellant
Versus
SHAIK MAHAMOOD DY COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER AND ANOTHER – Respondent
CRLA 1302/2011
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURENDER CRIMINAL APPEAL No.1302 OF 2011
JUDGMENT:
The State, aggrieved by the acquittal of the respondents/A-1 and A-2, is questioning the judgment dated 23.05.2011 in S.C.No.20 of 2010, on the file of II Additional Special Judge for SPE & ACB Cases, Hyderabad. The offences alleged against the accused are under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w. 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1998, and 34 of IPC.
2. Heard Sri T.Bala Mohan Reddy, learned Special Public Prosecutor for ACB cases and Sri T.Aditya, learned counsel for respondents.
3. A-1 died, and accordingly, the appeal against him was abated on 11.04.2025.
4. The Appeal is heard insofar as A-2 is concerned.
5. P.W.1 is the defacto complainant. According to him, he was the Proprietor of Sri Sai Binding Works. He used to purchase raw material from Vijayawada and Hyderabad which included taxes. On 13.06.2003, A-1 went to his shop and verified the details of bills and accordingly levied Rs.1,809/- for the year 2002-03 and Rs.7,171/- for the year 2003-04. On 18.06.2003, A-1 informed P.W.1 that an amount of Rs.8,980/- has to be paid as tax. Further, penalty of Rs.2,000/- was levied as user charges. P.W.1 paid the entire amount on 18.06.2003. Though the amounts were paid, A-1 did not return the bills. For returning the bills A-1 informed P.W.1 that he is competent to impose heavy penalties and taxes and in order not to impose the same, an amount of Rs.10,000/- has to be given to him as bribe. P.W.1 requested that he would pay the said amount as Rs.6,000/- and Rs.4,000/- in two installments. Then, A-1 called P.W.1 and informed that he would send A-2 to the shop and amount shall be handed over to him. When A-2 went to the shop, P.W.1 expressed that he was not having the amount and that he will talk t A-1. On 27.06.2003, P.W.1 went to ACB office and filed complaint Ex.P.3. Along with the complaint, he also enclosed Exs.P.1 and P.2, which are receipts of payment of money by P.W.1.
6. The trap was laid on 30.06.2003. After completing the formalities, entire team went to the office of A-1. P.W.1 entered the office of A-1. A-1 enquired about the bribe amount and P.W.1 stated that he brought Rs.6,000/-. Accordingly, A-1 asked P.W.1 to handover the said amount to A-2. P.W.1 gave the amount to A-2 and A-2 kept the amount in the right side pocket of his pant. P.W.1 went out and conveyed the prearranged signal to the trap party. On his signal, DSP/Umakantha Reddy entered into the office and conducted test on both A-1 and A-2. Test on A-1’s hand proved negative, while A-2’s hand proved positive. The said amount was later handed over to DSP by A-2. Since DSP Umakantha Reddy died, in his place P.W.7 was examined, who was part of the trap.
7. Having concluded the trap proceedings, A-1 and A-2 were arrested. Thereafter, investigation was done by Inspector/P.W.8 and charge sheet was filed.
8. Learned Special Judge examined witnesses P.Ws.1 to 8 and also marked Exs.P.1 to P.18. M.Os.1 to 10 were also brought on record by the prosecution. Exs.D.1 and D.2 which are the letters issued by the Commercial Tax Officers were marked on behalf of the defence.
9. The evidence insofar as A-1 is concerned is not discussed since the case is abated against him.
10. Insofar as A-2 is concerned, learned Special Judge found that at no point of time, A-2 was informed that amount was bribe amount. Even according to the evidence placed on record, A-2 did not have the knowledge that the amount received from P.W.1 at the instance of A-1 was that of bribe amount. Learned Special Judge further found that the demand of bribe amount was for return of the bills, however, P.W.1 himself admitted in his cross-examination that the bills were received under Ex.P.4 and his endorsement at Ex.P.4(a). Though P.W.1 stated that some other bills were not received, however, the details of such bills were not mentioned.
11. Learned Special Judge found that the demand aspect insofar as A-1 is concerned was not proved. The su