Appeal No 265 of 2014
Page 1 of 34
In the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity,
New Delhi
(Appellate Jurisdiction)
Appeal no. 265 of 2014
Dated: 8th September, 2016
Present:
Hon'ble Mrs. Justice Ranjana P. Desai, Chairperson
Hon'ble Mr. I.J. Kapoor, Technical Member
In the matter of
Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd.
Kochi LPG Regional Office,
Irumpanam, P.O. Kochi – 682309
... Appellant
Versus
1. Kerala State Electricity Regulatory Commission
K.P.F.C. Bhavanam, C.V. Raman Pillai Road,
Vellayambalam , Thiruvananthapuram
695 010, Kerala
….Respondent No 1
2. Kerala State Electricity Board,
Vydyuthi Bhavan,
Pattom, Thiruvananthapuram,
695004, Kerala
….Respondent No 2
Counsel for the Appellant(s):
Mr. Anand K. Ganesan
Ms Swapna Sheshadri
Ms Mandakini Ghosh
Mr Ishan Mukherjee
Mr Akshi Seem
Ms Neha Garg
Counsel for the Respondent(s):
Mr Ramesh Babu M.R.
Mr Paramhans for R-1
Mr M.T. George
Mr Katitha K.T. for R-2
Appeal No 265 of 2014
Page 2 of 34
JUDGMENT
1.
The present Appeal has been filed by Hindustan Petroleum
Corporation Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the “Appellant”) under
Section 111 of the Electricity Act, 2003 against the Impugned Order
dated 14.08.2014 passed by the Respondent No. 1, Kerala State
Electricity Regulatory Commission (hereinafter referred to as the
“State Commission”) in OP No. 9 of 2014 dealing with the approval
of the Annual Revenue Requirements of the Kerala State Electricity
Board (hereinafter referred to as “Respondent No.2”) and the tariff
applicable for the Appellant and all consumers in the State of Kerala
for FY 2014-15 wherein the State Commission has erroneously
categorized Liquefied Petroleum Gas ('LPG') Cylinder bottling plants,
and Petroleum Terminals (POL Terminals) under the HT-IV
Commercial category along with other commercial establishments
such as malls and multiplexes, hotels etc. as against the claim of the
Appellant for categorisation under the HT-1 Industry category.
PER HON'BLE MR. I. J. KAPOOR, TECHNICAL MEMBER
2.
The Appellant is a Government of India undertaking and is engaged in
the refining and marketing of Petroleum products including LPG and
allied products. The Appellant has got two LPG Bottling Plants, one
POL Terminal and a Petroleum Depot in the State of Kerala.
3.
The Respondent No 1 is the Electricity Regulatory Commission for the
State of Kerala exercising jurisdiction and discharging functions in
terms of the Electricity Act 2003.The Respondent No 2 is Kerala State
Appeal No 265 of 2014
Page 3 of 34
Electricity Board (hereinafter called “KSEB”) is the Distribution
Licensee in the State of Kerala.
4.
Aggrieved by the Impugned Order dated 14.08.2014 passed by the
State Commission, the Appellant has preferred the present appeal on
following grounds:
a)
Whether the process of bottling the LPG being carried out at the
Appellant's factories can be termed as a mere commercial activity as
against the claim of the Appellant of it being an industrial activity?
b)
Whether the processes carried out at the Appellant's Petroleum
Terminal and Depot (Factories) including blending and manufacture of
consumable petroleum products can be termed as mere commercial
activity as against the claim of the Appellant of it being an industrial
activity?
c)
Whether at all any commercial activity is being carried out in the
factories of the Appellant where the final product is derived and moved
to various destinations for distribution?
d)
Whether the process at the factory of the Appellant, that of converting
the LPG in bulk to cylinder, after the cylinders are cleaned, repaired,
filled, and sealed to get the product is an industrial process?
5.
Facts of the present Appeal:
i.
The Appellant is engaged in the refining and marketing of Petroleum
products including LPG and allied products. It has two LPG Bottling
plants in the State of Kerala which carry out the ope