HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH
BACHCHI DEVI AND OTHERS – Appellant
Versus
RADHESHYAM GUPTADIED THR. LRS URMILA GUPTA AND OTHERS – Respondent
SA 65/2003
['ASHOK KUMAR SHUKLA', '', 'RAVI PRAKASH GANDHARVA', 'SUBHASH YADAV', 'J K GUPTA', '', 'A G', 'A K PRASAD', 'USHA CHANDRAKAR', 'SHIPRA BISWAS', 'PANKAJ AGRAWAL', 'SANGEETA MISHRA']
S.A.No.65/2003
Page 1 of 16
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
Second Appeal No.65 of 2003
Order reserved on: 20-2-2019
Order delivered on: 5-3-2019
1. Bachchi Devi, W/o Babaoo, aged about 60 years.
2. Sitaram, S/o Babaoo, aged about 38 years.
3. Rajaram, S/o Babaoo, aged about 30 years.
Appellant No.1 to 3 are R/o Village Kewra, Police Station
Bhaiyathan, Tahsil Surajpur, Distt. Surguja (C.G.)
4. Shanti, D/o Babaoo, W/o Ram Dular, aged about 45 years, R/o
Village Pariyadanrh, Police Station Bhaiyathan, PO Dawna, Tahsil
Surajpur, Distt. Surajpur (C.G.)
5. Krishna, D/o Babaoo, W/o Bhuneshwar, aged about 38 years, R/o
Village/Post Sirsi, Police Station Bhaiyathan, Tahsil Surajpur, Distt.
Surguja (C.G.)
6. Rukman, W/o late Ganga Ram, aged about 50 years.
7. Dharamraj, S/o late Gangaram, aged about 30 years.
8. Ramadheen (Dead) Through LRs
(a) Sonamati, W/o Late Ramadhin, Aged about 50 years,
Occupation Agriculture
(b) Ramvilas, S/o Late Ramadhin, Aged about 30 years,
Occupation Agriculture
(c) Kailash, S/o late Ramadhin, Aged about 25 years, Occupation
Agriculture
(d) Avilas, S/o Late Shri Ramadhin, Aged about 18 years,
Occupation Agriculture
(e) Amarnath, S/o late Shri Ramadhin, Aged about 16 years,
Occupation Student, Minor Through Guardian Mother Sonamati,
Respondent No.8 (A)
Respondent No.8(a) to 8(e) are R/o Village Kevra, P.S. Bhaiyathan,
Tahsil Surajpur, Distt. Surguja (C.G.)
9. Shivadheen, S/o Sonsai, aged about 36 years.
S.A.No.65/2003
Page 2 of 16
Appellant No.6, 7 and 9 are R/o Village Kevra, Police Station
Bhaiyathan, Tahsil Surajpur, Distt. Surguja (C.G.)
10. Raimat (Dead) Through LR
(a) Shivnath, S/o late Nanka Ram, aged about 52 years, R/o
Karkoti, Bhaiyathan, Tahsil Bhaiyathan, District Surajpur (C.G.)
11.Rameshwar, S/o Bhagirathi, aged about 28 years.
(Plaintiffs)
---- Appellants
Versus
1. Radheshyam Gupta (Dead) Through LRs
(a) Urmila Gupta, widow of late Radhey Shyam Gupta, aged about
51 years,
(b) Anand Gupta, S/o late Radhey Shyam Gupta, aged about 30
years,
(c) Vishudhyanand. S/o late Radhey Shyam Gupta, aged about 27
years,
All R/o Village Manendragarh Road, Surajpur, District Surajpur
(C.G.)
2. State of Chhattisgarh, through Collector, Surguja, Ambikapur (C.G.)
3. C.P. Baghel (Nayab Tahsildar) (Deleted)
(Defendants)
---- Respondents
For Appellants:
Mr. Ashok Kumar Shukla and Mr. Atanu Ghosh,
Advocates.
For Respondents No.1(a) to (c): -
Mr. H.B. Agrawal, Senior Advocate with Mrs. Prabha
Sharma, Advocate.
For Respondent No.2 / State:-
Mrs. Meha Kumar, Panel Lawyer.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal
C.A.V. Judgment
1. This plaintiffs' second appeal was admitted for hearing on the
following substantial question of law: -
“Whether the Courts below were justified in holding that
the plaintiffs are not entitled to get the alleged registered
S.A.No.65/2003
Page 3 of 16
deed of sale, dated 29.10.1975 (Exhibit D/1) as null and
void as its executor Chunnilal has failed to assail the
same during his lifetime despite knowing the fact that it
was not validly executed?”
(Parties hereinafter will be referred as per their status shown
and ranking given in the plaint before the trial Court.)
2. The suit property was originally held by Jaina. He had two sons
and one daughter namely Sonsai, Chunnilal and Nanki,
respectively. Chunnilal executed sale deed dated 29-10-1975 in
favour of defendant No.1 and died on 22-1-1976. The original
plaintiff was Sonsai (died during the pendency of suit). He had filed
suit for setting aside the sale deed executed by Chunnilal in favour
of defendant No.1 on the ground that the sale deed was obtained
by fraud, as Chunnilal was taken for treatment and got the sale
deed executed fraudulently. Defendant No.1 filed his written
statement denying and opposing the plaint allegations and stated
that the sale deed was executed for legal necessity and it is in
accordance with law. The t