Advocates:
['M/S EVENTA A GONSALVES', 'THE ADDL GOVT PLEADER', '', 'NO', 'SHRI Y R NAIK', 'FOR R', 'NOS &', 'SHRI ANIL DIWAN', 'SHRI C J SAWANT WITH', 'SHRI A M BAGLA']

:1:

IN

THE

HIGH

COURT

OF

JUDICATURE

AT

BOMBAY

CIVIL

APPELLATE

JURISDICTION

WRIT

WRIT

WRIT

PETITION

NO.

6205

OF

1996

PETITION

NO.

6205

OF

1996

PETITION

NO.

6205

OF

1996

WITH

WITH

WITH

CIVIL

CIVIL

CIVIL

APPLICATION

APPLICATION

APPLICATION

NO.

7624

OF

1996

NO.

7624

OF

1996

NO.

7624

OF

1996

M/s. Union Industires & anr. .. Petitioners

Vs.

The State of Maharashtra & Ors. .. Respondents

WITH

WITH

WITH

WRIT

WRIT

WRIT PETITION NO. 6206 OF 1996

PETITION NO. 6206 OF 1996

PETITION NO. 6206 OF 1996

WITH

WITH

WITH

CIVIL

CIVIL

CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7626 OF 1996

APPLICATION NO. 7626 OF 1996

APPLICATION NO. 7626 OF 1996

Liberty Oil Mills Ltd. and anr. .. Petitioners

Vs.

The State of Maharashtra & Ors. .. Respondents

WITH

WITH

WITH

WIRT

WIRT

WIRT PETITION NO. 6305 OF 1996

PETITION NO. 6305 OF 1996

PETITION NO. 6305 OF 1996

G.B.K. Exports Ltd. and anr. .. Petitioners

Vs.

The State of Maharashtra & Ors. .. Respondents

WITH

WITH

WITH

WRIT

WRIT

WRIT PETITION NO. 6306 OF 1996

PETITION NO. 6306 OF 1996

PETITION NO. 6306 OF 1996

WITH

WITH

WITH

CIVIL

CIVIL

CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7757 OF 1996

APPLICATION NO. 7757 OF 1996

APPLICATION NO. 7757 OF 1996

Lanyard Foods Ltd. and anr. .. Petitioners

Vs.

The State of Maharashtra and ors. .. Respondents

WITH

WITH

WITH

WRIT

WRIT

WRIT PETITION NO. 6315 OF 1996

PETITION NO. 6315 OF 1996

PETITION NO. 6315 OF 1996

WITH

WITH

WITH

CIVIL

CIVIL

CIVIL APPLICATION NO.7786 OF 1996

APPLICATION NO.7786 OF 1996

APPLICATION NO.7786 OF 1996

Ruchi Soya Industries Ltd. and anr. .. Petitioners

Vs.

:2:

The State of Maharashtra and ors. .. Respondents

Mr.

Hiralal

Thacker,

Senior

Advocate

with

Ms.

K.

Belgani i/by Ms. Eventa A. Gonsalves for the

petitioners in all the above matters.

Mr. P.M. Patil, AGP for respondent no.1 in all the

above matters.

Mr.

K.K.

Singhavi,

Senior.

Advocate

with

Mr.

Y.R.

Naik with Mr. Prashant Naik for respondent nos.2 and

3.

WITH

WITH

WITH

WRIT

WRIT

WRIT PETITION NO. 1243 OF 2002

PETITION NO. 1243 OF 2002

PETITION NO. 1243 OF 2002

The Bombay Sugar Merchants

Association & Anr ..Petitioners

Vs.

The State of Maharashtra and ors. .. Respondents

Mr. C.M. Korde with Mr. V.B. Naik for petitioners.

Mr. P.M. Patil, AGP for respondent nos.1 and 2.

Mr. Y.R. Naik for respondent no.3.

WITH

WITH

WITH

WRIT

WRIT

WRIT PETITION NO. 4743 OF 1998

PETITION NO. 4743 OF 1998

PETITION NO. 4743 OF 1998

WITH

WITH

WITH

CIVIL

CIVIL

CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 553 OF 2002

APPLICATION NO. 553 OF 2002

APPLICATION NO. 553 OF 2002

M/s. B.S.I. Ltd.

..Petitioner

Vs.

The State of Maharashtra and ors.

..Respondents

Mr. R.G. Ketkar for petitioner.

Mr. P.M. Patil, AGP for respondent nos.1,3 & 4.

Mr. K.K. Singhavi, Senior Advocate with Mr. Y.R.

Naik with Mr. Prashant Naik for respondent no.2.

WITH

WITH

WITH

WIRT

WIRT

WIRT PETITION NO. 6801 OF 2000

PETITION NO. 6801 OF 2000

PETITION NO. 6801 OF 2000

M/s. Veesha International & Ors.

..Petitioners

Vs.

Mumbai Agricultural Produce

Market Committee & Ors.

..Respondents

Mr. Ranjit R. Bhosale i/b M/s. Mulla & Mulla and

C.B.C. for petitioner.

:3:

Mr. N.N. Bhadrashete for respondent no.1.

Mr. P.M. Patil, AGP for respondent nos.2 to 4.

CORAM:

CORAM:

CORAM: B.H. MARLAPALLE &

B.H. MARLAPALLE &

B.H. MARLAPALLE &

D.B.

D.B.

D.B. BHOSALE,JJ.

BHOSALE,JJ.

BHOSALE,JJ.

Dated: June 16, 2006.

P.C.:

P.C.:

P.C.:-

1.

In view of our Judgments in Writ Petition

Nos.1072/91

(OS),

3278/91

(OS),

6270/96

(AS),

353/98

(OS) and 1341/98 (OS) rendered today and for the

reasons stated therein we hold that,

(a)

Vanaspati,

refined

edible

oil

or

edible

oil,

sugar,

cashew

nuts

and