HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
KUNJAR BROTHERS CONTRACTORS PVT LTD THR DIRECTOR – Appellant
Versus
KIRTIVARDHAN BAPUSAHEB LALIKAR – Respondent
WP 7134/2012
1 W.P. 7134.2012
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET No
.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 7134 OF 2012
Kunjar Brothers Contractors Pvt. Ltd. Thr. Director V/s Kirtivardhan Bapusaheb Lalikar
Office Notes,Office
Memoranda
of
Coram,appearances,
Court's orders or
directions
and
Registrar's orders
Court's or Judge's orders
................................
CORAM : S.V.GANGAPURWALA, J.
DATE : 28/08/2012.
Mr.S.V.Adwant, Advocate for the Petitioner.
..........................
.
PER COURT :
1.
The present respondent/plaintiff filed Suit for specific
performance of contract on the ground that the present
petitioner/defendant has executed agreement of sale in favour
of the respondent on 08/09/2009. The Suit was filed on
01/09/2009. It appears that during the pendency of the Suit,
the present petitioner had executed a registered conveyance in
favour of the third party on or about 05/10/2010. The present
respondent/plaintiff filed an application to implead the said
2 W.P. 7134.2012
purchaser as a party. The said application is allowed.
Aggrieved thereby the original defendant had filed present Writ
Petition.
2.
Mr. Adwant, learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the proposed party is not a party to the agreement, of
which the specific performance is sought. His presence is not
relevant. The scope of the Suit is about the agreement, its
terms and its enforceability. The proposed party is no way
concerned with the same and such a party can not be allowed
to be impleaded. The learned counsel relies on the Judgment
of the Apex Court in the case of Bharat Karsondas Thakkar
V/s Kiran Construction Company and others reported in
(2008) 13 Supreme Court Cases – 658 and another Judgment
of the Apex Court in the case of Ramesh Chandra Pattnaik
V/s Pushpendra Kumari and others reported in (2008) 10
Supreme Court Cases – 708.
3.
The learned counsel also relies on the Judgment of the
Division Bench of this Court in the case of Suresh M. Jain &
Anr. V/s Daruwala Wadi Cooperative housing Society Ltd.
& Ors. Reported in 2006 (12) LJSOFT – 303.
4.
According to the learned counsel, when the proposed
party is not necessary nor proper party, it was an error on the
3 W.P. 7134.2012
part of the trial Court to invoke its power under Order I – 10
(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure [ For short, ‘ the Code ’ ].
The impugned order suffers from jurisdictional error.
5.
With the assistance of the learned counsel, I have gone
through the order.
6.
The Suit is filed by the present respondent for specific
performance of contract, so also, seeks an injunction that no
third party interest should be created. As per the contention of
the present respondent, the present petitioner has transferred
the suit property during the pendency of the Suit vide
conveyance dated 05/10/2010. It is in this premise, the
application is filed for adding the subsequent purchaser as a
party.
7.
No doubt, the enquiry in the Suit would be regarding the
agreement, its contents, its enforceability, so also the readyness
and willingness of the plaintiff.
8.
At the same time, it can not be lost sight that the title is
passed in favour of the subsequent purchaser. As per Section
52 of the Transfer of Property Act, the Judgment and Decree
passed by the Court would bind the subsequent purch