HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
VISHNUDAS VITHOBA MALE – Appellant
Versus
SUKHDEO BAJIRAO SALUNKE – Respondent
SA 627/2014
['DESHPANDE C R', 'SHRI P M SHINDE', '', 'CVTR']
1 S.A. 627....2014 - [ J ]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
SECOND APPEAL NO. 627 OF 2014
WITH
SECOND APPEAL NO. 628 OF 2014
Vishnudas S/o Vithoba Male
Age : 51 Yrs., Occ. : Agril.,
R/o : Salunkwadi, Taluka :
….. APPELLANT/
Ambajogai, Dist. : Beed.
[ORIGINAL PLAINTIFF]
V E R S U S
Sukhdeo S/o Bajirao Salunke
Age : 60 Yrs., Occ. : Agril.,
R/o : Salunkwadi, Taluka :
….. RESPONDENT/
Ambajogai, Dist. : Beed.
[ORIGINAL DEFENDANT]
.............................
Mr. C.R.Deshpande, Advocate for the Appellant
Mr. N.B.Khandare, Advocate i/b Mr. P.M.Shinde,
Advocate for the Respondent.
..............................
CORAM : R.G.KETKAR, J.
DATE OF JUDGMENT : 9th DECEMBER, 2014
.............................
2 S.A. 627....2014 - [ J ]
ORAL JUDGMENT :
1.
Heard Mr. C.R.Deshpande, learned counsel for
the appellant and Mr. N.B.Khandare, learned counsel for the
respondent at length.
2.
Second Appeal No. 627 of 2014 is preferred by
the original plaintiff, whereby his claim for specific
performance is dismissed by the Courts below. Second
Appeal No. 628 of 2014 is also preferred by the original
plaintiff, by which the counter claim set out by the
respondent herein – DEFENDANT for cancellation of
registered agreement of sale dated 22/05/1986 and for
handing over possession was allowed. The parties shall
herein after be referred to as per their status before the trial
Court.
3.
The appellant instituted Special Civil Suit No.
32/1998, which was subsequently renumbered as R.C.S. No.
217/2013 for specific performance of agreement dated
22/05/1986. It is the case of the plaintiff that the
defendant agreed to sell land admeasuring 4 Acres from
3 S.A. 627....2014 - [ J ]
northern side of G.No. 83 in all admeasuring 7 Acres 36
gunthas situate at Salunkwadi, Taluka Ambajogai, District
Beed (for short, ' suit property ' ). The defendant executed
registered agreement on 22/05/1986 and the total
consideration agreed between the parties was ` 40,000/-
(Rupees Forty Thousand only ). Out of that, plaintiff paid
` 15,000/- (Rupees Fifteen Thousand only ) in the presence
of Sub Registrar on the same day and balance consideration
of ` 25,000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand only ) was to
be paid at the time of execution of sale deed (
चैतर शु.
१ शके
१९०९). The agreement further recited that in case the
plaintiff fails to pay the balance consideration and get the
sale deed registered, the defendant reserved his right to
cancel the agreement. The defendant further agreed to get
the land measured to the extent of 4 Acres agreed to be
purchased by the plaintiff and till such time the land is not
measured, time for execution of the sale deed would be
extended. In pursuance of the agreement, plaintiff was put
in possession of the suit land.
4.
It is the case of the plaintiff that the defendant
did not get the land measured and, therefore, transaction was
4 S.A. 627....2014 - [ J ]
not completed in time. The plaintiff further contended that
the defendant had approached him and received amount of
` 6,000/- (Rupees Six Thousand only ) on 13/08/1988 and
` 5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand only ) on 26/02/1989 for
education of children and marriages of daughters. Besid