HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
ABDUL RAUF MOHAMMED KHAJA – Appellant
Versus
THE GOVERNMENT OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH THE SECRETARY MUMBAI AND OTHERS – Respondent
WP 2352/2018
['KURUNDKAR SUNIL V', 'COPY SERVED ON GP', '', 'GP']
1 wp_2352.18.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 2352 OF 2018
Abdul Rauf Mohammed Khaja,
Age : 54 years, Occu. : Service as a
Peon in Collector Office Nanded,
R/o Itwara Machi Market,
Nanded.
.. Petitioner
Versus
1.
The State of Maharashtra,
Through the Secretary,
Revenue Department,
Mantralaya, Mumbai 400 032.
2.
The Divisional Commissioner
Office, Aurangabad.
3.
The District Collector,
Nanded.
.. Respondents
Shri Sunil V. Kurundkar, Advocate for the Petitioner.
Shri K. N. Lokhande, A.G.P. for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3.
CORAM :
MANGESH S. PATIL AND
SANDEEP V. MARNE, JJ.
CLOSED FOR JUDGMENT ON
:
04.10.2022
JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON :
14.10.2022
JUDGMENT (Per Sandeep V. Marne, J.) :-
.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. With the consent
of parties taken up for final hearing.
2.
By the present petition, the petitioner assails judgment
and order dated 16.08.2017 passed by the Maharashtra
2 wp_2352.18.odt
Administrative Tribunal, Bench at Aurangabad (for short
“Tribunal”) in Original Application No. 482 of 2015. Before the
Tribunal, the petitioner had challenged (i) order passed by the
Disciplinary Authority dated 15.12.2008 imposing the penalty of
reduction to the minimum pay scale (ii) order dated 23.09.2010
passed by the Appellate Authority modifying the penalty to that
of reduction to the minimum of the pay scale permanently and
(iii) order dated 03.03.2015 rejecting the revision petition. By
the judgment and order impugned in the present petition, the
Tribunal has proceeded to dismiss the original application.
3.
We must note at the outset that the Tribunal has
erroneously observed in para No. 2 of the judgment that the
petitioner was challenging the order of dismissal from service. By
order dated 15.12.2008, the disciplinary authority had imposed
penalty of reduction to the minimum of the pay scale without
specifying any period. The appellate authority while rejecting
the appeal by order dated 23.09.2010 directed that the reduction
to the minimum of the pay scale would be on permanent basis.
This is the ultimate penalty which was the subject matter of
challenge before the Tribunal.
4.
While working as a Peon (Watchman), disciplinary
proceedings were initiated against the petitioner vide
memorandum of charge sheet dated 02.02.2005 on the charge
that he had turned hostile during the trial in Sessions Case No.
10 of 2004 against another peon Shri Sayed Alim S/o Sayyed
Mohiuddin, which led to his acquittal. Based on findings
recorded by the Sessions Judge while acquitting the accused, the
petitioner was charged with the misconduct of turning hostile
3 wp_2352.18.odt
and aforesaid penalty came to be imposed on him after being
found guilty in the disciplinary enquiry. The Tribunal has
dismissed the original application of the petitioner holding him
responsible for acquittal of the accused. It is held by the
Tribunal that the petitioner had never claimed that his earlier
statement before the Special Judicial Magistrate Nanded was
given under coercion and that therefore, he was not justified in
turning hostile.
5.
Appearing for the petitioner Mr. Kurundkar, the learned
counsel would submit that initiation of disciplinary proceedings
against the petitioner was flawed as mere giving of testimony
before the Sessions Judge cannot amount to misconduct. He
would submit that the findings recorded by the Sessions Judge
would indicate that the statement of the petitioner recorded by
the Special Judicial Magistrate Nanded was not in accordance
with the procedure prescribed by law. He would further submit
that his testimony alone has not resulted in acquittal of the
accused. He therefore prays for setting aside the order of the
Tribunal.
6.
Per contra, Mr. Lokhande, learne