Advocates:
['ADV ABHIJEET KAMAT', 'ADV PRASHEEN LOTLIKAR', '', 'ADV VISSILI LEWIN BRAGANZA']

1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA.

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 49 OF 2013

AND

CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 156 OF 2013

IN

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 49 OF 2013.

1

Mr. Jyotin Chopra, son of

Mr. A. D. Chopra, age 44

years, businessman, Indian

National, resident of S-100,

Pansheel Park, New Delhi-

110017.

2

Mr. Romy Singh, Son of Mr.

Ishwar Singh, 55 years of age,

businessman, Indian National,

resident of 73, Anand Lok,

New Delhi herein represented

by his duly authorized P.O.A.

holder Plaintiff no.1.

....

Appellants.

V/s

1

Mr.

Aleixo

Domingos

Fernandes, alias Alex Dominic

Fernandes

alias

Domnic

Fernandes, Son of late Mr.

Celestino John Fernandes, 67

years of age, and his wife,

2

Mrs. Theresa Mendes alias

Tereza

Fernandes

alias

Theresa Fernandes, 58 years

of age, Both Indian Nationals,

and residents of Shalini

Apartments, Flat no.7, Vikas

Nagar, Wanorie, Pune-411040.

2

3

Mrs.

Maria

Felismina

Fernandes, alias Filomena

Mascarenhas, alias Felismina

Mascarenhas, Daughter of late

Mr. Celestino John Fernandes,

Wife of late Antonio Simao

Mascarenhas alias Simon

Mascarenhas, 76 years of age,

Indian National, resident of

2000, St. Vencent Street

Camp, Pune-411001.

4

Mr. Pascal Bruno Mascarenhas

alias Mr. Pascal Simon Bruno

Mascarenhas, Son of late

Antonio Simao Mascarenhas,

alias Simon Mascarenhas, 48

years of age, and his wife

5

Mrs. Clementine Moriais alias

Clementine Mascarenhas alias

Clementina Mascarenhas, 44

years of age, Both Indian

Nationals, and residents of

Flat no.98, building no. A-3, A

wing, Ravi Park, Wanwari,

Pune-411040.

6

Mr.

Savio

Domnic

Mascarenhas

alias

Savio

Mascarenhas, Son of late

Antonio Simao Mascarenhas

alias Simon Mascarenhas, 47

years of age, and his wife

7

Mrs. Sangeeta Maria Dutta

alias

Sangeeta

Maria

Mascarenhas alias Maria S.

Mascarenhas, Wife of Mr.

Savio Domnic Mascarenhas,

37 years of age, Both Indian

Nationals, and residents of

Flat no. 2, Natraj, S. No.27,

Kondhwa, Pune 411048.

3

8

Mrs. Maria Gonsalves alias

Rosemary Fernandes, Widow,

wife of late Mr. Bruno

Fernandes, alias Lourenco

Bruno Fernandes, 62 years of

age, and her son

9

Mr. Ryan Camilo Fernandes,

Son

of

late

Mr.Bruno

Fernandes, alias Lourenco

Bruno Fernandes 24 years of

age, Both Indian Nationals,

and residents of Flat no. A-12,

Bakau Wolf Housing Society,

Kharalwadi, Pmpri, Pune-

411018.

10

Mrs. Juliana Gomes alias

Juliana Nee Julia Gomes alias,

Julie Martins alias Juliedenis

Martins, Daughter of late Jose

Gomes, Niece of late Ana

Eugenia Menezes 62 years of

age, residing at 3, Topaz CHS

Ltd., Kalina village road,

Kalina, St.Cruz(E), Mumbai

400029,

11

Mrs. Maria Eufemia Conceicao

Gomes alias Maria Eufemia

Conceicao Grao alias Maria

Grao alias Maria Eufemia

Gomes, Daughter of late Jose

Gomes, Niece of late Ana

Eugenia Menezes, 60 years of

age, resident of 21/2A, Green

Park, CHS Ltd., Link road,

Malad West, Mumbai 400064.

12

Mr. Dexter Savio De Souza,

resident of H.No.1/133 A,

Major of age, Gaura Vaddo,

Calangute, Bardez, Goa.

…..

Respondents.

4

Mr. S. S. Kantak, Senior Advocate with Mr. P. Talaulikar,

Advocate for the appellants.

Mr. M. B. D'Costa, Senior Advocate with Ms. K. Betquekar,

Advocate for the respondents no. 1 to 9.

Mr. S. D. Lotlikar, Senior Advocate with Mr. C. Padgaonkar,

Advocate for the respondent no. 12.

Mr. D. Vernekar, Advocate for respondents no. 10 and 11.

CORAM :- U. V. BAKRE, J.

Reserved on: 20^th November, 2013.

Pronounced on: 25^th November, 2013.

JUDGMENT :-

Heard Mr. Kantak, learned Senior Counsel

appearing on behalf of the appellants, Mr. D'Costa, learned

Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents no. 1 to

9, Mr. Lotlikar, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of

the r