Advocates:
['ADV JAGANNATH JAYANT MULGAONKAR', '', 'ADV JAYANT PANDURANG MULGAONKAR', 'ADV GAJENDRA USGAONKAR', '', '', '']

1 WP522/13

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA

WRIT PETITION NO. 522 OF 2013

1

REGINALD BAPTIST LOBO,

r/o. H. No. 1, Vaddem,

Socorro, Bardez, Goa.

2

MR. AGNELO CARIDADE LOBO,

3

MRS. DITOSA LOBO,

Both r/o. H. No. 1,

Vaddem, Socorro, Bardez,

Goa

4

MRS. AURORA LOBO,

r/o. H. No. 1, Vaddem,

Socorro, Bardez, Goa.

…....

Petitioners.

Versus

1

SHRI ROBERT D'SOUZA,

2

SMT. ROZY D'SOUZA,

Both r/o. H. No. 81, Near

Vaddem Ground, Vaddem,

Bardez, Goa.

3

BOSCO GONSALVES,

4

CARMELINA GONSALVES,

Both r/o Near Janata

Bakery, Vasco, Goa.

5

LUIS ANTON SALVADOR LOBO,

R/o. Vaddem, Socorro, Bardez,

Goa.

6

MRS. MARY ANN AFONSO,

major, widow,

7

SIMON AFONSO,

8

DARRYL AFONSO,

All r/at 17, Rosary

Building, Station Road,

Mahim, Mumbai – 16.

9

MRS. ROMINA AFONSO,

2 WP522/13

R/o Cobra Vaddo, Calangute,

Bardez, Goa.

10

MRS. SABINA AFONSO,

11

MISS LOURDES AFONSO,

12

MISS AVITA AFONSO,

All r/at Baman Vaddo, Siolim,

Bardez, Goa.

13

MRS. REMDIANA e LOBO

(EXPIRED)

14

MRS. LOURDINE RODRIGUES,

15

MR. NOEL RODRIGUES,

16

MR. EDWIN RODRIGUES,

All r/at Siolim, Bardez, Goa.

17

MR.

MICHAEL

LUCIANO

RODRIGUES,

18

MR. ZICO RODRIGUES,

19

MR. JONATHAN RODRIGUES,

All r/at 17, Rosary Building,

Station Road, Mahim, Mumbai

-16.

20

MR. RONNIE RODRIGUES,

21

MRS. RUFINA RODRIGUES,

All r/at Feira Alta, Marvaddo,

Alcon Construction, Mapusa,

Bardez, Goa.

22

MRS.

MARTHA

FELICIDADE

MIRINDA,

23

MR. PETER MIRANDA

Both r/at Dollars Colony, Antop

Hill, Wadala, Mumbai.

24

MRS.

LAZARINA

BELLA

FERNANDES,

25

JOSEPH

C.

FERNANDES

(EXPIRED),

Both r/at Royal Apartments,

Ahmedabad, Khanpur, Gujarat.

26

MRS. CARMELINA GONSALVES,

27

MR. BOSCO GONSALVES

Both r/at Near Janata Bakery,

Vasco-da-Gama.

3 WP522/13

28

MR. LUIS ANTONIO SALVADOR

LOBO (deleted)

29

MRS. MEERA LOBO,

r/o Night Queen Bar, Near Old

Market, Vasco,Goa.

….......

RESPONDENTS.

Mr. J. P. Mulgaonkar, Advocate for the petitioners.

Mr. G. Usgaonkar, Advocate for the respondents no. 1, 2, 4 and 5.

Respondent no. 3 absent.

CORAM : U. V. BAKRE, J.

RESERVED ON : 17TH JANUARY, 2014.

PRONOUNCED ON : 28TH JANUARY, 2014.

JUDGMENT :

Heard Mr. Mulgaonkar, learned Counsel appearing on behalf

of the petitioners and Mr. Usgaonkar, learned Counsel appearing on

behalf of the respondents no. 1, 2, 4 and 5.

2.

By this Petition, the petitioners have challenged the order

dated 14/02/2013 passed by the learned District Judge – I, North Goa

at Panaji (First Appellate Court) in Miscellaneous Civil Appeal No. 185

of 2010.

3. Inventory Proceedings no. 47/1997/B for partitioning the

estate of the deceased Reginaldo Baptist Lobo and his wife Felicidade

Fernandes, were instituted in the Court of learned Civil Judge, Senior

Division, Mapusa (Trial Court), by their son Shri Vitorino Jose Mariano

4 WP522/13

Lobo, since deceased. Prior to the impugned order, the petitioner no.

1 was the Cabeca de casal (administrator) in the said Inventory

proceedings whereas as the other petitioners and the respondents

were the interested parties. In the course of the proceedings, Cabeca

de Casal listed certain properties as belonging to the deceased grand

parents. The respondents no. 1 to 5 raised objections alleging that

none of the properties listed in the list of assets belong to the estate-

leavers and that the properties at serial nos. 1 to 5 belong to the

estate of late Aleixo Mariano Lobo and his wife Luizinha Inaci