1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA

WRIT PETITIONS NO.506, 557 AND 577 OF 2009 AND

657/2011

WRIT PETITION NO.506/2009

1)

Marvin S. Gonsalves;

2)

Noel Monteiro;

3)

Casiano Menino D'Souza;

All residents of C/o

Benny D'Souza, Bambolim

Church Road, P.O. Medical

Complex, Ilhas – Goa – 403 202.

4)

Joao Manual Peixoto

resident of Cardoz Vaddo,

Taleigao, P.O. Caranzalem,

Ilhas – Goa- 403 003.

(REGISTERED ADDRESSES)

… Petitioners.

VERSUS

1)

State of Goa, through the

Chief Secretary, Alto

Porvorim, Bardez – Goa.

2)

The Administrator of

Communidades, Central

Zone, Panaji – Goa.

3)

Shri Anand Gaunso,

s/o late Raju Ishwar

Gaunso, major, married,

employed at Canara Bank,

St. Cruz Branch, St.

Cruz, Tiswadi – Goa.

4)

Mrs. Deinisis Dias e

Mergulhao, w/o late Maximo

2

Mergyulhao,

Model Residency, First

Floor, St. Inez,

Panaji – Goa.

5)

M/s. Raghurai Tamba, a

Registered Partnership

Firm, having its office

at 'Parimal', Altinho,

Panaji – Goa, through its

Partner, Shri Raghurai

Tamba.

6)

Shri Pascol Trinidade,

Director, Aldeia de Goa,

next to Goa University,

P.O. Goa University,

Bambolim -Goa- 403 206.

7)

Communidade of Bambolim,

by its Special Power of

Attorney, Shri Jeronimo

Manuel Monteiro, resident

of Bambolim Church Road,

P.O. Medical Complex,

Ilhas – Goa- 403 202.

8)

Pundalik Cuncolkar, s/o

late Parshuram Cuncolkar,

major, married, service;

and his wife,

9)

Sumati Pundalik Cuncolkar,

major, service,

Both residents of Palem,

Siridao, Tiswadi – Goa.

10)

Ganga alias Shobha Vasudev

Narvekar, w/o late Vasudev

Narvekar, major, daughter

of late Parshuram

Cuncolkar, married,

housewife;

3

11)

Mamtha Vasudev Narvekar,

d/o late Vasudev Narvekar,

major, unmarried, Service,

Both residents of Goa

Velha, Tiswadi- Goa.

12)

Kensar Manuel Pereira

alias Kunkolikar, wife

of Manuel Pereira,

d/o late Parshuram

Cuncolkar, major,

Married, housewife;

13)

Manuel Pereira, s/o late

Joaquim Pereira, major in

age, married, service,

Both residents of Cacra,

St. Cruz, Ilhas – Goa.

14)

Mrs. Rukmini Bhikaro Gauns

Gomes, w/o late Bhikaro

Gauns alias Gomes, major,

housewife, resident of Modlowado,

Siridao, Palem,

Tiswadi – Goa.

15)

Geeta Prakash Narvekar,

w/o. Prakash Narvekar,

d/o late Bhikaro Gauns

alias Gomes, major;

16)

Prakash Narvekar, major

in age, married,

Government Servant,

Indian National,

Both residents of Taleigao,

Tiswadi – Goa.

17)

Chandrika Bhikaro Gauns

alias Gomes alias Lotlikar,

d/o late Bhikaro Gauns

alias Gomes, major,

4

resident of Modlowado,

Siridao, Palem, Tiswadi – Goa.

18)

Mr. Madhu Cuncolkar alias

Cuncolkar alias Cancolkar,

s/o Laximan Cuncolkar,

major, service;

19)

Mrs. Succorina Madhu

Cuncolkar alias Cancolkar

alias Manisha Madhu

Cuncolkar alias Cancolar, major,

housewife,

Both residents of Modlowado,

Siridao, Palem, Tiswadi,

Goa.

20)

Mr. Rama Gomes alias

Lotlikar, s/o Sebastiao

Gomes, major, service;

21)

Smt. Sita Rama Gomes alias

Lotlikar, housewife,

Both residents of Palem,

Siridao, Tiswadi-Goa.

… Respondents.

Mr. Rohit Bras De Sa, Advocate for the Petitioners.

Mr. P. Talaulikar, Additional Government Advocate for

Respondent no.1.

Mr. V. A. Lawande, Advocate for Respondent no.2.

Mr. A.N.S. Nadkarni, Senior Advocate with Mr. D. Lawande,

Advocate for Respondents No.5 and 6.

WITH

WRIT PETITION 557/2009

1.

Marvin S. Gonsalves

2.

Noel Monteiro

5

3.

Casioano Menino D'Souza

C/o Benny D'Souza

All residents of Bambolim

Church road, P.O.

Medical Complex, Ilhas-

Goa- 403202

4.

Joao Manuel Peixoto

Taleigao, Cardoz Vaddo

P.O. Caranzalem

Ilhas-Goa-403003

..

PETITIONERS

Versus

1.

State of Goa

Through the Chief Secretary

Alto Porvorim, Bardez, Goa.

2.

The Administrator of

Communidade, North Goa,

Panaji, Goa.

3.

M/s. Raghurai Tamba,

A registered partnership firm

Having its Office at

“Parimal”, Altino,

Panaji-Goa Through its

Partner Shri Raghurai Tamba

4.

Shri Pascol Trinidade,

Director, Aldeia de Goa,

Next to Goa University,

P.O. Goa University,

Bambolim, Goa- 403206.

5.

Shri Sebastiao J. Botelho,

Resident o