HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
STATE TH.CHIEF SECY – Appellant
Versus
VINNY CHAWLA AND ORS – Respondent
APCIV 61/2018
['KARMAN SINGH JOHAL', 'ROHIT KAPOOR', 'AAG', '', 'K S JOHAL SR ADV']
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR
AT JAMMU
Pronounced On: 06/04/2021.
IA no. 01/2018
APCIV No. 61/2018
State of J&K through Chief Secretary
…..Petitioner(s)/Applicant(s)
Through: -
Mr. Ayjaz Lone, Dy.AG.
V/s
Vinnay Chawla and Ors.
…..Respondent(s)
Through: -
Mr.K. S. Johal, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Karman Singh Johal, Advocate.
CORAM:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Javed Iqbal Wani, Judge.
JUDGEMENT
1.
This order shall dispose of the instant application being filed by the
applicant under Section 151 Cr.PC for recalling of order dated
30.12.2017 where under restoration application being 05/2017 filed
for re-admission of appeal bearing No. 25/2011 had been dismissed.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
3.
Learned counsel for the parties reiterated their submissions in tune
with their respective pleadings.
4.
While learned counsel for the applicant prayed for recalling of the
order dated 30.12.2017,on the grounds urged in the application, the
counsel for the non-applicant insisted for dismissal of the application
inter-alia amongst others, fundamentally on the ground that the
application is not maintainable.
5.
Before adverting to the application in hand ,a brief resume of the case
which emerges from the record is that a first appeal had been filed by
Page 2 of 8
IA no. 01/2018
APCIV No. 61/2018
the applicant herein against the judgement and decree passed by the
court of District Judge Samba in File No. 50/Samba dated 20.04.2009
in favour of respondents/non-applicants being CIA No. 25/2011.
6.
The said appeal had got dismissed for non-prosecution on12.07.2016.
The dismissal of the appeal resulted into filing of an application for
execution of the decree by the plaintiffs/respondents herein prompting
the appellant/applicant herein to file an application for re-admission of
the appeal being 05/2017. The said application being time bared had
been accompanied with an application for condonation of delay. The
said condonation of delay application had been allowed in terms of
order dated 06.06.2017 and restoration application directed to be
diarized.
7.
During the pendency of the said restoration application, MP No.
02/2017 is filed by the plaintiffs/non-applicants herein for
releaseRs.05 lacs of decreetal amount which had beendeposited by the
applicant herein before this court pursuant to an order dated
29.03.2017.
8.
The application for restoration supra had been dismissed by this court
for non-prosecution on 30.12.2017. The said order is sought to be
recalled through the medium of the instant application.
9.
On 23.05.2018 the date of issuance of notice in the application in
hand, decreetal amount deposited before this court by the applicant
herein was directed to be released in favour of the plaintiffs/non-
applicants herein subject to an undertaking that in case the applicant
herein succeeds in the appeal the amount so received by the non-
applicants herein shall be reimbursed with interest.
Page 3 of 8
IA no. 01/2018
APCIV No. 61/2018
10.
The inherent powerof this court under Section 151CPC is being
invoked in the instant application for the reasons detailed out
thereinwhich are extracted and reproduced in extenso along with
accompanied affidavit here under:
The applicant most respectfully submits as under:-
1.That the above titled execution petition was listed in the
Hon?ble Court for hearing on 12.03.2018. Through this
execution petition/application on 12.03.2018 for the First
time, appellant came to know that restoring application
filed for restoration of appeal has beendismissed for non-
prosecution. It may be specifically stated that the