1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 25^TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2020

PRESENT

THE HON’BLE Mr. JUSTICE ARAVIND KUMAR

AND

THE HON’BLE Mr. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR

R.F.A. No. 2094/2019

BETWEEN :

--------------

1.

Centre for Urban and Rural

Development

Having its office at No.181

Canara Bank Colony

Nagarabhavi Main Road

Bengaluru - 560 072.

Reptd. by its Managing Trustee

Sri. Chikkanagappa

S/o. Sri. Lingappa

Aged about 73 years.

2.

Sri. Chikkanagappa

S/o. Sri. Lingappa

Aged about 73 years

Managing Trustee of Centre

for Urban and Rural Development

No.181, Canara Bank Colony

Nagarabhavi Main Road

Bengaluru - 560 072.

2

3.

Smt. Sampangamma

W/o. Sri. Chikkanagappa

D/o. Sri. H. Muniyappa

Aged about 62 years

Trustee of Centre for Urban and

Rural Development

No.181, Canara Bank Colony

Nagarabhavi Main Road

Bengaluru - 560 072.

4.

Smt. C. Padmaja

D/o. Sri. Chikka Muniyappa

Aged about 41 years

Trustee of Centre for Urban

and Rural Development

R/at Konakunte Cross

Kanakapura Main Road

Bengaluru - 560 062.

5.

Sri. B. Suresh Kumar

S/o. Sri. Beeraiah

Aged about 38 years

(Present Trustee as per amended

Trust Deed dated 07.09.2009)

6.

Smt. B.V. Prathiba

Now aged about 26 years

W/o. Sri. Kiran Kumar

(Present Trustee as per amended

Trust Deed dated 07.09.2009)

… Appellants

(By Sri. Subba Shastry N, Adv.)

3

AND :

-------

1.

Sri. Rangaswamaiah

Now aged about 78 years

S/o. late Sri. Rangaiah

R/at No. 31, Varadenahalli Hand Post

Bachenahatti Post

Magadi Taluk-562 120

Ramanagara District.

Rep. by his GPA Holder

Sri. B.R. Shanmukha

S/o. Sri. Rangaswamaiah

Aged about 55 years

R/a. No. 3, 4^th Block

Behind CCB Office

Police Officers Quarters

Mysore Road

Bengaluru – 560 002.

Sri. Nalluraiah

(since dead represented by his LRs)

2.

Smt. Hanuma Rangamma

Aged about 60 years

W/o. Sri. Nagara

Bachenahatti Village and Post

Magadi Taluk - 562 120

Ramanagara District.

3.

Smt. Thimmakka

W/o. Sri. Muniyappa

Aged about 56 years

Gerupalya, Kumbalagodu Post

Kengeri Hobli

Bengaluru - 560 060.

4

4.

Smt. Shanthamma

W/o. Sri. Chikkarangaiah

Aged about 48 years

Surigenahalli Village

Gopalapura Post

Gubbi Taluk - 572 216

Tumkur District.

Sri.Nalluraiah

(Since dead by his LRs)

5.

Smt. Jayamma

W/o. late. Sri. Nalluraiah

Aged about 50 years

6.

Sri. Ramakrishna

S/o. late Sri. Nalluraiah

Aged about 35 years

7.

Sri. Keshava

S/o. late Sri. Nalluraiah

Aged about 30 years

8.

Sri. Suresh

S/o. late Sri. Nalluraiah

Aged about 28 years

Respondents No. 5 to 8 are

R/at Bachenahatti Village and Post

Magadi Taluk

Ramanagara District - 562 120.

9.

Sri. Gurumurthaiah

S/o. late Sri. Nalluraiah

Aged about 52 years

R/at Bachenahatti Village and Post

5

Magadi Taluk

Ramanagara District - 562 120.

10.

Sri. Ramakrishna

S/o. late Sri. Nalluraiah

Aged about 33 years

R/at Bachenahatti Village and Post

Magadi Taluk

Ramanagara District - 562 120.

11.

Sri. Keshava

S/o. late Sri. Nalluraiah

Aged about 30 years

R/at Bachenahatti Village and Post

Magadi Taluk

Ramanagara District - 562 120.

12.

Sri. Suresh

S/o. late Sri. Nalluraiah

Aged about 30 years

R/at Bachenahatti Village and Post

Magadi Taluk

Ramanagara District - 562 120.

13.

Sri. Hanumarangaiah

S/o. Sri. Gurumurthaiah

Aged about 28 years

R/at Bachenahatti Village and Post

Magadi Taluk

Ramanagara District - 562 120.

14.

Sri. Raghavendra

S/o. Sri. Gurumurthaiah

Aged about 26 years

R/at Bachenahatti Village and Post

Magadi Taluk

Ramanagara District-562 120.

6

15.

Sri. K.S. Nagaraj

S/o. Sri. K. Suryanarayana Rao

(Resigned as T