[2023/RJJP/000418]

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN

BENCH AT JAIPUR

D.B. Criminal Appeal No. 13/2021

Mahesh Paratha Son Of Khacher Singh, Resident Of Khati

Mohalla, Beenaganj, Police Station Chachoda, District Guna

(Madhya Pradesh) (At Present Confined In Open Jail,

Sanganer, Jaipur)

----Appellant

Versus

State Of Rajasthan, Through P.p.

----Respondent

For Appellant(s)

:

Mr. Vivek Goyal with

Mr. Ajay Singh Yadhuvanshi

For Respondent(s)

:

Mr. Javed Choudhary, AGA

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PANKAJ BHANDARI

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR UPMAN

Judgment

JUDGMENT RESERVED ON : 23/01/2023

DATE OF PRONOUNCEMENT : 02/O2/2023

(PER HON. ANIL KUMAR UPMAN)

1.

Challenge in this appeal is judgment and order dated

17.12.2008 passed by Additional Sessions Judge, Aklera,

District Jhalawar (hereinafter referred as trial court) in

Sessions case No.112/2008 arising out of FIR No.132/2008

registered at Police Station Manohar Thana, District Jhalawar

for the offences under Section 364, 376, 392 & 302 IPC.

Trial court recorded conviction of appellant for offence under

Section 302 IPC and sentenced to imprisonment for life along

[2023/RJJP/000418]

(2 of 10)

[CRLAD-13/2021]

with fine of Rs.60,000/- and in default of payment of fine, 6

months simple imprisonment was ordered further 6 months'

Simple Imprisonment was ordered. For the offence under

Section 364 IPC and sentence to R.I. 10 years and fine of

Rs.1,000/- and in default of payment of fine further 1

month's Simple Imprisonment was ordered. For the offence

under Section 201 IPC and sentence to 5 years R.I. and fine

of Rs.1,000/-. In default of payment of fine 1 month's

Simple Imprisonment was ordered. It was also ordered that

all the above sentence shall remain concurrently.

2.

The criminal proceedings were set on motion on the

basis of written report (Exhibit-PW-1) submitted by Banwari

Lal Sain (PW-2) to Ravindra Singh (PW-9) who was then

posted as SHO, Police Station Manohar Thana, District

Jhalawar.

3.

Written report Exhibit P-1 is being reproduced here as

under:-

lsokesa]

Jheku~ Fkkusnkj lk-

iqfyl Fkkuk euksgjFkkuk

fnukad 19@08@08

fo"k;%& izkFkhZ fd ifRu lqfe=k ckbZ dk vigj.k djds ,oa cykRdkj dj lksus pkanh ds

tsoj o udnh ywV dj gR;k djus ds lEcU/k esaA

ekU;oj]

fuosnu gS fd izkFkhZ 20 lky ls Hkouhe.Mh ifjokj lfgr jgdj egur etnwjh

djrk gaWwa fnukad 15@08@08 dks esjh iRuh lqfe=k ckbZ j{kk cU/ku dk R;kSgkj eukus ds

fy;s mlds figj VksMh Fkkuk pkpkSMk ftyk xquk e-iz- tkus ds fy;s Hkokuhe.Mh ls fnu ds

1 cts djhc jokuk gqbZ Fkh vksj 'kke dks N% cts ds djhc mlh fnu euksgj Fkkuk ls thi

ua- M.P. 04/8283 esa cSBdj chukxat ds fy;s jokuk gqbZ Fkh ftls thi esa cSBrs le;

o tkrs le; cnzhizlkn S/o eksgu yky tkfr ukbZ us ns[kk Fkk esjh iRuh us dkuks esa

lksus fd >qedh o xys esa ,d lksus dk eaxylq= o lksus fd pkj vxwBh;ka ,oa pkanh ds

[2023/RJJP/000418]

(3 of 10)

[CRLAD-13/2021]

250 xzke fd ik;tsc igus gq,s Fkh vkSj 1300@& udn FksA ftlds igqpus fd tkudkjh

esjs lkys lhrkjke VksMh okys us fn fd esjh cfgu lqfe=k ckbZ ;gkWa ugh igqph gSA blfd

tkap djokuk rks esa fnukad 17@08@08 dks Hkouhe.Mh ls jokuk gksdj euksgjFkkuk vk;k

,oa esjh iRuh lqfe=k ckbZ ds ckjs esa Nku chu o ryk'k fd rks irk pyk fd esjh iRuh

lqfe=k ckbZ egs'k ijkBk fuoklh pkpksMk ckys fd thi esa cSBdj tkuk ekywe iMk egs'k

ijkBk us gh esjh iRuh dk vigj.k] cykRdkj o ywVikV djds esjh iRuh fd gR;k djds

dgh taxy esa Nqik fn;k gSA fjiksVZ dk;Zokgh ,oa tkap gsrq Jheku~ fd lsok esa is'k gSA

izkFkhZ

cuokjh yky lsu

S/o lsu txUukFk th lsu

fuoklh Hkokuhe.Mh

P.S. Hkouhe.Mh

4.

On the basis of this written report (Exhibit-P-1) formal

FIR No.132/2008 (Exhibit-P2) was registered at Police

Station Manohar Thana, District Jhalawar for the offences

under Section 364, 376, 392 & 302 IPC. After investigation,

police submitted charge sheet before the concerned

Magistrate. Case was committed to the Court of Sessions.

Learned Sessions Judge entrusted this c