HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN

BENCH AT JAIPUR

S.B. Civil Second Appeal No. 64/2019

Bashir Mohd. S/o Ibrahim, R/o Baharli Bundi, District

Bundi (Raj.) Since Deceased Through-

1/1

Smt. Sultana Begam Widow Of Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli

Bundi, District Bundi (Raj.).

1/2

Shehzad Begam D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli Bundi,

District Bundi (Raj.).

1/3

Shamin Begam D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli Bundi,

District Bundi (Raj.).

1/4

Nasim Bano D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli Bundi, District

Bundi (Raj.).

1/5

Nazma D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli Bundi, District Bundi

(Raj.).

1/6

Aaysha Begam D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli Bundi,

District Bundi (Raj.).

1/7

Rubina D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli Bundi, District Bundi

(Raj.).

1/8

Mumtaz D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli Bundi, District

Bundi (Raj.).

1/9

Nasir Khan S/o Bashir Khan, R/o Baharli Bundi, District

Bundi (Raj.).

1/10

Tikka Khan S/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharli Bundi, District

Bundi (Raj.).

1/11

Yahiya Khan S/o Bashir Khan, R/o Baharli Bundi, District

Bundi (Raj.).

----Plaintiff-Appellants

Versus

1.

Regional

Manager,

Rajasthan

State

Industrial

Development And Investment Corporation Ltd.,

Indraprastha Industrial Area, Kota (Raj.)

2.

Managar, RIMDC Ltd., Jaipur Udyog Bhawan, Tilak Marg,

Jaipur (Raj.).

3.

Assistant Resident Engineer, REMDC Ltd. Indraprastha

Industrial Area, Kota (Raj.).

4.

Assistant Resident Engineer, RIMDC Ltd., Nainwa Road,

Bundi (Raj.).

(2 of 13)

[CSA-64/2019]

5.

Narendra Gupta S/o Chandmal, R/o New Colony, Kota

Road, Bundi (Raj.).

----Defendant-Respondents

Connected With

S.B. Civil Second Appeal No. 143/2019

Bashir Mohd. S/o Ibrahim, R/o Baharlibundi, District

Bundi (Raj) Since Deceased Through:

1/1

Smt. Sultana Begam Widow Of Bashir Mohd., R/o

Baharlibundi, District Bundi (Raj)

1/2

Shehzad Begam D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi,

District Bundi (Raj)

1/3

Shamim Begam D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi,

District Bundi (Raj)

1/4

Nasim Bano D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi, District

Bundi (Raj)

1/5

Nazma D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi, District Bundi

(Raj)

1/6

Aaysha Begam D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi,

District Bundi (Raj)

1/7

Rubina D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi, District Bundi

(Raj)

1/8

Mumtaz D/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi, District Bundi

(Raj)

1/9

Nasir Khan S/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi, District

Bundi (Raj)

1/10

Tikka Khan S/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi, District

Bundi (Raj)

1/11

Yahiya Khan S/o Bashir Mohd, R/o Baharlibundi, District

Bundi (Raj)

----Plaintiff-Appellants

Versus

1.

Regional

Manager,

Rajasthan

State

Industrial

Development And Investment Corporation Ltd.,

Indraprastha Industrial Area, Kota (Raj)

2.

Manager, RIMDC Ltd., Jaipur Udyog Bhawan, Tilak Marg,

Jaipur (Raj)

3.

Assistant Resident Engineer, RIMDC Ltd., Indraprastha

Industrial Area, Kota (Raj)

(3 of 13)

[CSA-64/2019]

4.

Assistant Resident Engineer, RIMDC Ltd., Nainwa Road,

Bundi (Raj)

5.

Narendra Gupta S/o Chandmal, Resident Of New Colony,

Kota Road, Bundi (Raj)

----Defendant-Respondents

For Appellant(s)

:

Mr. Rajendra Prasad, Sr. Advocate

assisted by Mr. Madhusudan, Adv.

For Respondent(s)

:

Mr. R.K. Agrawal, Sr. Advocate

assisted by Mr. Mamun Khalid, Adv.

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE GOVERDHAN BARDHAR

Judgment

Date of Pronouncement

::: February 15th, 2021

Since both the second appeals arise out of common

judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below, hence same

are being decided by a common Judgment.

The plaintiffs appellants by filing second Appeal No.

64/2019 have challenged the impugned judgment and decree

dated 08.01.2019 passed by the Court of Additional District Judge

No.1 Bundi (Raj.) [for short ‘the First Appellate Court’] in civil

Appeal No. 02/2011 (CIS No. 59/2014) whereby the first appellate

court dismissed the appeal filed by the plaintiffs appellants and

partly maintained the judgment and decree dated 20.11.20